4 ms·
There are few kinds of HN comment I hate more than the superior-by-dint-of-hindsight putdown.
by wpietri 12y ago
There are few kinds of HN comment I hate more than the superior-by-dint-of-hindsight putdown.
- ekianjo 12y agoIt's not hindsight. When you play with fire you obviously end up being burnt once in a while. It's just common sense. And you should not play with fire with things you REALLY care for, like your home.
- wpietri 12y agoPlease. Your comment only has any punch because you made it on one of the rare negative outcomes. And you could have made it after any similarly rare disaster. Their home could have been trashed after letting a friend stay. After having a cleaner come by. After a plumber. After they left the door unlocked. After somebody broke in when they went away on vacation. And you could have said, "Well duh, what were you thinking leaving your house unoccupied." Life is risk. Running around and acting smart after the negative outcomes is boring and easy. It's the same game played by the vast number of people who explain why a startup could never work after the startup has already failed.
- ekianjo 12y agoLife is risk indeed, and by allowing strangers into your place without any supervision, you are significantly increasing the risk that something wrong can happen, don't you think ? EDIT: Oh, and the startup comparison is silly, most people who run startups don't even put their own home at stake in case everything fails.
- wpietri 12y agoYes, and I named several occasions when one lets strangers into one's place without supervision, as well as two where strangers come in on their own. Life is risk, which is why we should react with compassion rather than mockery when somebody's dice come up snake eyes. The startup comparison is not silly, because my point is not about houses. It's about after-the-fact commentators finding occasions to kick people when they're down.
- ekianjo 12y ago> The startup comparison is not silly, because my point is not about houses. It's about after-the-fact commentators finding occasions to kick people when they're down. The reason why I thought it was silly is not just that. Startup owners are known to take risks because they venture in stuff that has never been done before and therefore high-risk is a natural factor in that environment. Renting your house is nothing like that: it's very clear from the beginning that it could be trashed by the occupants, it's a very REAL and tangible risk (and it has been known to occur in many occasions), nothing like the "Unknown" startup owners face. You need to be wise to be a startup owner (and lucky), but renting your own place (if you actually care about it, like that person in the article) is just silly in terms of benefit/risk ratio.
- wpietri 12y agoYou are not understanding the analogy I am making. It is not startups = houses. I am saying that it is easy to use hindsight kick people while they're down, and that we see that behavior all the time when startups fail. > renting your own place (if you actually care about it, like that person in the article) is just silly in terms of benefit/risk ratio Ah, note another rhetorical maneuver: the false objective voice. That is a belief of yours, not a demonstrated fact. Many people differ. Try owning your opinions.
- x0x0 12y agoI take your point, but renting your home out to strangers just seems, to me, like a very strange thing to do. I'm a little grossed out even by public toilets, so to have people I don't know with who knows what hygiene habits doing god only knows what in my house is just something I'm not interested in. It's not the negative outcome; I just find simultaneously calling your home a sanctuary and renting it to strangers for cash to be passing strange. I have friends who aren't particularly attached to their house, and the wife even has a massage studio there; they rent it out on airbnb all the time. But they already have all sorts of strangers passing through anyway.
- wpietri 12y agoI agree that for some it will seem strange; for many, though, it feels normal. I love my books, but I lend books out pretty much at the drop of a hat because there's a joy in sharing. If somebody willfully destroyed one of my books and handed me back urine-soaked shreds, I would still feel violated. And if somebody then said, "Well duh, what do you expect lending out your books?" I would think that person an asshole. Because what I expect, what most people would expect, is what generally happens: the book gets returned with appreciation. One can always seize upon the rare bad outcome to sound smart in hindsight, but as far as I can see it's just kicking people when they're down.
