3 ms·
Horwitz acknowledged that “a few” of the best performers might not deserve an F. But the school wouldn’t let him teach just those students, so he had no choice
by JadeNB 12y ago
Horwitz acknowledged that “a few” of the best performers might not deserve an F. But the school wouldn’t let him teach just those students, so he had no choice but to flunk everyone and leave the course, he said.
Wow—as a teacher myself, I went to this story all prepared to root for this guy, but can't. "[T]he school wouldn't let him teach just those students, so he had no choice but to flunk everyone"? Who knows what's going on inside the classroom that we don't know—but, whatever happened, regardless of the provocation, comments like this [0] are a stain on the profession of teaching. It is our (teachers') job to deal with our students professionally, and that professionalism on our part becomes more, not less, important when it is not demonstrated by our students.
[0] Assuming that it is an accurate representation of what he said. I was once the subject of a friendly story in my local paper, and, even with the best of intentions on the reporter's part, I was amazed at how different what she wrote was from what I meant (and, I believe, said).
- wahsd 12y agoI am not sure that it really is a teacher, let alone professor's professional responsibility to have to deal with the student's lack of basic human decency. I don't know what happened in that class and I also don't know if his statement about "a few" not deserving being flunked is accurate, but it does not change the fact of the matter that a teacher / professor / lecturer's only job is to teach and educate. Their job is not crowd control or behavior modification therapy. I don't see any way how A&M is not negligent in performing their duty to assure an environment to allow him to perform his contractual obligation to teach the students that are there to learn. Especially if he requested that the disruptive students leave and / or be removed from the class, he and the affected students that were possibly not contributing to the disruption should really be suing the university for contract non-performance. If you go to a university and expect education and instruction and the school does not perform it's duty to assure that happens, they are in breach of contract. There doesn't seem to be any real difference from any other service contract.
- JadeNB 12y ago> I am not sure that it really is a teacher, let alone professor's professional responsibility to have to deal with the student's lack of basic human decency. It is every professional's responsibility to deal professionally even with unprofessional behaviour. That doesn't mean tolerating or excusing the behaviour. For example, as a teacher, if I am repeatedly provoked and harrassed by students (which has never happened!), then I am within my rights to ask them to stop, to call security, and even to refuse to return to the classroom until some assurance is made that it is a safe environment. That is a professional response to unprofessional behaviour. What I am not entitled to do is to say that there are some good apples, but, because of the few (or many) bad apples, I am going to fail everyone. That is an unprofessional response.