3 ms·
This exact question turned up in reference to the Sandy Hook school shooting. A few of us asked why it was so prominent on HN given then guidelines, and in par
by ColinWright 12y ago
This exact question turned up in reference to the Sandy Hook school shooting. A few of us asked why it was so prominent on HN given then guidelines, and in particular I said:
Yes, this is important, yes, it's newsworthy.
No, it's not "Hacker News". It's all over the
news, and there's nothing specific about hacking,
or start-ups. It's not even of "deep interest"
in any real sense. It's tragedy, pure and simple,
and then it becomes politics.[0]
PG replied (in reference to the guidelines you quote) with:
Note those words most and probably.
Another accused me:
Try on a little human emotion and sensitivity for
size: this isn't your site to police. Even pg has
pointed out the precision of the wording which you
seemingly ignored.
I usually stay out of discussions about on-topic/off-topic now. There's nothing to be gained. I just flag things according to my own criteria and move on.
[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4922380 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4922380