6 ms·
Single sentence extract: > He goes to the counselling centre but instead of offering any help, they call my mom to come down and then at 5 p.m. that day, hold
by nailer 12y ago
Single sentence extract:
> He goes to the counselling centre but instead of offering any help, they call my mom to come down and then at 5 p.m. that day, hold a meeting with a dean and five other staff where they promptly dismiss my brother from William and Mary and ban him from College grounds.
- snowy 12y agoWhy was he dismissed and banned? Surly not for having suicidal thoughts. Did something else go on here that is been omitted? Did they see him as a threat to other students? If so you can't really blame them.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- baldfat 12y agoI worked in Student Life as a Resident Director. The power of Lawyer is extremely strong and the fear of litigation is very high. Our college handled this differently and perhaps it was due to my strong advocate since my brother took his own life when I was a kid. We required hospitalization for the hospital to evaluate and than we would work one on one to make sure they were following doctor's orders in terms of counseling and medications. This all had to be done secretly so that students privacy wasn't stolen and that students would know it was a safe place. As a Resident Director we would directly contact the professors and arrange a way for the student to make up their work and to complete the classes. usually the students would have a lot of abstinence and this would cause an issue, but we would always try our best and set up things in place for the next semester if need be and with financial assistance (AKA not charge them for the class credits a second time).
- andrey-p 12y agoThat was the bit that really stood out for me. Even if one could argue that they sent him off in order to take a break and recover before continuing his studies, this > and ban him from College grounds is ridiculous.
- eep_opp 12y agoI don't understand that part either. I wonder if the councilor saw a potential to not only harm himself but others and that's why it was included. I can understand the school not wanting to be the next stage for another tragedy similar to Virginia Tech. And had they not dismissed him and he continued on and something to that effect were to happen would we not see stories about friends and families of victims asking about why they would have allowed an obviously deeply disturbed person to remain on campus? Maybe the counselor thought (erroneously?) this particular problem was too big to handle?
- derrida 12y ago> I can understand the school not wanting to be the next stage for another tragedy similar to Virginia Tech. How can you understand this that way? I can't. I can't understand it because I know lots of people with depression, and I've experienced it once myself, never once did anybody I know or myself or for that matter, a reported case, ever think "I know, lets go and kill a bunch of people." I don't understand it... The number of dehumanizing things that have been done in the name of "health and safety" is staggering. Life begins with birth and ends with death, use compassionate reasoning in between, there's always a rule or formalism to hide behind.
- eep_opp 12y agoWell let's deconstruct my comment: 1: I don't get why they would bar him from campus. -Unless the councilor thought that he was also a danger to others. 2: If that was there view then I can understand why they would want to remove him. I’m saying that I agree but that maybe they (erroneously) saw something more than depression or something different from your situation. Given that what exactly is the issue?
- derrida 12y agoI mean, I can understand it, in the sense of, someone has a limited picture / a busy day / not the time & emotional resources for which to be able to also think compassionately about someone else in need. Or sometimes responsibility is diluted in institutions so an institution can act in a way that's devoid of compassion, where an individual acting face to face could not. (I hope you did not read me as objecting to your comment, just "expanding the picture") To understand how someone could exclude someone from campus with depression, I'd have to start positing the existence of events / information we don't have. Usually if a health care professional decides they are a danger to others, that is when people get sectioned. This is common place stuff. Virginia Tech is not common place stuff. Maybe the people at Virginia Tech were depressed or something, I don't know. But, so what? Hitler was an artist. There's always the "historical psycho" exception to every rule. Mathematics causes Unabombers? These events are in the popular imagination, but it's a reaction coming from fear. In cases like depression it's particularly important for people around a person to act from compassion, open-ness etc. Just "being there" is enough. Saying "I'm here..." is enough, you have no idea how a small thing like that can make a world of difference without you feeling like it's even a thing you had to give.
- Red_Tarsius 12y agoMy thoughts as well. The final response of the school to Cassie is also saddening and revealing of a culture devoid of any empathy.
