7 ms·
> Thinking about money gives her a jolt, “like you’re about to get into a car accident,” she later told me. There’s the $3,700 for massage-school tuition that
by grecy 12y ago
> Thinking about money gives her a jolt, “like you’re about to get into a car accident,” she later told me. There’s the $3,700 for massage-school tuition that she still owes on her credit card; the $60 a month for drugs for her anxiety and bipolar disorder, which she might skimp on again
Sentences like that make me sad about the reality of life for tens of millions of working Americans.
I just visited Australia after 9 years in North America, and it's like a slap in the face to realize there are no desperate people there. Almost everybody has enough money for basic essentials, and nobody is crushed with student debt or the fear of not being able to pay medical bills.
It really does feel like another planet when people earning "minimum wage" are doing just fine, are extremely happy, and likely less stressed than the career workers in North America, simply because they earn "enough to live comfortably"
- Swizec 12y ago> It really does feel like another planet when people earning "minimum wage" are doing just fine There's a big difference between getting minimum wage every 5th of the month on the dot, or getting $2k one month, $10k next month, $1k third month and so on.
- grecy 12y agoWhen getting minimum wage is enough of a baseline to have a great and worry-free life, anything above that is cream.
- Swizec 12y agoThe issue the article is talking about is the whole not getting minimum wage every month. It's the uncertainty. Minimum wage in California is $9/h. That means that if you work minimum wage full-time (160h/month), you get $1440 per month. You won't have luxury, but I imagine that managing your money when $1440 appears on your bank account every 5th of the month at 3pm isn't that difficult. But when the deposits look like this: - Jan 10th: $800 - Feb 4th: $2500 - Mar 15th: $1400 - Apr 29th: $1060 Managing cashflow is hard. But the average monthly income in this example is still minimum wage.
- nmrm2 12y agoSurviving on 1440 in many parts of California would not be nearly as easy as you make it sound. One wrong step (e.g., a high medical bill -- even with insurance) and you're into the endless cycle of credit card debt with no way out. (edit: I agree that uncertainty certainly doesn't help the problem.)
- Swizec 12y agoI didn't say it would be easy, but it would be plannable. And that makes a huge difference. Unexpected expenses will of course mess it up and throw you into a spiral if you don't have a buffer. But that's true at any income level. Even if you're a techie making $200k a year, but without a buffer, you will have a huge problem if something unexpected happens. Of course why you wouldn't have a buffer if you make that much money is a different problem. But hey, Mike Tyson was making millions and when the shit hit the fan, he went bankrupt in a heartbeat.
- sologoub 12y agoThese ar two separate issues and I think the original comment makes the point that sure it will be plannable, but simply not enough. The article says as much also when it notes that this offering won't help those with insufficient overall incomes. The AU example is fascinating, because if true, it really does feel like healthier society.
- kamaal 12y ago>>Of course why you wouldn't have a buffer if you make that much money is a different problem. That is the problem. Even in the example of unpredictable income you gave two posts above. If you spending all the money you are earning(even if variable) just because you are earning it a little extra every month. Something is badly broken in the way you live your life. You are essentially not solving any problem at all, all you are doing is delaying your problems one month at a time. Someday that will blow up in your face. And when it does you will back to all the problems you had started with or may be even worse. You should never be earning to make ends meet(That only delays problems, doesn't solve them). You should be earning towards a framework which enables you to do away with working to make a living(a.k.a retirement).
- nilkn 12y agoThe most horrifying thing is that not only do minimum wage jobs in the US barely get you above poverty, but that many people struggle even to get one of these jobs. I'm willing to wager that many readers here have never looked for a minimum wage job. If you haven't, you may not realize how much competition there can be. It's really shocking. This is especially true in smaller towns, where there are very few jobs that aren't minimum wage. I remember, years ago when I was in high school, my dad was a local business owner in a small town and was connected with all the other business owners. On several occasions, a friend or family member needed a minimum wage job and literally couldn't get one due to scarcity; my dad had to approach the owners of other businesses and put in direct recommendations so someone could get on at, say, a Dairy Queen or a car wash.
- Retra 12y agoI've looked for minimum wage jobs. Never worked one: I'm too "over qualified."
- kefka 12y agoThe trick to that is make yourself "qualified", if you want to work one. Holes in employment, sketchy details, questionable descriptions. Or you could go the complete opposite route, and blatantly lie on your resume. As long as you actually know the skills, lie and say you have them. What's the worst they do to you? Fire you? Just don't do that with a professional degree. Pissing off gov't is a bad idea.
- Xixi 12y agoIf the job market is really that, a market, then it should not come as a surprise. It's the imbalance between the number the people seeking a kind of job and the number of jobs available that drives the salaries all the way down to minimum wage. Hence the lowest paying of all jobs are the most fiercely fought for. Now of course there is another side to this equation: the remuneration is capped by the (perceived) value derived from the work done.
- nilkn 12y ago
- comrh 12y agoAbilify, a medication for bipolar disorder, is $200 with insurance, over $1000 without. What do we expect people to do?
- brc 12y agoAustralia is no picnic. The main cities cluster in the top 10 most expensive places to live in the world. The Australian demographic time bomb is starting to go off, as well. The amount of healthcare and aged care spending is starting to take off like a rocket and this will-inevitably- lead to reductions in eligibility and payments, including what treatments are avialable from the health system. What Australia does have is a lack of a large poverty stricken underclass, mainly because of the last 50-100 years of the countries history, which includes a lot of prosperity from agriculture and mining so that just about everyone has always had a job and intergenerational poverty has not been able to get a wide hold. Those things are not guaranteed to last forever. Australia might just look like California in the 1950s right now, with a troubled future ahead.
- switch007 12y ago> and this will-inevitably- lead to reductions in eligibility and payments, including what treatments are avialable from the health system. I was in Oz a couple of weeks ago and the government announced they're "reviewing" Medicare. The way they kept stressing that they're working with doctors and it's not a cost-cutting exercise made it painfully obvious they're going to do cost-cutting.
- brc 12y agoVarious governments of various political flavours have tried stuffing the genie back into the bottle but the public doesn't want any part of it, fanned on by whoever is the political opposite at the time. Introducing a co-payment for a doctors visit (last proposal was $5, I think) was considered to be the end of the world. Of course everyone understands that if you give something away for free, you have to produce more of it, and nobody wants taxes to go up any further, so the can gets kicked down the road. It has to happen sooner or later. You can avoid most things except for demographics.
- megablast 12y ago> The main cities cluster in the top 10 most expensive places to live in the world. This is mainly because the Aussie dollar was so high for so long, things haven't caught up yet. Pay is a lot higher in Australia as well, with a high minimum wage.
- tesin 12y agoI'm from Melbourne, living in Boston. There's an entire middle class waiting to explode. There's rampant underemployment, rising credit card debt, and my entire generation has given up on the notion of ever fully owning a home. There's many many reasons why I moved to the U.S.