2 ms·
The evidence is at best neutral for education boosters which is really weird. Education increases as the economy grows but it doesn't seem to have any effect on
by barry-cotter 12y ago
The evidence is at best neutral for education boosters which is really weird. Education increases as the economy grows but it doesn't seem to have any effect on economic growth itself.
http://econlog.econlib.org/archives/2012/10/did_nations_tha.html http://econlog.econlib.org/archives/2012/10/did_nations_tha....
Did Nations that Boosted Education Grow Faster?
No. Each dot in the graph below represents a nation: Change in education on the x-axis and change in per capita GDP growth on the y-axis. Between the 60's and the 90's every country in this sample boosted its average years of education--it was a golden age of alleged human capital investment. Some nations boosted schooling more, some less. How did that turn out?
- rmk2 12y agoThat guy bothers me. What he doesn't account for is that, most likely, a place that would have to invest in education is not a developed nation in the first place. However, whatever you produce and especially export to the developed countries most likely comes from low-skilled labour to begin with, because that's how capitalism organised its centre/periphery-model of outsourcing labour costs. A boost in education does nothing to change the underlying power relations and economic networks that govern generation of wealth, since you still have to rely on exporting products that come from cheap labour, whether your workers can now read/write or not. This is especially true for an increasingly more globalised world, and since the numbers only take into account anything past 1960, I get the feeling he is omitting rather a lot that would have to be addressed.
- nhaehnle 12y agoThe graph is odd. According to the label, the Y axis is change in economic growth (probably meaning change in change in GDP). Honestly, I don't find it that surprising that the dots are all over the place. Economic growth is a variable that depends on a lot of things, you can think of it as G = f(education) + N, where N is basically random noise with a variance that is likely quite a bit higher than differences in f(education). So then if you measure G in 1960 and again in 2000, you really aren't measuring anything about f(education), you're only measuring noise. It would be much more interesting to see a comparison of educational standards and GDP growth (not change in GDP growth) over that time period. But even such a graph would be fraught with problems, mainly due to the effect of less developed countries having an easier time in "catching up" to developed countries. Anyway, as it stands I would basically throw that article in the garbage bin. Usually, I would give the author the benefit of the doubt and take more time to think about why my interpretation may be wrong, but this is an economist (maybe?) writing on a website with "economics and liberty" in the title. That's a huge warning sign for crack-pottery with an agenda.
- barry-cotter 12y agoThe graph is "odd" because it's looking for causality not correlation. If more developed countries are more educated all it proves is that education is a normal good and that people consume more of it as they get richer. That would prove nothing about whether education causes economic growth. Your point about noisy measurements, such as it is, applies to all macroeconomic measurement. If you're willing to proclaim radical scepticism about all macroeconomics fine. Otherwise this is just an isolated demand for rigour. The authour is on fact an economist and he references two different economics papers in the post, with links in support of his argument. And of course he has an agenda. Everyone has an agenda. The agenda of the agendaless is continuation of the status quo. Neutrality is an illusion.