3 ms·
The trouble with schools isn't about the teaching of teachers
- Perceval 17y agoIs the solution to avoid hiring education majors for education jobs, preferring instead people with degrees relevant to the subject? One aspect of academia and academic training is that it is not built primarily to produce teachers, but instead to produce researchers. Johns Hopkins started this trend back in the 1800s, turning professors from teachers into researchers. All other major educational institutions largely followed suit. Because academia is engaged in self-reproduction, they no longer really instruct anyone in teaching (as most of us find out when dealing with grossly incompetent TAs in discussion section), instead their graduate and masters students learn to be researchers. Maybe the trouble with schools is that they don't train people engaged in disciplines how to teach their discipline, instead relying on people specifically schooled in 'education' in the abstract to teach whatever course administrators deem necessary.
- jseliger 17y ago"Is the solution to avoid hiring education majors for education jobs, preferring instead people with degrees relevant to the subject?" (Note: the response below is regarding primary and secondary schools.) Perhaps: but school districts and teachers unions generally require education degrees, and frequently education M.A.s, for teachers. Alternately, some districts effectively make the M.A. required for salary reasons; in Seattle public schools, for example, the M.A. leads to a $6 – 10K/year pay jump. You'd be a fool not to get one, even if the degree is useless. Consequently, even if you took some enterprising principal who decided education degrees were useless, the pay structure and district policy would probably prevent that person from doing away with them.
- HistoryInAction 17y agoI agree. I forget who told me this, but the US Patent and Trademark Office in DC hires engineers for their engineering disciplines' patent examiner FTE slots. The argument goes that it's easier to take an engineer and give them a smattering of law education than it is to take a lawyer and give them a smattering of engineering education and expect them to understand the utility of a new engineering application or detect whether or not it is novel because they don't understand the technology enough to see what's similar to it. However, as the article demonstrates, a piece-wise comparison of A/B where A is what you've trained for and B is being an educator, A wins for pay in just about every field. B is always a step down in pretty much whatever metric you look at, aside from developing future generations. Simple game theory proves that B is only going to be populated by low-tier individuals who don't have much in the way of other options or those few gems in which the 'developing future generations' is an outsized factor in their decision-making.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoTeaching is a step down in pay, but not in compensation. Teachers get summers off, short working hours, public sector union pensions/health plans, earlier than normal retirement, and ridiculous job security. http://web.missouri.edu/~podgurskym/articles/files/fringe_benefits.pdf http://web.missouri.edu/~podgurskym/articles/files/fringe_be...
- HistoryInAction 17y agoI would argue that when considering a job, most people don't write out and include these sort of benefits in their cost-benefit analysis. I personally consider benefits to be a service that's cost neutral, rather than factoring it into my overall pay. I know that's not accurate, but that's just how my mind works. Also, any self-respecting teacher (especially new ones) will tell you that short official working hours are a mask for quite decent hours spent preparing for the teaching hours.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoI'm not sure what you mean by "quite decent", but in general teachers work a little bit less than other full time professionals 9 months out of the year. The other 3 months they work dramatically less. http://www.bls.gov/opub/mlr/2008/03/art4full.pdf http://www.bls.gov/opub/mlr/2008/03/art4full.pdf
- HistoryInAction 17y agoSorry for the lack of precision, I mean 40+ hour weeks, much of it unpaid. The rule of thumb that I was told was that you're working about 8 hours of prep for every hour of teaching the first year. Drafting lesson plans, putting together projects, laying out longer term units of study, things like that. They're only paid for the 8 am - 3 pm (35 hours or so a week, though the pay is per hour better), but most teachers I know show up early and work at home grading, preparing dittos, stuff like that. Add in requirements for Continuing Education, administrative tasks, and non-teaching related requirements that most unions/tenure programs require, and I'd still say it's a surprisingly low paid position for the time that goes into it and the long-term effects on the students.
- jerf 17y agoHN's title seems to be misleading; one main point of the linked article is that changing the incentives around teaching will lead to changes in how teachers are taught (second paragraph after the big chart), which would seem to imply the author does indeed consider that part of the problem. I've spent a lot of time thinking about math education and one of the problems I have with it is that it is very, very incestuous. Teachers who barely know what is taught in high school, and certainly nothing beyond it, then go on to teach other teachers, without mathematicians safely sealed off from the process so as not to interfere with the latest theory of the day on how to teach a math one hundred years divorced from actual mathematicians. Getting more people with actual degrees in relevant fields involved in the process could have profound second-order effects in an educational curriculum that feels stale because it is stale. Education sealed off every avenue that new blood could come in decades ago, and every year it just gets worse. Often in the name of fixing education... which never happens because at this point the educational establishment is pretty clueless about the situation they are in, so how do we expect them to fix it?
- jseliger 17y ago"that changing the incentives around teaching will lead to changes in how teachers are taught (second paragraph after the big chart), which would seem to imply the author does indeed consider that part of the problem." It's part of the problem, but a very small part relative to other problems related to incentives in the field, which chiefly relate to pay, merit, and the relative ability of highly qualified people to get other jobs.
- jerf 17y agoWell, you seem to be both the original author and the HN summarizer, so I guess I can't complaint about misleading titles then. But it does seem to be all of a kind, all boiling down to a lack of competent people in the profession. Personally I'd consider the "second order effects" to be even more important than the direct effects of getting more skilled teachers in the field; the problem is a culture and that problem must be fixed by culture, and it will never be solved by just importing good people (even were that possible) if the cultural deck gets stacked against them making any changes, whereas even a small number of people could profoundly improve the entire system if the culture chose to let them.
- RK 17y agoI have never understood the educational purpose of tenure for pre-university level teachers. It just seems like a symptom of teacher unions holding the system hostage.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoOr even for non-research tenured professors. Actually, even among research professors, tenure is used more to protect the lazy than to protect academic freedom. Every department has plenty of deadwood, but rarely more than one or two people with radical ideas.
- kiba 17y agoMy AP Computer Science course is more like teaching people how to program in Java. They taught us the specifics like interface class, abstract class, ArrayList class, and the like. Then they make us do toy programs that teaches these concept. I practically roll my eyes at the "Student class, Person class, etc" assignment. It was as if they don't have enough for all that they need to teach in Java programming and decided to push it over to computer science. I thought I was going to be writing algorithms, learning data structure, how to optimize it, etc. I was wrong. It was nothing more than gorified java programming class, at least this semester. Plus the teacher doesn't seem to be interested in her students' private projects and what we really think of her class. It was only a class of 8 students. As a result there's only 8 people who take computer science AP class in the entire school. Java programmming class have a lot of students but few students made it to computer science. There's little incentives in providing a compelling computer science education in high school.
- misterbwong 17y agoWhat does the AP test cover? If the test glosses over the same issues, it might be the fault of the testers rather than your teachers.
- HSCompSCI 17y agoWell, the course description specifically states what is tested and taught for the APCS exam. I think you were hoping to get more of an "AB" curriculum rather than an "A". You are simply in the wrong class if you "roll your eyes". You should look at taking a class at a local community college in something more challenging. I have a few articles that covers problems in the APCS test at http://www.hscompsci.com http://www.hscompsci.com Unfortunately, the "AB" tested is dropped this year. The College Board lost like $700,000 per year because not enough high school students took the test compared to how many people they have to hire to grade them. So yes, the "A" curriculum is pretty fundamental (though 40% of students flunk the "A" test each year)
- dpatru 17y agoSeliger cites a study showing that GRE scores for education graduate school students are 27 out of 28 disciplines. The only discipline with worse scores is public administration.