- erroneousfunk 12y agoI think that was perhaps the best William and Mary could do without commenting on that particular student's case at all, or revealing any personal information, which they wouldn't be allowed to do.
- MrZongle2 12y agoAgreed. It read as if written by legal robots, far more interested in avoiding words that could possibly imply any sort of responsibility.
- kosma 12y agoHow is this even legal? I can't even imagine this happening in Europe; you can't dismiss someone from school without legal basis. Is it different in America?
- k-mcgrady 12y agoIsn't this how employment there works too?
- lawl 12y agoApart from there not beeing a single law for Europe... In theory yes, in practice it's easy to make something up, here it's mostly "company internal reasons", which they don't have to justify. The formal reason will never be that someone sucked at their job.
- celticninja 12y agowell that is somewhat inaccurate, there are EU wide laws and regulations.
- digi_owl 12y agoIirc, EU issue directives. But it is up the individual member nations to turn those into national laws and regulations.
- pjc50 12y agoThere have been a couple of cases of whistleblowers being fired on bogus mental health grounds from the EU itself. Although I can't remember names at the moment.
- mox1 12y agoAre you saying that in Europe colleges cannot dismiss anyone without a "legal basis" (ie they have committed a crime?) If so that is crazy..Cheating on a test is not "illegal." There are a whole host of things that are "against school policy" but not illegal. I find this very hard to believe....
- justonepost 12y agoCouple of more sentences: Almost 40% of the students who access our services at the Counseling Center report having had suicidal thoughts. The vast majority of those students continue to be seen at the Counseling Center and remain in school. Likely there was something extremely dramatic about this case that made the college believe he was a clear threat to himself and/or others if he stayed at the college.
- pluma 12y agoHe was speaking to the Counseling Center, not the college administration. In what world is banning someone from college the right approach to handle someone with obvious mental issues disclosing his problems in a counseling center? If his situation was "more extreme", the first course of action should be to escalate the situation to more qualified, not the college administration (who are neither qualified nor relevant). You can still kick someone out after they're in professional treatment. It's extreme irresponsible to not just refuse treatment but actually measurably make their situation worse. You might as well hand them a razor and tell them "yes, you're right, take this and go kill yourself" while you're at it.
- Lawtonfogle 12y ago>In what world is banning someone from college the right approach to handle someone with obvious mental issues disclosing his problems in a counseling center? Any potential threat of negative repercussions only serves to destroy trust between a potential client and any therapist. Imagine what would happen if people with AIDs had their info put into a public database (especially back when fear of the disease was much higher)? It would have destroyed not only the trust of those with or who might have AIDs, but of many people with other health concerns as well.
- smrtinsert 12y agoI read that and my jaw dropped. They should investigate legal options. I can't understand how they don't understand how that might push a student even closer to suicide - college is your world when you are in it.
- mcguire 12y agoOn the one hand, it's possible the counsellor concluded that he was a threat to others at the College---an immediate threat, which would require an immediate response. On the other hand, assuming he went to the counselling center first thing in the morning, that's roughly nine hours minus travel time, scheduling, and all the other steps involved in this kind of decision. I find it difficult to believe that a counsellor met with him for more than an hour. Further: "My brother is then taken home and the next day starts at our local mental health facility. He voluntarily enters a residential program, which is very hard ordeal for both him and my parents. However, he does well and is released to out-patient status on Monday, March 30, 2010." The residential program released him after less than two weeks. I suspect they would not do so if they believed him to be a threat. So, why did the College initially deny him re-admittance?
- Lawtonfogle 12y ago>On the one hand, it's possible the counsellor concluded that he was a threat to others at the College---an immediate threat, which would require an immediate response. And they may have protected the other students at the cost of selling out the integrity of therapy in general. Think of a judge, given the smoking gun needed to convict a murderer that was obtained by unconstitutional means. He must let the murderer go because, while releasing the murder introduces risks to the public, the risk of not upholding the Constitution is even greater. As it stands, I would no more advise someone to see a therapist than I would advise them to tell everything to a defense lawyer in a country where the defense lawyer tells everything to the prosecutor and it is all admissible in court.