9 ms·
Want a steady income? There's an app for that
- nissimk 12y agoThe article is very good and the business idea seems solid too. It reminded me of the article from last week about how etsy is a "B corporation" and they've committed to put social and environmental concerns before profit. It sounds like that would be a good choice for this company too. Providing financial products to poor people is a slippery slope if you're trying not to be evil. Payday loans, rent a center, layaway, check cashing all serve to perpetuate a cycle of poverty. If even can be a profitable company and also help to break that cycle it will be really great.
- d135_1r43 12y agoTL;DR?
- MarkyC4 12y agoSets aside money when you make more than your average paycheck, uses the money that was set aside when you make less than your average paycheck
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- madcaptenor 12y agoDuplicate of https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9460628 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9460628
- preinheimer 12y agotl;dr App called "even" allows people with incredibly variable income (case study is on a massage therapist, lots of money one week, little the next) to even out their income. They evaluate their income history, then offer a stabilized value, say $380/week. Weeks they make more, the application takes it and puts it aside. Weeks they make less, it either pulls it in from a reserve, or an instant loan is made. Costs users $3/week. Which is non-trivial, but less than a payday loan company.
- gadders 12y agoWhen I started reading I thought it was going to be "Uber for Masseuses" but it turned out to be more interesting than that. I hope it works out.
- profinger 12y agoThank you. This article was way too long to get such a simple thing across.
- belorn 12y agoSo its a very basic personal economy management tool that automatically takes loan and restrict withdraws. Sound risky.
- qzcx 12y agoWhat is the risk you are referring to? On the surface it sounds like a decent app for someone who lacks financial skills.
- belorn 12y agoMaking automatic loans sound very similar to sms loans, which is a common cause for people falling into incurable debt. It mean less insight and less responsibility, targeted to those who lack financial skills. That could make things better in theory, or things much much worse if the incentives are to get people to take unnecessary and expensive loans.
- icebraining 12y agoThey say they aren't loans, but credits. It's not clear that you actually become indebted to them.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- 12y ago
- rjaco31 12y agoThat's a seriously fucked-up webpage without Javascript =/ http://i.imgur.com/Lr53m7u.png http://i.imgur.com/Lr53m7u.png
- JustSomeNobody 12y agoThe internet hates people who don't run javascript.
- mhuffman 12y agoIn this particular case, even moreso. It wants Javascript to to do the job of CSS and how!
- rhizome 12y agoVery common. My assumption is that frontend wears the pants in these companies and tells backend just to provide barebones with (many times partial) content and structural ULs for menus and related stories.
- toxican 12y agoHow the fuck? I go to ridiculous lengths to avoid using JS for anything critical (ya know, like SITE STRUCTURE!), and then these people waltz in....
- thrownaway122 12y agoPlease continue to do so. I'm sure that there are others like me that seriously appreciate you doing so.
- finnn 12y agoYou should see the company's website without 3rd party Javascript: https://i.imgur.com/xfzP26A.png https://i.imgur.com/xfzP26A.png Note that this is just blocking Javascript from other domains, anything from their domain is allowed
- btbuildem 12y agoAmidst all these verbose vignettes of precious characters, what DOES Even DO? Oh, ok, there's one paragraph in there that sheds some light: "The app then holds back an “Even cushion” — a savings account it manages for the user. In the demo I saw, the app, drawing on a sample bank account, reported that “if you earn less than $380, Even will automatically boost your paycheck. If you earn more than $380, Even will automatically pay back boosts and save the extra to your cushion.”
- def_illiterate 12y agoIt reads like a precocious high-schooler wrote it. I stopped reading when I got to that paragraph.
