3 ms·
Individual developers might not make much money, but the profits for Apple and Microsoft depend on the sales as a whole across all developers. In Apple's case,
by Silhouette 12y ago
Individual developers might not make much money, but the profits for Apple and Microsoft depend on the sales as a whole across all developers. In Apple's case, they're making plenty.
That's true for now, but I don't think it's sustainable.
Apple's effective monopoly on the distribution channel is already a big risk for developers. You might not get approved at all, and have no real recourse if you don't. You might be effectively forced to update existing apps to comply with arbitrary new rules or UI guidelines because another iOS update came out, even though there's nothing in it for you (except for not losing what you already had). I've lost track of how much it costs or soon will cost just to be able to develop and ship apps in the first place via Apple's App Store, but it's more than nothing. And even if you jump through all the hoops, the near-zero price point of any app no matter how large or high-quality is now firmly established, and Apple can take a huge cut of those near-zero revenues purely because they have that monopoly on distribution of software for their own devices.
So for users, the software available for iOS is limited in scope and much of it is junk. For developers, iOS apps are one of the most high-risk, low-reward options, so that situation isn't going to change. And Apple's market share, particularly among consumers, seems to be diving faster than you can say "Good Android devices cost half as much", making iOS an ever-less-attractive platform for new development. If you're Facebook and giving your app away for free because you make your money another way, or if you're a specialist consultancy making business apps that integrate with cloudy things like SalesForce and are priced accordingly, you're playing a different game. But for typical consumer apps, the rules are heavily stacked against developers, and sooner or later the only people left will be the naive ones who haven't learned better yet, until the default wisdom becomes Android-first for any app[1], at which point Apple's mobile device business model is finished (and potentially so is Apple itself, though it's so huge now that like Microsoft and IBM before it there will be several chances to reinvent itself and recover first).
[1] Edit: Or Microsoft-first, if they really land Windows 10. Or Web-first, if mobile browsers and the APIs for using features traditionally reserved for native apps catch up. Web apps still have a huge advantage in portability compared to native ones, and that will also get more important if Microsoft/BlackBerry/anyone else manages to establish additional significant mobile platforms that aren't iOS- or Android-based.
- wlesieutre 12y agoGenerally agreed. I'm one of those former iOS users who jumped ship to a cheaper Android phone. But while there's only so much room for $10 text editors like Vesper, there are plenty of people who are content to keep dumping money into Candy Crush. As much as I hate it, I don't see that revenue stream drying up. Even if nobody ever wrote a new text editor for iOS, Apple would be fine. The 1000 editors that have been written already are enough. MS's approach is pretty interesting. It's tempting to write it off as an OS/2 style "Why would anybody bother writing apps if it's compatible with Android" scenario, but I see that more as a stop-gap to get their phones in people's hands. Without it, people are missing work essential apps (Hipchat/Slack/Trello/etc) and apps driven by friend-networks (Snapchat) that can't be easily substituted, even if a similar alternative is available. Maybe with this, they'll have a bit of luck in actually selling phones. And then the native apps can trickle down from Universal Apps being developed for desktops and tablets. I hope they manage it, but the MS name has an awful lot of baggage attached.