8 ms·
'Cut-through' traffic caused by Waze app must stop, L.A. councilman says
- acadien 12y agoJust once it would be great to read a headline like: "Traffic congestion spurs realization that enhanced public transit is sorely needed in high density population zones" instead of: "City council continues to make short sighted decisions that don't help anyone"
- spacemanmatt 12y agoBlaming Waze is blaming information, because that's all Waze can provide. I'm sure it plays well with his constituency, though.
- jusben1369 12y agoI think blaming Waze is blaming an imbalance in the system. One side of the equation has leapt ahead of the other via technology and now there's an imbalance. Technology tends to take fairly steady state systems in equilibrium and turn them on their head for awhile.
- scelerat 12y agoWaze is more than information. It provides directions to drivers, with the promise of speeding a commute. It appeals directly to people in a hurry, and it directs them through residential neighborhoods not designed for through traffic. A reasonable hypothesis would be that greater Waze use would correlate to higher numbers of accidents in residential neighborhoods.
- RickHull 12y ago> Waze is more than information. Nope. In this respect (transportation routes), it is quite literally and merely information. It does not make promises.
- scelerat 12y agoWaze has synthesized voice instructions to "turn left at Oak Glen Circle." I call that "direction." You call it "information." Potayto, Potahto? Also, "promise," meaning indicative of potential.
- spacemanmatt 12y agoAll are functions of the information. Take away the information, and all those things go with it.
- spacemanmatt 12y agoWaze is a consumer DSS (decision support system) and as such delivers valuable, decision-affecting information. But it is limited to information. Directions to drivers, promise of speeding a commute, appeal to people in a hurry, directions through residential neighborhoods: All data.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Waze is more than information. It provides directions to drivers, with the promise of speeding a commute. That is no more than information. That is exactly information -- information about the most efficient route from one's location to one's destination. So, yes, blaming Waze is blaming information. If there is blame to be assigned for residential roads being part of the most efficient route between two points that are outside of those roads locale, it belongs to those responsible for the design of the road system, not to the app providing information about the results of that design in the current traffic environment.
- fjabre 12y agoI can just open up a google map and do it manually. I do that now. Waze just makes it easier. If you don't want traffic congestion you might consider not living in Los Angeles.
- SEJeff 12y agoOr perhaps the city council should fix the actual underlying problem... That their road systems can't really cope with the amount of traffic they have currently.
- malvim 12y agoOr that their cities can't really cope with the amount of people they currently have.
- iwwr 12y agoOr that cities need to get more dense and friendlier toward pedestrians and bikes.
- jusben1369 12y agoIt's simply a personal preference for dense cities vs being an absolute truth.
- mikeash 12y agoDenser cities are demonstrably better off and more efficient.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Denser cities are demonstrably better off and more efficient. "Better off" is a matter of subjective value, and the fact that lots of people prefer not to live in denser cities demonstrates that the measures by which denser cities are "better off" do not represent universally-shared values.
- sjg007 12y agoLol.. Welcome to Los Angeles. Traffic is and has always been bad and cut throughs always have happened. This is not new or news.
- bgun 12y agoContributing to a discussion about how to ameliorate the situation would be more welcome than "that's just how it is" dismissal.
- Semiapies 12y agoNot really. All we have is a bunch of commenters, the most vocal from outside the area, hand-waving and saying officials should just fix the problem. Realities of settlement, infrastructure, and politics stand against just waving a magic wand, though. Also, just saying "transit" is saying absolutely nothing without demonstrating that one knows the difference between the layouts of NYC and Greater LA.
- jamra 12y agoYou're right. I don't think the non Los Angeleans really understand the layout of LA. It's not a city like NY is a city. Politics are stopping us from developing better public transportation options. Blaming people for trying to stay out of 2 hour traffic is not the right approach.
- bkeroack 12y agoThis is an example of the NIMBYism that's unfortunately common here. The homes in the areas with the worst traffic (ie, Westside) are very expensive (>$1million) and are also usually in hilly areas with twisty, narrow streets. While I can't blame the residents for hating the extra traffic, OTOH at peak times of day the main thoroughfares are almost literally nonfunctional due to congestion. I drove for three hours yesterday morning and went a total of maybe 8-10 miles--and that was avoiding the freeways and using 'secret' backroad shortcuts. We really need to get serious about stopping subsidies for freeways and other outdated modes of transporation, and instead fund efficient, modern mass transit. Roads designed for single passenger cars are the steam engines of the 21st century.
- dudifordMann 12y agoThis may very well be reflective of my ignorance of that area, but would a bicycle not suffice for an 8 to 10 mile trip? If an average speed of a bicycle is say 10mph, then you've already cut your time by two hours! Of course.. I believe most American cities and roadways are not well designed for commuter cyclists. Perhaps we need a serious look into the bike highways of Copenhagen.
- lavamantis 12y agoThe mayor has a plan for LA. Opinions are mixed, but at least someone is trying to do something. http://la.streetsblog.org/2015/04/08/garcetti-unveils-sustainable-city-plan-includes-transportation-and-livability-goals/ http://la.streetsblog.org/2015/04/08/garcetti-unveils-sustai...
