6 ms·
Transgender game developer jumps off bridge after online abuse
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- smhenderson 12y agoAnd here you are on hacker news using it to push yours.
- fwn 12y agoHey smhenderson, I'm embarrassed to ask you but I get harassed by someone who thinks I was the person you replied to. He is convinced I was the person and tries to engage me in an argument about gamer gate. However: Can you remember to whom you replied? This would be a tremendous help for me, he already followed me to a different thread.
- DonHopkins 12y agoJust set "showdead" to "yes" and you can see that smhenderson replied "And here you are on hacker news using it to push yours." to fwn's post here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9458661 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9458661 And you can see that the last post in fwn's history now says "Ok, I feel like I'm on /r/all ..." and is downvoted to be light gray: https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=fwn https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=fwn As anyone can see, when a hacker news user deletes a post, it still shows it to people who have "showdead" set to "yes", followed by the string "[deleted]". He edited it to replace the original comment that smhenderson replied to, but fwn's downvoted comment and smhenderson's reply are all still there. That's how hacker news work. The ball is in fwn's court to explain why his post was so badly downvoted, what it originally said, why he deleted it, what he meant by editing it to say "Ok, I feel like I'm on /r/all ..." before deleting it, and why he then lied point blank twice that "Also I did not edit anything recently, I really think this is a mistake." and "I - still - did not edit anything in the thread you mentioned." So I'm confident that I know that fwn has stopped being honest. The fact that you can't delete postings was designed on purpose by Paul Graham to keep editors honest. But fnw is denying the evidence and blustering instead, which is a pretty good indication that he's the kind of person who would exploit the tragic suicide of a transgendered person to push their misogynistic gamer gate agenda, which is behavior that doesn't belong on hacker news. So the system is working as it was designed. http://www.paulgraham.com/hackernews.html http://www.paulgraham.com/hackernews.html >"I think it's important that a site that kills submissions provide a way for users to see what got killed if they want to. That keeps editors honest, and just as importantly, makes users confident they'd know if the editors stopped being honest. HN users can do this by flipping a switch called showdead in their profile." -Paul Graham
- DanBC 12y ago> Just set "showdead" to "yes" and you can see that smhenderson replied "And here you are on hacker news using it to push yours." to fwn's post here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9458661 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9458661 No. Fwn wrote a post. ("I feel like I'm on /r/all".). That post got flagged and is now dead. Someone made a different post, and smhenderson replied to this other post. That person then deleted their post. > The fact that you can't delete postings You can delete posts. You've made a mistake. > As anyone can see, when a hacker news user deletes a post, it still shows it to people who have "showdead" set to "yes", followed by the string "[deleted]" No! You can see that a post was deleted. You can't see the deleted post.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- DonHopkins 12y agoOk, your explanation makes sense. I'm sorry, fwn. The way the "[deleted]" was indented at the same level flush with the message it was a reply to made me think that it was about the message at the same indentation, not about a sub-message that had been deleted. I remember seeing the original message but it was deleted before I could reply, and I couldn't reply to yours directly either, so I assumed showdead handled moderator deleted messages the same way as user deleted messages, and you'd edited it then deleted it after it was downvoted. It was my fault, I'm sorry, and I won't make that mistake again.
- fwn 12y agoI was confused as well. I wish I could have explained it! Sorry for being snappy in the end.
- DonHopkins 12y agoI'm even more sorry for going after you like that. Whoever posted the deleted comment was being bad in the wrong place at the wrong time, but I mistakenly thought you were that person, so denying that you'd done it instead of admitting to it would have brought it to a different level of bad. So your snappiness was justified.
- DanBC 12y agoYou might want to post to HN mods to let them know. Or maybe flag the posts. It's clear to me that you wrote a post which got killed by user flags. And that someone wrote a post, which smhenderson replied to, and that person later deleted their post. Their deleted post currently sits below your flagkilled post, and donhopkins has mistakenlythought that your flagkilled post is a self-deleted post and that people with showdead can see user deleted posts (theycan't) and then launched an attack on you.
- fwn 12y agoOh, ok. Well, thank you for this clarification! I have to admit that I also did not understand why it was displayed in the way it is. Thank you! So I guess it's all caused by an interface stumbling block we did not realise.
- smhenderson 12y agoI know this is old now but for the record I do not remember who I replied to by name. I simply remember them making a comment about TWP pushing an agenda by using the story and thought it in poor taste when I read it. I usually try to stay away from the bait but in a moment of irritation I responded. My post is at three now but it was down to at least -2 at some point which in hind sight I was glad about. I should have been smacked down a little for feeding trolls.