- x0x0 12y agoAnyone who's rented out homes knows the deal. Family had a ski house out east that was regularly rented out. People are assholes. They steal cheap target throw rugs or cheap wall art, break into the owners' closet, leave enormous messes, etc. I'm really not trying to make this sound like, "Well, what did you expect!" -- shit sucks and these homeowners don't need people piling on them -- but seriously, anyone who's rented out homes knows the deal. The reason your book example is misleading is you aren't renting it out for cash to strangers to take to a party with them. If you have a personal connection to people they treat your stuff with more respect because it's tangled up in your relationship. When you let friends use your home, it's personal for both of you. When you let strangers use your home for money, it's personal for you but just business for them. It's an alternative to a hotel and will be treated with the same (lack of) respect, for better or for worse.
- venomsnake 12y agoNo. This is inherit risk in renting. That is why commercial operations have insurance and sometimes legal recourse to recoup damages. There will always be bad actors. You cannot take only the good stuff from something without the bad.
- wpietri 12y agoThere is inherent risk in home ownership too, which is why we have homeowners' insurance. Nobody is denying the inherent risk. I agree that we should take the bad with the good. However, I believe that assuming the mantle of intellectual superiority after something bad happens is doing basically the opposite. These transactions work out just fine for most people. Seizing upon the rare bad outcome as a chance to sound smart is ignoring that most AirBnB guests really do treat other people's homes well.
- mikeash 12y agoPersonally, I dislike comments that just criticize commentary as "hindsight." If it were technologically possible to discuss these things before they happen then I'm sure we would do it, but for now we're stuck with traditional concepts of causality. I imagine a lot of people on this site have considered renting on AirBnB. Certainly I have. It's a hip service, it fits in well with our techie notions of the world, and you make a little extra cash. Perfect! Then I came to my senses and decided that the risk to my house, where I happen to live and in which I place great value, wasn't anywhere near worth the relatively small amount of money it would bring in. If you thought it through and decided it's not worth the risk, it's hardly "hindsight" to point out when somebody else clearly got it wrong.
- wpietri 12y agoI am in favor of commentary, but his comment only makes sense as hindsight. If he posted it beforehand, he would mostly be wrong, because AirBnB mostly works. If he posted it after any of the many successful outcomes, he would look dumb. There is no reason to say that these people "got it wrong". They were unlucky. Suppose the same shitheels broke a window, climbed in, unlocked the door, and had a big party on a weekend when the owners were away. One inclined to superiority-by-hindsight could say, "Well duh, why didn't they have bars on their windows?" After a rare negative occurrence, one can always look back with hindsight, find some way the bad outcome could theoretically have been averted, and then say, "Well duh." Always. It is a great way to sound and feel smart. But it never actually fixes anything. Indeed, it can prevent the fixing of things because, having blamed someone, we mostly stop looking for useful lessons to learn. If you want the book-length version of this, Sidney Dekker's "Field Guide to Understanding Human Error" has a great explanation of why retrospective blame ends up being immensely harmful: http://www.amazon.com/Field-Guide-Understanding-Human-Error/dp/0754648257 http://www.amazon.com/Field-Guide-Understanding-Human-Error/...
- mikeash 12y ago"Why didn't they have bars on their windows?" could be a reasonable criticism or it could be pure hindsight. Which one depends on whether the person stating it was faced with a similar decision and decided in the direction they advise. If I've evaluated the risks and decided that putting bars on my windows is wise, and I did it, then it's totally reasonable for me to criticize people who didn't and subsequently got their house broken into. That's not hindsight, that's having foresight, and criticizing other people for not having it. That's relevant because the AirBnB question is one that a lot of us have actually thought about and decided on. I (and presumably the other guy above) had the foresight to realize that renting my house on AirBnB was not wise. Pointing out the natural consequences of making what we see as the unwise choice is not hindsight, because we made that decision beforehand. I don't see how this particular instance doesn't fix things, or prevents fixing things. Convincing people not to rent their houses on AirBnB if they care about said houses is a fix! It's a really good fix! It doesn't fix the problem of "AirBnB guests can sometimes cause major damage to their accommodations" but it does fix "AirBnB guests cause emotional violation by trashing a person's primary dwelling." "Don't rent your home to strangers from the internet" is not searching in hindsight for some way the problem could have been avoided, and using that to unjustly criticize. It's a completely rational approach to life that a lot of people have been following for a long time.