4 ms·
HN's title seems to be misleading; one main point of the linked article is that changing the incentives around teaching will lead to changes in how teachers are
by jerf 17y ago
HN's title seems to be misleading; one main point of the linked article is that changing the incentives around teaching will lead to changes in how teachers are taught (second paragraph after the big chart), which would seem to imply the author does indeed consider that part of the problem.
I've spent a lot of time thinking about math education and one of the problems I have with it is that it is very, very incestuous. Teachers who barely know what is taught in high school, and certainly nothing beyond it, then go on to teach other teachers, without mathematicians safely sealed off from the process so as not to interfere with the latest theory of the day on how to teach a math one hundred years divorced from actual mathematicians. Getting more people with actual degrees in relevant fields involved in the process could have profound second-order effects in an educational curriculum that feels stale because it is stale. Education sealed off every avenue that new blood could come in decades ago, and every year it just gets worse. Often in the name of fixing education... which never happens because at this point the educational establishment is pretty clueless about the situation they are in, so how do we expect them to fix it?
- jseliger 17y ago"that changing the incentives around teaching will lead to changes in how teachers are taught (second paragraph after the big chart), which would seem to imply the author does indeed consider that part of the problem." It's part of the problem, but a very small part relative to other problems related to incentives in the field, which chiefly relate to pay, merit, and the relative ability of highly qualified people to get other jobs.
- jerf 17y agoWell, you seem to be both the original author and the HN summarizer, so I guess I can't complaint about misleading titles then. But it does seem to be all of a kind, all boiling down to a lack of competent people in the profession. Personally I'd consider the "second order effects" to be even more important than the direct effects of getting more skilled teachers in the field; the problem is a culture and that problem must be fixed by culture, and it will never be solved by just importing good people (even were that possible) if the cultural deck gets stacked against them making any changes, whereas even a small number of people could profoundly improve the entire system if the culture chose to let them.