7 ms·
Well, let’s see where the incentives take us. Journalists want to report on interesting things which people want to read about or watch. Reporting on things
by teddyh 12y ago
Well, let’s see where the incentives take us.
Journalists want to report on interesting things which people want to read about or watch. Reporting on things by secret informants and sources is a bit harder, but usually worth is because it gives a better story. But informants who have to be kept secret from the government is another matter – it’s nigh-impossible, even for an expert, to keep such things secret from the NSA and all its collaborators (knowing and unknowing). So these stories are much harder to do, but the story itself is not that much more interesting than other possible stories which does not have the same level of government interest. For this reason, the journalists are incentivized to avoid stories which attract the government’s interest. As the government’s interest grows to encompass all things, the journalist is therefore pressed to nevertheless report on stories within the government’s scope of interest, even though the risk is high for failure. The obvious solution for the government is to provide juicy stories for journalists to report on which are not in the government interest – the more frivolous, the better.
And thus we can explain today’s media landscape.
- themartorana 12y agoNicely said.
- mhuffman 12y agoUsing your theory as a lens to observe current events in Baltimore (Ferguson, etc.), where the media is really responsible for fanning the flames of outrage to riot proportions -- it seems that the government is either ineffective at this refocusing of media and not really an issue, or so diabolically effective that we should all be shitting our pants.
- mschuster91 12y ago> or so diabolically effective that we should all be shitting our pants. Buncha rioters looting cities. Nothing better to prove your "tough on crime" attitude or to activate military powers... (yes, I know, calling in the National Guard is commonplace in the US, but virtually unthinkable in Germany)
- maxerickson 12y agoSomeone from the Maryland National Guard was in front of cameras this morning emphasizing that their presence was not under a declaration of martial law (which is a perhaps pedantic interpretation of "activate military powers", but there you go). The situation in Baltimore (a city of 600,000, a metro of several million) looks to me like it is limited to at most a few thousand people. The idea that the media fanned these people into action is silly. They see large crowds of people (that are not rioting or looting) engaging with the police and see it as an opportunity to do whatever they want while hiding in those crowds. The most common type of small riots in the US are sports related, those riots are certainly not the result of the media fanning flames, they are a result of small numbers of people feeling like they can hide in a crowd.
- dangerlibrary 12y agoBaltimore is a city that has extreme poverty, very poor social services, and a tax structure (city/county border) that prevents regional economic growth from benefiting the poorest residents. As a result, there are a lot of opportunistic criminals. The protests just tied up enough of the police force to create an opportunity.
- Zigurd 12y agoCivil unrest brings out the propaganda machine: http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/toronto/why-were-police-cruisers-left-to-burn-at-g20-summit/article572789/ http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/toronto/why-were-police-...
- teddyh 12y agoThe initial events in Baltimore, Ferguson, etc. happened independently of journalists. Any “fanning” done by journalists is presumably done because because it’s probably easier to do that than to find other, juicer, stories (where such stories might also be of such a nature to attract government interest).
- mhuffman 12y ago380 such events have happened so far this year, however only a few have had national reporting. Journalists are very clear what makes a story "juicy", I think. [1] http://killedbypolice.net/ http://killedbypolice.net/
- dragonwriter 12y ago> 380 such events have happened so far this year 380 killings of unarmed people by cops under circumstances similar to those that existed in the stories that have been widely covered aside from the issue of race?
- mhuffman 12y agoNot all 380, but certainly some[1]...and I can find many more, but leave that as an exercise for you. Linked story is of an unarmed teen, with hands outstretched being killed by police. Also there was a video. However, teen is white officer is black. Officer cleared of charges. Very similar to Ferguson, but no riots, no fanning of the social injustice flames by the media, etc. No national story. I point this out to show that police are doing this sort of thing all the time, however the media (defined as TV news, online news) are very selective of the ones they promote because they know they will get a reaction. [1] http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/10/11/gil-collar-shooting-video_n_1958480.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/10/11/gil-collar-shooting...