- jawns 12y agoThe article opens with the story of Heather Jacobs, a masseuse whose income is volatile, and it implies that she's a prototypical Even user. But she actually seems to be an undesirable user, from the company's point of view. It sounds as if she's struggling not just to budget but to earn enough money to pay for all her expenses, both recurring and unexpected. (She says she's often "desperate" around the end of the month.) That's exactly the kind of user that Even should try to avoid. I'm not necessarily faulting the woman for not being able to make enough; I'm just saying that Even's ideal user should be someone who, over time, earns enough to cover their expenses, but either has trouble sticking to a budget or would prefer the convenience of an app to handle budgeting for them. For instance, my parents (one a teacher, who got paychecks from September to May, and the other a landscape, who earned little during the winter months) could have used an app like this when I was growing up. Between the two of them, they made ends meet, but they struggled to figure out how much to save so they'd have a reserve during the months when their incomes dipped. One thing I am curious about, which the article doesn't touch on: What happens if I have a surplus in my Even account (which the article says is kept in a savings account), and I run into a huge unexpected expense? What are my options for tapping into that surplus? If I have the same access to it as a regular savings account, does that kind of defeat the point of the app (to prevent people with poor willpower from spending their surplus instead of saving it)? Or is it treated like a withdrawal from a 401(k), with penalties for taking the money out earlier than scheduled?
- Infinitesimus 12y ago> It sounds as if she's struggling not just to budget but to earn enough money to pay for all her expenses, both recurring and unexpected. (She says she's often "desperate" around the end of the month.) That's exactly the kind of user that Even should try to avoid. I'm not entirely convinced of that. She could also be the very type of customer that they'll want for their expansion (i.e. into a budgeting service). They could evolve to help people both stabilize their incomes and learn how to budget better to improve overall stability
- marcinx27 12y agoI think the fact that her pay fluctuated from between $90 and $700 is what makes her the "prototypical" user. I'm sure if she had a few high paying weeks, she wouldn't be desperate at the end of the month. Also, I checked out their website and it seems that you can withdraw all of the money that you have in Even if you need it immediately. And they put a pretty big emphasis on the fact that when you start, you get hooked up with an Even employee to help guide you through your finances and using the app. It isn't just a download and go setup. It seems to me that there is a lot of human interaction involved with actually using it.
- mhuffman 12y ago> If you have no money saved, Even will boost your pay with interest-free credit. You'll automatically pay the credit back the next time you earn more than your average pay. ... then later > ... Even is not a lender and Even does not provide loans. I'm guessing this is to stay on the right side of lender regulations, but talk about being slippery with semantics!
- hurin 12y agoThank you for double posting the infomercial for an app (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9460628 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9460628) within a mere 6 hours of it's last appearance. (HN really should have a built in filter for this). Also a big thanks to the new york times for their uninterrupted commitment towards high-quality journalism.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- DanBC 12y agoThose links were posted by different people. You might want to check ColinWrights submission history - they submit many interesting articles. They're not shilling or astroturfing for this company and your assumption is a bit rude because it's so easy to check. About the dupe: This submission has a clean url, the earlier submission has a bunch of cruft which is probably why the dupe filter didn't spot it. http://www.nytimes.com/2015/05/03/magazine/want-a-steady-income-theres-an-app-for-that.html http://www.nytimes.com/2015/05/03/magazine/want-a-steady-inc... http://www.nytimes.com/2015/05/03/magazine/want-a-steady-income-theres-an-app-for-that.html?emc=edit_tnt_20150429&nlid=66702700&tntemail0=y&_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2015/05/03/magazine/want-a-steady-inc...
- hurin 12y agoThe article author obviously is astro-turfing for the company and if people want to link infomercials passing for journalism I can have an opinion on that. (I agree that I did not phrase my first comment well and it makes it sound like I implied ColinWright's involvement specifically, I've fixed that). That doesn't change the fact that it's a duplicate from within 12* hours and should get removed.
- VikingCoder 12y ago> obviously Or they think it's fascinating and want to share. I'm saying it's not "obviously" anything, to me.
- jklein11 12y agoThis interest free loan makes it VERY susceptible to fraud or abuse. Lets consider for example, a technology contractor, making $120,000 a year from various contracting jobs. The contractor could sign up for Even, and then retire, collecting a $2500 "paycheck boost" interest free. I think this idea has a lot of value, but their current business model can't be profitable.
- jkaunisv1 12y agoIt sounds like the signup process will be fairly high-touch, to evaluate whether they're a customer Even wants. Given that this involves a fairly complete opening of the kimono, I doubt Even would let someone who makes $120k/year sign up.
- jklein11 12y agoHow can you afford a high touch sign up process for a customer who is worth ~$144 a year?
- jkaunisv1 12y agoIf customer support requirements are high at sign up but low for customer lifetime then it shouldn't matter as long as their retention is good and lifetime is long. I don't know, it's not my business plan. I'm just pointing out they're unlikely to have a signup process that lets people with high levels of income in.