- marssaxman 12y agoIn California? it'd work for half the year; the other half, you'd die of heatstroke.
- dudifordMann 12y agoInteresting point. I'm on the west coast, and our summers tend to be much hotter, and winters much colder. So I suppose, not only bike friendly roads are needed, but also a whole biking culture would need to be established to allow employees to change into work clothing from weather sensitive bike gear... hmmm, complexities...
- chollida1 12y agoThis is the same problem that technology always brings. The "you could do it before but required alot of work and now the technology makes it so anyone can do it" problem. Google made this famous by allowing anyone to learn more than people wanted other to know about themselves. The information was all there before google but google made it easy for anyone to collect with little effort. To the home owners point, I do find myself doing this alot with waze in Toronto. Instead of taking Gardener or Front Street, waze sends me through the CNE grounds on streets that i didn't even now existed. I could have probably done this before waze but the technology made it easy for anyone to do. It seems like the solution is the do what they've always done, improve core infrastructure arteries and put up speed bumps, slower speed limits and more stop signs to help deter people from moving through residential neighbourhoods.
- mauricemir 12y agospeed bumps sound ok until: A some one looses a $3k exhaust system on a sports car to them B Someone dies because of slow ambulance response - Emergency vehicle crews hate speed bumps
- kinghajj 12y agoThe speed bumps around my old neighborhood have a dip in the median exactly so that ambulances can avoid the bump completely. I was told that it's also a safety concern, as sudden shocks when carrying, say, someone with a spinal injury could actually be life-threatening. (Un)fortunately, it's also perfectly possible for ordinary cars to use the dip, too, and thus not have to slow down really at all.
- jusben1369 12y agoUggh. Speed bumps and more stop signs. I read somewhere once that nothing does more to cause car pollution than the innocent looking stop sign.
- ljd 12y agoI've lived in Los Angeles for the last 5 years and I can tell you that Waze really uses neighborhood routes in the hills, which coincides with the most affluent residents in LA. Unfortunatelly, Los Angeles is built with 3-4 choke points to get from the reasonably priced suburbs in San Fernando Valley to the companies that pay for $100k+ positions on the west side and mid-wilshire. Waze helps alleviate that traffic and I not surprised that a politician here in LA is so out of touch that he would recommend shutting down a tool most people use to get to work so that the wealthy can have less traffic noise outside their house at 8am. Streets are public domain, and until I'm relieved of my road tax liabilities I intend on using any one I choose.
- leephillips 12y agoUntil they put up signs forbidding rush hour traffic for non-residents of the street. At least, that's what they do around here (DC area).
- StillBored 12y agoAnd hire the off duty sheriff (with HOA fees) to enforce it like the neighborhood I cut through does...
- bkeroack 12y agoThere are a few streets off Sunset Boulevard with signs posted: "Dead end street after 10pm". Makes me chuckle every time I go by.
- berns 12y agoAnd how is it enforced? Do they ask "where are you going"? Can you answer "none of your business"? I never lived in the US but I refuse to abandon my mental image of the free country I always thought it was.
- tptacek 12y agoThey pull you over, and if you don't live in the immediate vicinity, you get a ticket. It's happened to me several times in Oak Park, and I live there! You could say "none of your business". You'll get the ticket, and, if its really unjustified, you can go fight it in traffic court.
- jamra 12y agoSo the statement is to stop cut through traffic in stead of fixing the broken LA system. How about we offer acceptable public transportation alternatives such as a proper metro and more frequent busses?
- eli 12y agoWhy not just put up "No Through Traffic" or "Local Traffic Only" signs as many other cities do?
- fiatmoney 12y agoThey're just about unenforceable.
- eli 12y agoWell, I got a ticket for it once -- only traffic ticket I've ever received. So not entirely unenforceable. I think most people at least make an effort to not break clearly marked traffic laws. And anyway, it seems tough to complain about people taking a driving shortcut that's perfectly legal.
- dragonwriter 12y agoOr, adopt the more common (and also pre-GPS) solution of just designing residential neighborhoods (or refitting existing roads with strategically placed auto-traffic barriers) so that they aren't usable for cut-through auto traffic, but still perfectly usable for ingress/egress and for through traffic by pedestrians/bicycles. Complaining that people are using public roads that connect their origin with their destination to travel from that origin to that destination is, well, bizarre.
- eli 12y agoProbably the right answer, but that sounds like multiple orders of magnitude more difficult than putting up some signs and/or posting a cop to write some tickets. Also, I assume the people who live in those neighborhoods would want still want their houses easily reachable by car.
- bryanlarsen 12y agoMy preferred solution would be 15 mph speed limits, strictly enforced. A car-pedestrian collision is highly unlikely to be fatal below 15-20mph, so it achieves the purpose of making the streets "safe for children". Some people would still cut through at 15 mph, but it would limit that traffic to the really bad times. And it would slow down local traffic, who are much more likely to be using the streets at the time children are playing.
