3 ms·
TL;DR please. I'm definitely not going to read this and I would be surprised if many did. Just being honest.
by Kiro 12y ago
TL;DR please. I'm definitely not going to read this and I would be surprised if many did. Just being honest.
- blumkvist 12y agoExactly the reason what is wrong with the world in general. You can't be arse to read a few pages, but I bet you feel entitled to an opinion, right? I bet you have opinions on many things. How did you form them? By reading tl;dr versions in the newspaper and discussing with friend on the dinner table?
- Kiro 12y agoWhat are you even talking about? Who said anything about opinions? I asked for a TL;DR, that's all. I also think it's interesting that you choose to rant when it's about a long and advanced scientific article full of terminology I don't even understand. Shouldn't this be a case where a TL;DR is justified if anything?
- jmilloy 12y agoPapers come with their own tldr. It's not because people are lazy, but because that's all most people reading it actually need. This is in contrast to many op-eds, blog posts, and even news articles, which intentionally make it hard to find a summary, disperse shallow content between ads, just like to hear their own voice, or other such behaviours that are worth avoiding. I think asking for a tldr here is mistaking the former for the latter (an honest mistake).
- saint_fiasco 12y agoFinally read the thing. It's pretty interesting. To be honest, I only read it because one of the authors is Nassim Taleb and I liked his books. Anyway, the gist of it is that there are different kinds of risk. Some risks can be calculated with certain probabilities, and you can do cost-benefit analysis with them. For example, you should only spend money on a security system for your home or business if the cost-of-being-attacked times the probability of attack exceeds the cost of the system, right? However, there is another kind of risk for which you can't do that, because their cost is so high that nobody will live to tell the tale and collect the statistics (extinction events), or maybe they will but it will be too late (global financial crisis). The paper argues that monocultures present that kind of risk. You can't calculate "probability of massive blight that kills all our genetically homogeneous food" for example because we don't have much of a sample size. And by the time we do have the sample size, it will be too late. Then, the paper points out some other risks and explains why the risks of artificial selection are different from the risks of GMO. Long story short, it's because a bad mutation in a "natural" crop only kills a few people before they realize that they should plant something else.