4 ms·
Honest actors can't compete with people who ignore the law though - you acknowledge yourself that the competition here is unfair. Yes, by ignoring copyright and
by jameshart 12y ago
Honest actors can't compete with people who ignore the law though - you acknowledge yourself that the competition here is unfair. Yes, by ignoring copyright and not compensating content creators at all, you can create a service that offers vast amounts of content for free. A legitimate business can't do that.
Saying 'well, sorry, the market has spoken and the price they are willing to pay for your content is $0' is just not reasonable. It's like pointing to a guy selling stolen iPhones for $20 and telling Apple they need to adjust their prices to the new reality.
- ddingus 12y agoThey can. There are a few use cases here: 1. Massive pirate. Won't pay for anything. If we made it a perfect world, they would just mooch off other people in the extreme, never paying for anything. They won't be customers. Ever. But they do talk about stuff, make recommendations, etc... So they can be leveraged in that way. Show them an AD, or have them do some other minor league thing of value, and trade on that for some value. Good as it gets. And it's important to factor these people in. Their copies and views don't devalue anything. Ignore their $0, and consider anything of value derived from their mindshare as a bonus. 2. Casual pirate. These people will pay, but don't want to be annoyed. Good service, making it easy, etc... all counts, and massive numbers of them will subscribe to lots of things. Cord cutters fall in to this bucket too. Cut out the $150 cable bill, and sign up for a few services, then buy things on top of that. Big cable loses a revenue stream, but content creators and service providers gain one. 3. Buyer. They typically have more means than most, and just pay because it's not a big impact to them. Upper middle class and above here mostly. What people make, and what $10 means to them is absolutely a factor in how to compete with free works. The difference between #2 and #3 here is important. Secondly, entertainment dollars are largely fixed for many people. Actually, my experience is this is true for most people. There is some flex in it, but there aren't billions laying around unspent somehow as most entertainment centric arguments imply. Most people have a coupla hundred bucks to spend. And the various forms of entertainment compete too. A summer of good movies? Yeah, maybe buy one less game. Recognition of this means understanding price points, incentives to spend and how / when / why to compete with other entertainment forms to optimize revenue. Very little is being said about this, but we are seeing flat rate services compete fairly well while delivering consistent revenue. All of this is particularly relevant to #2 above. Considering all of these together highlights some ways to compete with free. Be the free source. Pirating has some negatives attached to it. So side step those and give people options that can send value your way. Increasingly, it's possible to stream now. I am a fan of AMC "Halt And Catch Fire" and do not have cable. I can't go and buy AMC just yet, and they didn't put the show on the services I do subscribe to. On a quick check, there it was! Right there on the AMC site, and they want me to watch an AD, maybe participate in the little activities and potentially do other things in return for my eyeballs on the show. Result? Incentive to pirate goes way down. I've got a path in, and would gladly have gave them money for the views too. Cory Doctrow does this with his books too. If you want to read 'em, he's the source for that. Grab and go. If you want to translate, or do fan derivatives, he will source that too. I did that with "Down and Out In the Magic Kingdom", and really liked his work. Bought a lot of hard copies of his stuff since then. Had it not been that easy and obvious, I might have gotten some PDF, or other, or more likely, not done anything and would not know the guy at all. Mindshare matters. Buying it with views to compete is a perfectly valid business model. And giving people options like sharing / recommending / gifting means those who can pay with dollars will, and those who can't or won't, can do some work that leads to dollars. It's all dollars in the end, done right. So there are a couple of ways right there. Both compete with free, both leverage mindshare to get some value while at the same time offering purchase opportunities. The more of this there is, the less people will pirate, leaving us with just that use case #1 above, and there is nothing to be done with those people, other than to leverage their mindshare somehow. Maximizing revenue is all about the other use cases and recognition of the nature of entertainment dollars and pricing on that understanding, IMHO.
- jameshart 12y agoCasual pirates and cord cutters aren't the same. At all. I don't get how you can erase the moral line between freeloading and just not being a customer. Car rental companies don't look at people who just break into cars and steal them and think 'hey look - setting aside the hardcore boosting crews, and focusing on just casual car thieves, there's clearly a market for people who just want the convenience of taking any car they walk past for free! We need to compete with that on convenience and price!' There's simply no excuse for being a casual pirate. I'm sorry, but it's just not right or fair to access the work of a content owner through a channel they don't endorse. Just because they haven't figured out a way to give you access on terms they agree to doesn't give you the right to take access on your terms.
- ddingus 12y agoNo, they aren't the same. But they are similar in that a lot of members of both will pay. I lumped them in to the same bucket to highlight how mindshare can translate into value other than direct pay per view. As for there being no excuse? Sure there is. It's possible to do. End game is really simple: a. We make it a perfect, closed, trusted computing only world. That's draconian, and very likely not possible. Suddenly, mindshare goes way down. People only get what they can actually pay for. What do you think happens with pricing, etc...? b. We recognize that it's possible to do. Mindshare stays high, and people compete for revenue, and or ways to leverage mindshare for value / revenue. I'm in the latter camp, and am not judging people one way or the other, instead focused on getting the maximum value out of the activity and mindshare. And here is the hard truth. They don't like infringing. Who does? But they absolutely do like the massive mindshare their work got them. So it's one or the other. In the perfect world, getting mindshare might involve what? Say giving it away? Maybe allowing people to share it? Interesting, isn't it? Simple as that.
- jameshart 12y agoc. We recognize that individuals need to take some moral responsibility for their actions. The issue isn't that it's possible to do. All kinds of things that are bad for society are possible to do but people don't do them because they will get caught and punished. The issue is that it's possible to get away with doing it.