4 ms·
I am in favor of commentary, but his comment only makes sense as hindsight. If he posted it beforehand, he would mostly be wrong, because AirBnB mostly works. I
by wpietri 12y ago
I am in favor of commentary, but his comment only makes sense as hindsight. If he posted it beforehand, he would mostly be wrong, because AirBnB mostly works. If he posted it after any of the many successful outcomes, he would look dumb.
There is no reason to say that these people "got it wrong". They were unlucky. Suppose the same shitheels broke a window, climbed in, unlocked the door, and had a big party on a weekend when the owners were away. One inclined to superiority-by-hindsight could say, "Well duh, why didn't they have bars on their windows?"
After a rare negative occurrence, one can always look back with hindsight, find some way the bad outcome could theoretically have been averted, and then say, "Well duh." Always. It is a great way to sound and feel smart. But it never actually fixes anything. Indeed, it can prevent the fixing of things because, having blamed someone, we mostly stop looking for useful lessons to learn.
If you want the book-length version of this, Sidney Dekker's "Field Guide to Understanding Human Error" has a great explanation of why retrospective blame ends up being immensely harmful: http://www.amazon.com/Field-Guide-Understanding-Human-Error/dp/0754648257 http://www.amazon.com/Field-Guide-Understanding-Human-Error/...
- mikeash 12y ago"Why didn't they have bars on their windows?" could be a reasonable criticism or it could be pure hindsight. Which one depends on whether the person stating it was faced with a similar decision and decided in the direction they advise. If I've evaluated the risks and decided that putting bars on my windows is wise, and I did it, then it's totally reasonable for me to criticize people who didn't and subsequently got their house broken into. That's not hindsight, that's having foresight, and criticizing other people for not having it. That's relevant because the AirBnB question is one that a lot of us have actually thought about and decided on. I (and presumably the other guy above) had the foresight to realize that renting my house on AirBnB was not wise. Pointing out the natural consequences of making what we see as the unwise choice is not hindsight, because we made that decision beforehand. I don't see how this particular instance doesn't fix things, or prevents fixing things. Convincing people not to rent their houses on AirBnB if they care about said houses is a fix! It's a really good fix! It doesn't fix the problem of "AirBnB guests can sometimes cause major damage to their accommodations" but it does fix "AirBnB guests cause emotional violation by trashing a person's primary dwelling." "Don't rent your home to strangers from the internet" is not searching in hindsight for some way the problem could have been avoided, and using that to unjustly criticize. It's a completely rational approach to life that a lot of people have been following for a long time.
- wpietri 12y agoYour theory here seems to be that one person in the world having an extremely negative outcome validates basically all negative risk perceptions. I think that's bunk. It makes no more sense than saying that because one person wins the lottery, it validates everybody who buys a ticket and loses. To evaluate risk and reward, you have to look at baskets of outcomes, not crazy outliers. Suppose he lent his house to a friend who trashed it? Suppose he gave keys to a cleaning service and some reprobate there stole the keys and trashed the house? Suppose an earthquake destroyed his house? No matter what happens, there's always a way to blame people after the fact. The way this discourages fixing things is that blame never fixes anything. Blame isn't a solution, it's another problem. If somebody wants to do an integrated risk analysis on AirBnB and make some predictions on that, great. I'd love to read it. But comments like the one I call out are predicting the past. They're not just worthless, they're harmful to useful dialog.
- mikeash 12y agoWhat exactly is the difference between "blame" and analyzing a past problem with the idea of avoiding similar problems in the future, and what makes you put this particular statement on the "blame" side of it?
- wpietri 12y agoFrom Wikipedia: "Blame is the act of censuring, holding responsible, making negative statements about an individual or group that their action or actions are socially or morally irresponsible." This guy didn't "analyze a problem". There was zero intellectual contribution. He called people stupid for taking a risk and then being unhappy when they got a 1-in-a-million negative outcome. If you want a longer version of why blame impedes risk analysis, try the book I recommended upthread. (Or pretty much any book on retrospectives will have a shorter version.) But the short version is that you basically have a choice between the emotional activity of blame or the analytical activity of analysis. Because humans.