6 ms·
This shutdown - and some of the comments here that indicate how nasty Secret had become before it died - is quite interesting in light of the conversation surro
by nostrademons 12y ago
This shutdown - and some of the comments here that indicate how nasty Secret had become before it died - is quite interesting in light of the conversation surrounding Google's Real Names Only policy.
Secret cofounders David Byttow and Chris Bader-Wechseler were both veterans of Google+. Byttow, in particular, I recall being quite well-respected as someone who got shit done, quietly and efficiently, by the rest of the G+ team. I didn't know him personally, but I had a few professional dealings with him where I found him to be a straight-shooter that was remarkably effective and helpful. When I heard of the product concept for Secret, my first thought was "Woah, somebody's finally decided to take the other side of the stupid Real Names policy and build a social network that's completely anonymous."
Apparently that doesn't work either, and when you do that, people hate you just as much.
My take-away from this is that social software is remarkably hard, and that whatever you do, people will hate you. The social sites that survive - like Reddit, Flickr, and Facebook - are those that very carefully balance everyone's competing desires, making just enough changes to keep everyone slightly disgruntled but not enough to leave the site. The ones that die - like Secret, G+, LiveJournal - are the ones that either do nothing to moderate or that introduce heavy-handed blanket policies. (4chan, as always, remains inexplicable; somehow it is still going strong despite being a cesspool. Maybe that's the whole point of it, though, to be the Internet's honey pot of bad behavior.)
- maxerickson 12y ago4chan isn't a cesspool though, that's just an image they project to push away people who would respond to such pushing (approximately, the olds). (There are certainly parts of it that are risky clicks though)
- zachalexander 12y agoUsually when people say "4chan" I assume they mean /b/.
- rtpg 12y ago/v/, /jp/, /pol/, and so many other boards are extremely toxic in behavior as well. There's some interesting stuff, but it's behind layers of "2edgy4u" behavior of people trying to out-insult each other.
- lmm 12y agoThat's what keeps them interesting, honestly. I see the edginess as a kind of intelligence test: only people who are smart enough to ignore offensive content need apply.
- Ntrails 12y agoI'd take goatse spam, arguments about hitler being a decent enough chap, and FYAD flames in that sort of environment over twitter where the threats seem real, because most of those sending don't seem to be in on the fact it is all a big joke. Maybe it's just me - but I think the irreverent self-aware toxicity has it's advantages.
- joshguthrie 12y agoI agree with this sentiment. 4chan's /b/ is seen as "the cesspool" and nobody tries to make it better because nobody wants it to be better. It just needs to be that place where the EMT that spent his day dealing with life and death can relieve his stress and let go of what's plaguing his mind with "lol, tits or gtfo"[1]. Because in the end, it's all a big joke. 1: Can't find back the exact screenshot were a /b/ user was saying this, sorry.
- simias 12y agoI think 4chan survives thanks to its smaller communities. The big boards tend to turn into cesspool once a critical mass is reached (/b/ of course but also /v/ and /pol/, maybe others I'm less familiar with). Even in big boards if you're lucky it's sometimes possible to find an interesting thread if the subject is not too controversial. I'll still take that over reddit though, on 4chan people feel more genuine, for better or worse.
- angersock 12y ago/b/, /pol/, arguably /v/ are all containment boards. They've never been good, they'll never be good, etc. The reason 4chan has survived has been that it promotes anonymity and hence genuine expression. After dealing with it, for a while, you get to kind of know different types of people. You can go to a containment board and find people that are genuinely, for example, homophobic and antisemetic with complete seriousness. They compete for space with people that are just trolling, and both compete with some genuinely level-headed people. It's fascinating to watch. Meanwhile, in other boards, you'll find people snarking over guns (/k/), bicycles (/n/), anime (/a/), otaku and general Hikikomori behavior (/jp/), making things (/diy/), and on and on. Because everything is anonymous and the boards move so fast, there's no advantage to the sorts of politics and forking you see in Reddit or whatever--instead, you just develop a sort of hang-out culture and occasionally interact with invaders. It's fun.
- Yhippa 12y agoBy containment board do you mean like a theme that serves as a sink for those types of users so they don't bleed into the more general topics?
