4 ms·
Why Employee Benefits Will Become Irrelevant
- mauricemir 12y agoAuthor doesn't seem to have a clue about how benefits are taxed or that an employer can buy insurance or other benefits for 1000 people cheaper than any of the individuals can. And are not Employer DC pensions better because that contributions on both sides are pre tax - let alone if you go in for sacrifice schemes where you can save the NI (social security) as well. and this guys supposed to be a partner reads like some summer interns work to me
- prostoalex 12y ago> an employer can buy insurance or other benefits for 1000 people cheaper than any of the individuals can. Does that still hold true with the exchanges, which in large states supposedly pool millions of individuals?
- dzdt 12y agoI think so, and here is why it makes sense. Maintaining a steady employment is a pretty strong indicator of not having debilitating health problems and of having enough income to avoid poverty-driven health problems. The employee pool of a major corporation is probably a healthier pool than the one exchanges serve.
- mauricemir 12y agoYes a Company with 1000's of employees can drive a better bargain than a single individual.
- a3n 12y agoOnly because employers are buying benefits for 1000 people. I would love a world where the only thing we get from an employer is pay and experience, and where there are no tax breaks for anything except being a poor human.
- mauricemir 12y agoSo there would be no incentive for people to save into a pension or take equity over $ If you tax income and capita gains the same there is NO incentive to invest in equity as there is no risk premium.
- a3n 12y agoYes, people would still save out of necessity. And maybe people wouldn't take equity over dollars, or maybe they would, but it would be done for reasons other than tax policy. The market would have to work harder to prove that it's a good investment. Income vs capital gains taxation: again, the market would have to work harder to prove that it's a good investment. Or to put it another way: "there is NO incentive to invest in equity [without preferential tax treatment]." Then maybe investment in equity isn't actually a good investment in and of itself.
- markbnj 12y ago>> giving way to an alternative where employers simply pay employees in full for services rendered, and employees are left to make their own decisions –for better or worse–about where and how to allocate those dollars for their needs. That is so completely disingenuous. I think we can assume that blog writers at the WSJ are aware that wages have been stagnant for the majority of workers for over two decades, despite significant gains in productivity. So, really, what they meant to say was "giving way to an alternative where employers stop paying for benefits."
- mkirlin 12y agoYep. If anything like this actually happens, there isn't a chance in hell that money's getting funneled into the pockets of the employees.
- DamnYuppie 12y agoCurrently employers get better rates for their benefits then an individual can on the open market. As such this will open the flood gates for even higher insurance premiums, seems like a wind fall to the insurance providers. This is similar to the push away from pensions to 401k's in the 70's and 80's. It was supposed to be great for the individuals, more flexibility and control, can take it from job to job. Yet instead it was great for the financial services industry as they got to charge a higher service fees on their mutual funds to more people. The only people to lose out where the employees as the companies got reduced liabilities and payouts and the financial services sector go a large bump in service fees....
- nulltype 12y agoCould employees of different companies form a group that could get better rates? One of the problems with 401ks is that they are still related to your employer.
- ibealexm 12y agoYes - it's called a government. Pretty much all other countries already have such healthcare plans in place.
- danans 12y agoIf done well, this could empower employees to decouple critical life needs (health insurance, retirement) from their employers. If done poorly (i.e. the non-employer options and tax benefits are not good), then it will just create a 2-tier system where you have a class of workers with great benefits, and those with terrible ones... Oh wait, that's what we have now, right?
- nsxwolf 12y agoTake away the tax incentives and let the market readjust. Imagine if employers provided our food directly and all the issues that would result from that. And then imagine what would happen if someone suggested ending that - we'd hear about how employers can buy food at a bulk discount, tax breaks, everyone's going to starve, etc. Getting employers out of the health insurance game also conveniently dispenses with controversies like the HHS contraception mandate/Hobby Lobby etc.
- matthewowen 12y agoObviously I wish we lived in a world where health care wasn't coupled to employment, but I don't think the USA is adopting single payer any time soon so I don't really have high hopes. However, one practical thing that I find infuriating is the 401k/IRA system. It's absurd to me that if your employer doesn't offer a 401k there's a whole category of tax advantaged retirement saving that's off limits to you, and you're stuck to the IRA contribution limits (and income limits).
- scott00 12y agoEmployee benefits will become irrelevant if and only if (1) the government removes the tax advantage of providing certain benefits to employees over providing the value of those benefits to employees in cash, and (2) the government resolves the market failures innate to certain types of insurance. The ACA went a long way to resolving (2) for health insurance, but similar forces are at play in the life insurance and disability insurance markets.
- Jtsummers 12y ago> All it really means is that instead of an employer paying $X on behalf of an employee for a certain benefit, the employer pays the employee that same dollar amount and allows him/her to use the dollars as desired toward their own selection of benefits, from retirement to health insurance and more. This money is usually pre-tax. Let's say an office worker is making $80k/year + benefits and pays about 25% to taxes. If those benefits amount to $10k (feasible between 401k matching, insurance and other things) the employer needs to come up with an extra $3.33k to pay the employee to compensate for the tax owed on the extra income.
- nulltype 12y agoCould health care payments be tax deductible?
- prostoalex 12y ago"If you paid your health insurance premiums with your own after-tax money, they’re deductible." http://healthinsurance.about.com/od/savingmoneyonhealthcare/fl/Is-Health-Insurance-Tax-Deductible.htm http://healthinsurance.about.com/od/savingmoneyonhealthcare/... With a bunch of caveats, of course.
- Jtsummers 12y agoAh, thanks. This would still be an issue with some other benefits unless they also are tax deductible or made tax deductible for individuals. My 5% matching on my 401(k), in particular, would be an issue without increasing the tax deduction limits on 401(k)s.
- prostoalex 12y agoIt does make sense for the government to (a) allow for insurance premiums to be paid out of flexible spending accounts, (b) decouple pre-tax FSAs from employment and make them available to anybody. Not sure why it's not part of the ACA, perhaps there are some unintended consequences (a) would cause.