- JonnieCache 12y agoI was reading about this on /r/tas yesterday. Apparently she was a key developer of TAS features on the Dolphin emulator. Here are their tributes to her: https://dolphin-emu.org/blog/2015/04/25/commemoration-rachel-bryk/ https://dolphin-emu.org/blog/2015/04/25/commemoration-rachel...
- tantalor 12y agoTAS = tool assisted speedrun http://www.reddit.com/r/tas http://www.reddit.com/r/tas
- a_bonobo 12y agoThere may be a different story behind this: http://thecolorffooff.tumblr.com/bluh http://thecolorffooff.tumblr.com/bluh >On April 23rd Rachel posted her goodbye on Twitter and I freaked out and asked her a bunch of stuff to see if there was absolutely anything I could do to fix things. >There, of course, wasn't. >I asked her why she felt the need to do this. She replied saying that she had "incurable crippling diseases", specifically "RA + fibromyalgia" (RA I assume means Rheumatoid Arthritis).
- dalke 12y agoHow in the world is that a "different story". The WaPo article says: > Lisa Bryk said her daughter’s illnesses — and not just the abuse she suffered online — drove her to suicide. “While Rachel was certainly bullied and harassed online, that was NOT the reason she committed suicide,” she wrote. “Please pass along info on the abuse that trans individuals endure, but let’s also educate people on how difficult it is to live every moment in pain. A combination of everything was likely the cause, so let’s not make her a anonymous statistic.”
- tantalor 12y agoBecause it contradicts the headline.
- dalke 12y agoThere is no contradiction. "... after online abuse" is not the same as "... due only to online abuse". Here are other headlines in the last few days: 0) "Tuna company charged after employee burned to death in oven", 1) "Blue Bell is hoping for a "fresh start" after a listeria outbreak led to a total recall." 2) "LAPD officer charged with assault after yet another cop beating caught on camera", 3) "‘This is not Ferguson': Muddled mantra heard again after Freddie Gray death", 4) "Ricky Gervais fires back after getting slaughtered over hunting remarks", 5) "Boy found safe after being abducted during Northern California car theft", 6) "Five dead in family dispute after hours-long standoff at Phoenix home" There are so many examples where the phrase "after" is used for a temporal relationship where there is no direct causal relationship between the two. Eg, the five dead in (6) did not die because of an hours-long standoff but because of gunshot wounds. Why do you think there is a contradiction? What meaning do you assign to "after" which is also compatible with the 7 other examples I presented? Personally, I think the g'parent commenter didn't read the article and was trying to spin the conversation away from the idea that the written word can cause emotional trauma that might contribute to suicide.
- fwn 12y agoOk, I feel like I'm on /r/all ...
- amyjess 12y agoJesus. I'd heard about her death a few days ago, but this is the first time I heard about how she died. There have been way too damn many trans suicides lately. RIP :(
- Loughla 12y agoMaybe my view is messed up, but who goes on 4chan and expects anything but hatred and ignorance? That is the one and only fact about that site that has been constant since its inception. To me that's like going to the swimming pool and being upset because you get wet. While anger and hateful comments about transgender individuals and the LGBTQ community in general are prevalent online, isn't there a different site she could have used?
- rjbwork 12y agoFirst, a fewof points of accuracy: Dolphin is an emulator, an extremely famed one at that. A developer working on it is not necessarily a game developer. She was a developer on Dolphin, and she was damned good at what she did there too. Pucca's Kisses is a game, not an emulator. The video linked is a TAS, not her playing per se. Onwards: This is saddening. A brilliant programmer and open source contributor, snuffed out too soon by trolls and bullies. At risk of being accused of blaming the victim: we need to teach people, especially vulnerable young folks, to disengage from trolls and bullying online. Shut down your social media, turn off the computer if you need to. Killing yourself is a vast overreaction to being bullied on the internet, but can seem like the solution when you don't have have the proper perspective and tools to deal with the internet. I'd also like to take issue with this being called transmisogyny per se. I'm not denying it exists, or exists within the communities it is accused of existing in. HOWEVER, trolls are trolls and bullies are bullies. They will take anything and everything about you that you may be even vaguely insecure about, and harp on it as hard as possible to get a reaction. People have been doing this for what is now DECADES on the internet. It's a trait-agnostic tactic that is not unique to a trans person being bullied or trolled, or a gay person, or any other trait someone may have, or identity they may identify with. Painting this kind of behavior with such a narrow brush misses the point and issue entirely.