- angersock 12y agoYep. Unlike other more oppressive moderation schemes (cough reddit hackernews cough), 4chan just accepts as cost of doing business that people are going to want to be shitheads. So, you have boards specifically for people wanting to be shitheads. Over time, that becomes board culture, and often raises to a level of self-parody that they become easy to spot when they leak. Imagine, if you will, an island whose sole form of humor is hyperbolically racist, sexist, classist, or materialist. If you can contort yourself into that headspace and engage the art on its own terms, it is a never-ending source of creativity and amusement. The best part is, if it shows up somewhere else, you can just tell them to "go back to <whatever>", and they don't get a persecution complex about it, because they're not being censored.
- testguy34 12y agoModeration on 4chan and /b/ has increased over the last year. Mostly to prevent the posting of peoples personal information. But the posting of shock images has also decreased. I don't know if they are being removed as well.
- Giorgi 12y agoYes, so-called "Social Justice Warriors" took over and made once uncensored board into heavily censored tumbr.
- nyolfen 12y agoif preventing doxxing is your idea of social justice i have some news that will confuse you
- 0x15_faces 12y agoOne visit to /pol/ will show you how incorrect you are about increased moderation and lack of free posting.
- GhotiFish 12y agoMootles himself said that the reason 4chan works is because people make terrible asses of themselves every once in a while, and despite that can still contribute to society and culture. Anonimity ensures that even if you do fuck up, you still arn't ostracized, the benefit being that you will take risks and maybe make something amazing. The idea of individually singling someone out to make their lives miserable, for something stupid they've done, seems anathema to 4chan's culture. Or at least what makes 4chan's culture work. I see no problem with 4chan's mods removing dox. You're an idiot, so are we all, but people don't forgive as easily as they should. So have an upvote, make another post, and try again! Stick around Giorgi.
- eruditely 12y agoIt actually is. It depends on that community you are talking about, but after several years of on and off I completely disagree.
- derefr 12y agoI would phrase it as, "the default/most-well-known subforums of any forum will be garbage once the site reaches critical mass, being diluted by new members too quickly to keep their character. A proliferation of smaller subforums with their own effective communities will displace the sense that the site has any worthwhile/coherent community taken as a whole." Applies equally to 4chan and Reddit.
- bostonvaulter2 12y agoOne name for this is Eternal September: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternal_September http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternal_September
- Nemcue 12y agoNot entirely true. Some of the very large subreddits such as /games and /askscience have actually retained very high quality. They just require very strict rules and heavy moderation. Just compare the frontpage of http://reddit.com/r/gaming http://reddit.com/r/gaming with http://reddit.com/r/games http://reddit.com/r/games — granted one is about twice as big as the other in terms of active users, but /gaming has been full of low-quality submissions since before it became a default subreddit. It just comes down to having proper rules and enforcing them. Now, reddit and 4chan are very different in the regard of perceived quality. If you heavily moderate a subreddit the low-quality submissions will for the most part only be viewed by those that browse the queue of new submissions. This isn't really true with 4chan since the low-quality submissions that are buried will still be viewed by everyone (although this kind of depends on if you've configured the order of submissions). As an interesting aside, you can actually significantly impact what submissions get buried in a subreddit with very few votes since there's not a lot of people that browse the new-queue.
- sethbannon 12y agoI'm not so sure it's wise to call G+ a "dead" social network. According to recent research by Pew, it's more popular than Twitter and just as popular as LinkedIn. http://www.journalism.org/2014/10/21/section-2-social-media-political-news-and-ideology/ http://www.journalism.org/2014/10/21/section-2-social-media-...
- frostmatthew 12y agoDepends how they define "use" - as this article[1] points out "Technically, tons of people use Google+, since logging into it gives you access to Gmail, Google Drive, and all of Google's other apps." If the numbers there are right and only 4-6 million people are using it as a social network it isn't very surprising that Google would be "giving up on pitching Google+ as a social network" [1] http://www.businessinsider.com/what-happened-to-google-plus-2015-4 http://www.businessinsider.com/what-happened-to-google-plus-...
