4 ms·
In my experience, Reddit somewhat encourages snark and sarcasm, but you better be bleeding edge and perfect in your wit, lest you be criticized into reddit hell
by S_A_P 12y ago
In my experience, Reddit somewhat encourages snark and sarcasm, but you better be bleeding edge and perfect in your wit, lest you be criticized into reddit hell. Hacker news does a pretty good job of squashing most snark, sarcasm and humor which gives it a clarity of focus toward helpful discussion.
I think that this generally makes HN a much more pleasant, if slightly sterile place to hang out. In my opinion, that is a worthy trade off. I think the main critique I have of HN is that sometimes comments that are critical, but not necessarily mean get downvoted. Its a tough problem to solve though, so I can give it a pass. Maybe I should create a biometric mood ring that attaches your mood context with a post...
- chupy 12y agoI too have this problem when commenting on HN vs Reddit. When a badly phrased comment would be actually taken lightly on reddit here it gets easily misunderstood. That is one of the reasons I do not comment as much as I wish. I honestly think a small part of all this is linked to the cultural differences between different generations and peoples.