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Not all 380 So the claim was false, so why did you make it? > and I can find many more, but leave that as an exercise for you. Its not really my job to support your argument. If its not important enough for you to present evidence, its not important to me to go look on the off chance that you might not be exaggerating again.
- fineman 12y agoIt's not a media-generated event. People are upset about having their friends shot and automatic rifles pointed at their faces as they protest.
- classicsnoot 12y agoFuck. I can deal with it at family reunions. I can deal with it at bars. Most times i can deal with it in the bedroom. But here on HN? This i cannot abide. When you say "the Media" what in gods' name do you actually mean? The Media made me do it. I would have known but for The Media. Why does The Media always [x]. I am not that smart; i make a lot of mistakes in a lot of different ways. But i learned long ago that blaming my parents, my gender, my race, etc. for MY STUPIDITY is a huge waste of time and resources. People are rioting because they are frustrated, or insidious, or bored, or despicable, or bored, or passionate, or bored. They are not rioting because a TV told them to.
- mhuffman 12y agoThere are absolutely some people looting and raising hell because they are seeing others do it without consequence on television or online. When I say "the Media", I (in god's name) mean the television news, the online news, twitter, and facebook. Do you honestly think that people just independently thought to go burn some shit up (in a hive mind sort of way) all at the same time, for no reason other than they were bored? The TV didn't tell them to do it, it showed them that other people were doing it (stimulating people swaying that way to join in for whatever the reason). Further, "the media" have been purposely making a habit recently of showing black men killed by white police officers, when in fact, so far just this year 380[1] people have been killed by police -- only a fraction have been black, with the rest mostly while and latino. Also, you will note that some of those black people killed must have also been killed by black officers -- but crickets on the TV and online. Realistically, why do you think that is? Do you not at least suspect that it is because "they" (tv news, online news, etc) know how people will react? If it was just the act of the police killing someone, how come all the police shootings haven't been front-page news nation-wide? It is very naive to think that modern day journalists do not know if printing certain stories with sensationalist headlines, or focusing on certain stories will have effects on people. It is also very naive to think that people seeing and hearing these (very focused) stories would not react to them[2]. [1] http://killedbypolice.net/ http://killedbypolice.net/ [2] They certainly knew back in the day! See the Spanish-American War as a well-known example of the media "making" people do somthing
- Lawtonfogle 12y agoThose riots are a great way to increase racial tensions and racial divides. When you have the races blaming each other for all their woes, it is much harder for them to get together and notice where their economic trouble is really originating. I see most 'us vs. them' clashes in much the same light. Take the notion of the wage gap. It focuses on a relatively small wage gap with far more attention than that which is given to the gap in economic gains post recession.
- alfiedotwtf 12y ago“The smart way to keep people passive and obedient is to strictly limit the spectrum of acceptable opinion, but allow very lively debate within that spectrum....” -- Noam Chomsky, The Common Good
- jensen123 12y agoAs far as I can tell, there's no need to do anything at all to keep people passive and obedient. Most people seem to be born that way. They're kinda zombie like. Don't believe me? Look at the Stanley Milgram experiments.
- gress 12y agoWhat have milgram's experiments got to do with how people are born? He experimented with adults.
- hansjorg 12y ago> Most people seem to be born that way. >Look at the Stanley Milgram experiments. Milgram did experiments on newborns?
- logfromblammo 12y ago~ Judging by how they shamelessly manipulate their own parents, I'm sure every last one of those little jerks would have gone all the way up to the maximum pretend voltage. ~
- jensen123 12y agoFair enough. I should have found a better example. But do you really think those obedient people got that way because there's some sort of conspiracy by some elite, like Noam Chomsky alludes to?
- mjklin 12y agoAlexis de Tocqueville noted this as a feature of American society in the mid-1800s. Chomsky would be flattering himself to think it was an original idea or that it was imposed from on high.
