4 ms·
Names have no meaning? I'm pretty sure that's dystopian.
by Balgair 12y ago
Names have no meaning? I'm pretty sure that's dystopian.
- stephengillie 12y agoIt's a primary key, a handle for the thread of the bill, a (human-friendly) designation. Even important CVEs get named.
- rmxt 12y agoImportant CVEs get names like "Heartbleed" and "Shellshock" which are straightforward in their negativity, and reflect the severity of their underlying nature. I understand that we need a human readable/writable title for this bill, but putting "freedom" on this bill is polishing a turd of a policy (bulk collection). It obscures the actual values at stake with the consideration of this bill.
- vinceguidry 12y agoIt's a hard problem. When coding, I have to come up with sufficiently descriptive names for all methods, all internal variables, all classes, all modules to fit those classes in. Sometimes I feel the urge to cheat, to give less than fully descriptive names for things. Inevitably, this comes back to bite me when I go back to revise the code and find I can't immediately understand what the code is doing, and the first thing I find myself doing is renaming poorly-named constructs. Congress has very different constraints when naming bills, but the end result is the same, adding the burden of a hard-to-do-right, yet high-visibility responsibility to already-overworked staffers. I'm not surprised at all that the names for most bills are sappy and nondescript.
- tetrep 12y ago>Congress has very different constraints when naming bills, but the end result is the same... You speak as if they're making an honest attempt to give the bills meaningful and accurate names. They want the former, not the latter. The PATRIOT Act, like the USA FREEDOM Act and many other bills, is purposefully misnomed in an attempt to hide what the bills does and to dissuade voting against it. "You wouldn't vote against patriots or freedom, would you?"
- dragonwriter 12y ago> The PATRIOT Act [...] is purposefully misnomed in an attempt to hide what the bills does and to dissuade voting against it When discussing the manipulative nature of the naming of the act in question, its perhaps useful to get the name right: it's not just the PATRIOT Act, its the USA PATRIOT Act, and USA PATRIOT isn't the full name, its an acronym for "Uniting and Strengthening America by Providing Appropriate Tools Required to Intercept and Obstruct Terrorism".
- bookface 12y agoWow, that is, appropriately, a tortured backronym.
- npizzolato 12y agoI'm reminded of this line from Agents of Shield: Maria Hill: What does S.H.I.E.L.D. stand for, Agent Ward? Grant Ward: Strategic Homeland Intervention, Enforcement and Logistics Division. Maria Hill: And what does that mean to you? Grant Ward: It means someone really wanted our initials to spell out "shield."
- vinceguidry 12y ago> You speak as if they're making an honest attempt to give the bills meaningful and accurate names. Even if they did make an honest attempt, it wouldn't solve the problem. It would just increase their workload and open themselves up to political attacks for no real gain. You don't get the bill you want, you get the bill you can gain support for. Getting any bill onto the floor takes Herculean effort. Honest naming would just hurt these bill's chances.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Congress has very different constraints when naming bills, but the end result is the same, adding the burden of a hard-to-do-right, yet high-visibility responsibility to already-overworked staffers. I'm not surprised at all that the names for most bills are sappy and nondescript. The purpose of bill names, particularly ones on controversial issues, is not to be descriptive, it is to be sales tools. Its better to think of them as brand names than anything else.
- mapmap 12y agoThere are two hard things in Computer Science: cache invalidation and naming things. -Phil Karlton
- nitrogen 12y agoWhen coding, I have to come up with sufficiently descriptive names for all methods, all internal variables, all classes, all modules to fit those classes in. Sometimes I feel the urge to cheat, to give less than fully descriptive names for things. But do you name your method that erases the whole system super_fun_happy_data_protection_enforcement_method()?
- vinceguidry 12y agoBy this analogy it would be a protect_data_transport method written by an amateur that has a bunch of nasty race conditions and buffer overflows. You're assuming malice on the part of the politicians when there's really no reason to. Just because we know the implications of the law they passed doesn't mean they would.
- nitrogen 12y agoWasn't the original PATRIOT act written before Sept. 11, 2001? The frequency with which laws are named grossly inappropriately suggests something a bit more sinister than incompetence, even if it's not 100% malice.
- timtas 12y agoOrwellian, to be precise.
- zo1 12y agoIndeed, that's precisely what first popped up in my head when I read this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doublespeak http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doublespeak
- timtas 12y agoIndeed. I was thinking specifically of this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newspeak http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newspeak