- barrkel 12y agoIt's currently impossible to create a Youtube playlist without a G+ profile. Every time I want to create a new playlist, I create a new G+ profile, then delete it immediately afterwards. It is tedious. I'm sure many other people, when faced with roadblocks like these, create a do-nothing profile but don't bother deleting afterwards.
- dools 12y agoI made this a few years ago: http://www.cueyoutube.com/ http://www.cueyoutube.com/
- hackuser 12y ago> I'm sure many other people, when faced with roadblocks like these, create a do-nothing profile but don't bother deleting afterwards. Or don't use playlists and find other websites.
- rjaco31 12y agoIt's pretty hard to find as much content as Youtube elsewhere, from experience all the youtube-wannabe websites have tremendously less content. Or do you have a link?
- nyamhap 12y agoThe reason 4chan works is that 4chan itself is very like-minded. Secret attracted too broad an audience and scared off the quality content creators as bad content started rising. Divergence of 'like-mindedness' among different social groups was just too large for one feed.
- sergiotapia 12y ago4Chan is not going strong, in fact a large majority of their core users have migrated to 8Chan because of Moot's brainwashing by SJW.
- mahouse 12y agoThat was certainly a really bad move—Obviously people were very pissed off.
- oldmanjay 12y agoI hate that I have this reaction; when I read things like this, I can't help but feel that you're a 14 year old who accidentally found your way into the adult Internet. Welcome! Please try to not be a jerk here. We aren't 4chan.
- lmm 12y agoYour comment is superficially more polite than the typical 4chan post - but actually it's even less constructive (and perpetuates the horrible stereotyping of younger people). There's no way to respond - nothing to refute, not even anything helpful if you do agree.
- Giorgi 12y agoYeah, except 4chan is not what it used to be, main user base abandoned the ship long ago.
- ameister14 12y agowell, I don't think you can say that's because of the caustic nature of the site or because of how it's now moderated more strictly
- BillyParadise 12y ago...or maybe the members grew up?
- yuhong 12y agoI remember the threads on Vic Gundotra on Secret. And yes I agree that the decision to use real names or be anonymous in general should be left to the poster.
- ChuckMcM 12y ago> My take-away from this is that social software is > remarkably hard, ... Agreed > and that whatever you do, people will hate you. Disagree. I think it is remarkably difficult to create a functional community, and it is impossible to do that if you don't understand how communities work. In particular, successful communities often have places where similar members can congregate and effectively shun people who don't fit in. Call it a clique, call it a subreddit, but really its about finding a mental space to be.
- saraid216 12y agoA clique, a subreddit, a treehouse, a coffeehouse, a salon, a third place, a safe space, inside the magic circle...
- Retra 12y agoI wonder if anybody has made a 'choose your own community' site. You choose how many people you're given access to (say, 100, 10K, 100K, 1M+) and the only information you get is from those who are nearest to you in location and interests (based on an adjustable scoring algorithm) and anybody you've previously conversed with. Smaller communities could make for more specialized content, and everybody living on the edge of a bubble means theres plenty of opportunity for valuing middleman-style culture sharing (AKA reposts.)
- nostrademons 12y agoSubreddits, right?
- lnanek2 12y agoSeems like a big success to me. The founders each took 3 million cash off the table on investment and now are closing up the company. Corporations are just a vehicle to make money after all, they got their pay day and ran.
- jackgavigan 12y agoQuestion is, will any VC want to fund them again in the future?
- kidgorgeous 12y agodoesn't matter, had sex
- raverbashing 12y agoA lot of VCs funded Color, so I don't see why
- speby 12y agoThere are almost certainly rules/stipulations around the money that was taken off the table by the founders in their funding round. It most certainly was tied to vested equity, at an absolute minimum, rather than granted as something such as a one-time bonus with no strings attached. I would be surprised if the founders get to contractually retain the entire $3MM taken off the table in that funding round. It is possible that this is the case (and so maybe not so surprising) but given the often unique terms in startup funding, I would be surprised if this were the case here.
- wyclif 12y agoHere we go with the long-dismissed "Google+ Is Dead!" meme again.
- rajacombinator 12y agoThe nastiness was the distinctive feature. Once they killed that it marked the beginning of the end.