- cmsmith 12y agoI'll be the first to say here that if this effect is actually supported by data, and not just anecdotes, then the councilman has a good point. It's rude and dangerous to cut through residential neighborhoods to save one or two minutes off of your car trip, and mapping apps shouldn't be so quick to direct you to do so. Pedestrians and cyclists have already lost access to major roads (see invention of jaywalking, etc), but it was OK since we could still take walks in our neighborhood. If every road is open to its full traffic capacity, the only safe place to be is in a car.
- ohitsdom 12y ago1 - 2 minutes, sure. But what about 20-30 mins? Would it be OK then?
- kajecounterhack 12y agoThe gov't needs to build more roads or provide better mass transit. If main thoroughfares were doing their jobs then we wouldn't have this problem.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Its rude and dangerous to cut through residential neighborhoods to save one or two minutes off of your car trip, and mapping apps shouldn't be so quick to direct you to do so. No, its not rude to use public roads to get between points connected by those roads, nor is it dangerous provided you are driving in a safe manner (and, if you are driving in an unsafe manner, that's a problem no matter why you are on those roads -- just as much if you are doing it to get to or from your home that is on the road as if you are using it to get between two points that the road happens to connect.)
- maxerickson 12y agoSure it's rude. It's also okay for opinions on the matter to differ.
- Goronmon 12y ago...if you are driving in an unsafe manner, that's a problem no matter why you are on those roads So, then, let's assume that apps like Waze do cause a larger number of unsafe drivers to cut through residential areas. How do we fix that problem?
- rmxt 12y ago"No thru traffic" signs have been a part of life for a long time, long before Waze came around, and that's the simplest answer to the issue for these residents. [1] Yes, as other posters have pointed out, this is an instance of technology butting up against entrenched interests and behaviors: the shortcuts formerly only known by a few, are now available to anybody with a smartphone; rich residents get mad at the increased traffic, and political action happens quicker when rich people are involved. [2,3] Whether or not this is an example of the rich getting their way more quickly than the average person, I think that the point about residential areas seeing increased through traffic is an important one. No one, whether rich or poor, wants to live on a heavily trafficked street. (I believe that it is possible to create environments that contain both successful transportation infrastructure and livable streets for all people.) The answer, however, isn't to shut these roads off to thru traffic (an exercise in futility), but rather to create better routes for people to get to work. Whether these routes are better mass transit options, better new roads, or improvements to existing roads, they will all, unfortunately, be uphill battles against NIMBYers. Hopefully LA, and the US in general, can eventually come around from the car-dominated perception of the urban environment. [1] http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?t=236446 http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?t=236446 [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Los_Angeles_City_Council_District_2 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Los_Angeles_City_Council_Distr... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/San_Fernando_Valley#Property_values https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/San_Fernando_Valley#Property_v...
- michael_h 12y agoAs my Dad says, "'Thru' is not a word I recognize. Let's cut through here."
- scelerat 12y agoPart of me is with this councilmember: cities put effort into planning and zoning for the benefits of all citizens, not just those who are driving automobiles. Another part of me says, traffic has gotten bad because transportation infrastructure is bad, and a big chunk of that is this councilmember's job. So if he's complaining about the traffic, he also ought to be working on some solutions. More convenient public transportation, better bikeways, etc. I've had this same thought using Waze to avoid afternoon traffic in Silicon Valley when it took me through residential neighborhoods with kids playing in the streets and past schools.. Overall, if you're regularly diverting your commute from designated thoroughfares through residential neighborhoods, wealthy or not, I'm gonna call you a self-absorbed jerk.
- mikeash 12y agoWhat's a "designated thoroughfare"? I'm not sure I've seen such a beast. In my opinion, what's self-absorbed is buying a house on a public road that can be used as part of a longer trip, and then getting upset when people actually use it. If you don't want outsiders driving through your neighborhood, move some place which is off the beaten path, or where you can put up gates or something. This will be less convenient for you, but that's the tradeoff that comes from making things less convenient for others.
- scelerat 12y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arterial_road http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arterial_road
- jefurii 12y agoThis would be less of a problem if companies didn't all feel they had to be located in Santa Monica and West LA. Maybe the head office absolutely has to be on the Westside because of the cool address, but what about satellite offices around the city, closer to where people live? Or better yet, just evolve the corporate culture and embrace working remote.
- Semiapies 12y agoOr maybe looking outside of LA and SF entirely.
- dragonwriter 12y agoInstead of trying to have Waze direct people into less efficient routes, shouldn't the L.A. city council use the data provided about how roads are being used to address the fact that the "major roads" that are intended to be the efficient routes between distant locations are, in fact, not doing their jobs.
- jamespitts 12y agoI hope that this problem encourages LA's more elite residents to strongly support a subway underneath the 405. Poorer residents in the flats have long suffered this effect adjacent to freeways. But whatever the class of residents affected is, to mis-use streets intended for local neighborhood activity is terrible behavior. Due to where things are headed technologically, it is only a matter of time before the city simply automatically charges drivers fines for driving inappropriate routes.
- jamra 12y agoWhy stop there? We have enough money in LA to build a metro on or around the 101 and 405. We don't need five lanes if we reduce the cars on the road.