- jklein11 12y agoThat's a fair point. Sorry I didn't mean to come accross as attacking you I'm just confused by the business model in general.
- jkaunisv1 12y agoThis is absolutely not my area of expertise, but if I had to guess: * Spend a fairly fixed amount of money developing the app and related infrastructure * Keep a slush fund for covering loans * Potential customer provides their bank account info, run it through a risk analysis program * Have a human approve or deny the customer based on that program's results * If approved, give them some coaching & onboarding training * Largely ignore the customer unless they go in arrears, make $12/month for your SaaS offering Note that monthly cost isn't much different from something you'd pay for a Shopify store, say. And they have very high touch onboarding in some cases.
- Spooky23 12y agoI wanted to really hate this, but it sounds like a really interesting idea. It seems like it would either be very capital intensive, or it's going to need to operate like a bank. Also, folks in these situations tend to be very transient and have fluctuating income. How do you establish an adequate virtual salary when the terms of the person's employment change? Forget about massage people -- they are a bad example because two or three customers may make for a windfall-like experience. How about a person who works at the Gap or BestBuy? You might get 35 hours one week, 20 the next, then 18 for a month.
- joshdance 12y agoThey probably will look at the average of your hours across several months. Trial and error. Should be interesting.
- socialbullets 12y agoIts kind of marketing tactic? Spend some dollars to get viral!
- lhurtig 12y agoLooking at their website (https://even.me/)- https://even.me/)- this app both acts as a bank itself and interacts with a person's bank account. Some interesting notes - even is actually FDIC insured, so at least the money they are moving out of a person's bank account is insured in case the company collapses. Their linkedin page also notes they are... "A bank that automatically manages its customers' finances. Pays their bills. Balances their budget. Saves and invests. And at the tip of the iceberg, gives each and every customer a weekly paycheck of purely disposable income. " So not only is the income you get each week stabilized - the long term intent is the income you get is solely above and beyond bills and, presumably, investment goals. At some point - Even could issue debit cards, link up with paypal accounts, and literally supplant the banks that they are working with currently. Loans are a tricky concept, and Even is attacking a very appropriate market - more than 69% of payday loans are used just to pay normal bills, counter-intuitive to what I would have guessed (emergencies such as health and auto-repair are only around 16%). Some math: $3 a week = $156 a year - savings of ~$360 versus average payday loan interest. 12 million people use at least one payday loan during a year, with numbers skewed as a higher % of population in states with "looser" regulations on payday loans (6.6% of pop) rather than states with "very strict" regulation (2.9% of pop). Average loan = $375, 8 separate loans taken during a year, plus $520 on interest payments across all loans. 6 of those 8 loans are actually extensions of just 2 loans! If regular bills are budgeted for, and the money is literally reserved by Even, that eliminates the need for 70% of all non-extended payday loans. Add in budgeting for emergencies, and 84% of payday loans are gone - so whatever interest they do or do not charge for the other 16% is not going to approach normal interest costs. As jawns points out - majority of loans are because people can't afford their bills... Since they are FDIC insured - I'll assume they operate like a standard credit union overall and are buffering people's loans using other people's savings...again they also claim they want to invest people's money for them.
- thrownaway122 12y agoWhat is to stop someone simply opening two bank accounts. Then paying their unsteady income into one and then transferring a steady amount of money into the other. Combined with the old adage about spending less than one earns and the result is happiness.
- ticviking 12y agoThe service automates that, and adds friction to violating your budget. (or at least that is how I see it).
- bradleyprice 12y agoI worked with a company a few years back that did this exact thing, although we couldn't get past regulations and ended up shutting down. http://finovate.com/videos/finovatefall-2011-tandem/ http://finovate.com/videos/finovatefall-2011-tandem/
- Locke1689 12y agoThis is super interesting! Do you have any more details on the problems you faced?
- bradleyprice 12y agoSo, I left a couple months before the final audit before going to public launch. As far as I know, they were going to have to change a good bit of stuff focused around the taking out loans. The sole investor cut his losses since we were already over time and budget. Also, we were having custom development done from the bank that hosted our accounts and the bank that provided us with credit limits. And we were going to have to have them go back and overhaul a lot of their system that had been changed for us, which was extremely expensive.