5 ms·
I can't say I'm entirely disappointed to see LinkedIn doing poorly. They do shady things with their data[1], and I'm not okay with that. I like the idea, but
by kbenson 12y ago
I can't say I'm entirely disappointed to see LinkedIn doing poorly. They do shady things with their data[1], and I'm not okay with that.
I like the idea, but it feels like they are a company that could have done well and been fine privately, but market pressure forces them into some questionable practices (but I have no idea how representative of reality that is).
1: Such as determining a second email address of mine through data mining or some other method and sending emails to it asking if I know a person, even through I'm already linked with them, and that email address does not have a LinkedIn account. That's either an invasion of privacy, or spam, or both.
- themoonbus 12y agoI had LinkedIn sending me messages on an email that I had deleted from my account a year prior. It was a bug on their end (edit: or so they claimed), and they fixed it after I talked to customer service, but I've never really trusted them since then.
- talmand 12y ago"Bug"
- themoonbus 12y agoHaha, possibly. I don't see why they'd send email to an old address, but it definitely shows that I had a different definition of "delete" than they did. Also, I had some pretty terrible experiences trying to use their API (see: http://fucknolinkedindev.tumblr.com http://fucknolinkedindev.tumblr.com). Thankfully, I stopped developing anything using LinkedIn a couple months before they decided to totally nuke their existing dev resources (http://thenextweb.com/dd/2015/02/12/linkedin-takes-aim-developers-plans-lock-apis/ http://thenextweb.com/dd/2015/02/12/linkedin-takes-aim-devel...).
- m_samuel_l 12y ago"Fixed"
- NDizzle 12y agoIf we're trading stories about shady linkedin things, I want to participate! While I have never synced any of my email addresses with linkedin, and I have always used the hidden craigslist email address when buying/selling things, linkedin currently wants me to connect with two different people that I have sold things to on craigslist. I'm not even sure how that happens, especially since I use the craiglist-internal email for handling the transaction.
- VieElm 12y agoYou probably replied to a craigslist email which used your real email address via reply-to field and they were using gmail which stored this information.
- NDizzle 12y agoMy current theory is that I gave him my phone number in one of the emails, but every email transaction was through the pseudo-anonymous craigslist email that is generated per listing. He probably has a contact with that (now bad) email and my (still current) phone number. Which is my phone number on linkedin. That kind of makes sense, but it still doesn't make me very happy about their methods.
- nmridul 12y agoThe people who you sold stuffs to, they saw you on linkedin and tried to link you. Now here is the funny part - Linkedin asks them to enter your email id to confirm that they really know you. Bang... you receive mail on your craiglist email... Again, just a wild guess as I have received Linkedin mails on different mail ids including my official email id that I have not entered.... Lesson learnt. You dont need to share your information online. Your friends will do that for you. And some times, even people you thought know nothing about you will have that missing link that these companies can then use to join the dots .......
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- rudimental 12y agoI'm no lover of LinedIn, and I bet they do some shady thing. As to your second email address, I wonder if it's someone trying to 'connect' to you input it. LinkedIn asks for an e-mail address of the person you want to connect to if they're not close enough to you in the LinkedIn graph, and maybe a person put in the other email.
- kbenson 12y agoNo, when this first happened, I was confused and contacted the individual by IM. They hadn't tried to contact my through LinkedIn or any other method, nor even logged into LinkedIn in quite a while. I just checked, and now there exists an account for the other email address, with no contacts. It's possible a bug created a bunch of accounts based on some alternate email settings they had, but I can't imagine them keeping around a bunch of bogus accounts unless it served some useful purpose, such as increasing the user count to show growth...
- kbenson 12y agoOn further reflection, I remember creating that account with no connections while investigating what was going on. I tried to log in from the email address that was receiving the emails but couldn't and assumed that the account had been cancelled for inactivity. I "reopened" the account (in reality creating a new one) on accident. So I retract any statements about them accidentally creating accounts, this was a while back and I had forgotten that portion. But to be clear, that wohle scenario happened because LinkedIn started sending info to that (unaffiliated) email address unexpectedly, and I assumed if I was getting LinkedIn email there, that must be my account email...