- jerf 12y agoYour theory invokes more than it needs to. I see no evidence that the government needs to exert even a tiny bit of effort to feed journalists silly stories. I'd say the evidence suggests it is simply the natural state of the journalism given the current incentives, most of which are coming from the market as it reacts to the Internet. "Real" journalism, or perhaps rather, "effortful" journalism is really hard to sustain right now even before we consider government pushback, because trying to base journalism on "ads" and "page views" is all but actively hostile to such journalism. (We get reporting on Baltimore not because it's "real", but because it's easy; point camera, optionally bloviate and fit into narrative, done.) Until journalism figures out another funding method, the race to the bottom is the only possible economic outcome.
- samspot 12y agoAre we already at the bottom? I just read an article about Baltimore on CNN, and at the bottom the related articles included "TV's hottest news anchors".
- avn2109 12y agoI always think we're at the bottom now, but then next week they sink even lower.
- nosuchthing 12y agoAlmost, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uxoiOJ280LI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uxoiOJ280LI
- samspot 12y agohahaha, thanks for that reminder.
- logfromblammo 12y agoOld school curated and investigative journalism is expensive. New school journalism is a tiny professional choke on the shotgun blast of biased, crowd-sourced raw material available on video distribution sites and editorial blogs. The public interest is now measured after the fact rather than predicted in advance. Stories are steered rather than excavated. In the olden days of newspapers, the available, verifiable facts of a story might not be sufficient for even one column-inch of print. That left plenty of room for embellishment and editorializing. Later, the quantity of facts might have exceeded the attention span of the reader. Stories adopted the "inverted pyramid" form, to place the most interesting, salient facts first, and fill in lesser details later on. Now, there are so many available facts for each story--pictures being worth a thousand words, and video worth a thousand pictures--that editorial bias can be introduced merely by selecting a particular set of facts as the important ones. If the story has a preassembled narrative, and only facts that fit into the framework are presented, an entire week of 24-7 television news channel can be filled with sensational material without once including a single contradiction or suspicion. No one seems willing to pay for muck-raking, in-the-trenches journalistic investigation, because no one with the appropriate capital is selling it. It is more expensive than parrot journalism, and does not make proportionally more money for the company. In short, news companies are dying because they are not doing the one niche thing that the general wire services and small-time blogs cannot. They are not finding and breaking the difficult stories. There is no need to invoke conspiracy. The government is not feeding anyone stories. The news distributors are practically begging anyone willing to listen for completed, polished segments that they can air without editing. The prepackaged propaganda could be from a government agency with a media relations budget, or from a corporation wanting to do some stealthy advertisement. Watch your local television news tonight, and try to spot the paid advertisement dressed up like news. It really pissed me off yesterday, watching Baltimore-based footage, that none of the questions I had were answered by the reporting. It was, as parent mentioned, all dumb camera-pointing and bloviating into microphones. Does anyone else think there might be less rioting in these situations if people had more trust in their institutions? What if someone could actually count on the fourth estate to keep the government accountable long enough for justice to finally prevail? Would you riot if Respectable G. Newsanchor (the G is for gravitas) solemnly swore to you on air that no stone would remain unturned, until all the worms in the story were revealed and illuminated by journalistic sunshine? I would at least wait until RGN broke that promise, by which time more viable options might become apparent.
- tomjen3 12y agoI chose to upvote you because you make interesting point, but "todays media landscape" cannot be more than weakly-explained by NSA spying on us --- it was a problem back before the war on terror. Media has sucked for decades.
- thatcat 12y agoYes, but before media had a severely limited distribution system compared to the internet and it was media consolidation that led to easy censorship of certain issues. Now it's open and sucks in completely different ways that is probably more to the way people pay for media or don't than spies.
- vorg 12y ago> other possible stories which does not have the same level of government interest. For this reason, the journalists are incentivized to avoid stories which attract the government’s interest What other possible stories are these? Most stories journalists have reported on are government stories in some way, not counting entertainment/sports, business PR, and other such fluff. The "other possible stories" of interest that don't involve some form of government are those of big businesses, i.e. the people who control the allocation of advertising revenue for most major media outlets in the world. It's been a long time since journalists have routinely researched stories on the generally corrupt practises of these businesses. Reporting on governments and politics has always been a safe diversion for journalists, and most of them use such stories as a resume for a PR role at big biz anyway.