8 ms·
Texas college professor tries to flunk his whole class
- mahouse 12y ago>Horwitz
- ajuc 12y ago?
- vinceguidry 12y agoNow that's what I call a ragequit.
- al2o3cr 12y ago"being disruptive, rude and dishonest" Sounds like a bunch of straight-shooters with middle management written all over them. ;)
- Red_Tarsius 12y agoThere's not enough information for a fair opinion on the matter. The professor felt devalued from class behaviour, so he "made himself scarce". After establishing credibility by telling us about his past experiences and successes, he quits for reasons we can all empathize with. Scarsity, social proof and authority are 3 of the six principles described by Cialdini's Influence.
- winsletts 12y agoI imagine this is one of those situations where the truth will never be available. All participates have taken sides, and have skewed / omitted / shaped their own stories for their own interests. I wish we had a black box recorder for organizational and cultural failures. [edited tone to convey agreement]
- IkmoIkmo 12y agoBut the article ends with a student expressing disbelief as he did decent work and getting an F before the class even ends, and the professor acknowledging that some students were fine, but that he exercised collective punishment because it was his only instrument. That seems pretty clear cut to me, definitely a bad move. It can't be justified, solves no problems and punishes innocent students. I'd understand why he'd fail some of his students, and I can also imagine situations where it's tricky to pinpoint and isolate the unwilling students from his class, and if made out to be a clown day in day out, lacking the proper instruments, management backing and (understandably) mental fortitude, that you'd leave the school at some point. But how that translates to giving an F to an entire class, including students who bore no responsibility and were as powerless to keep the class going the right way as he was, is beyond me.
- Kenji 12y agoSeems like he just had a nervous breakdown. He should probably take some time off, recover, and maybe take a job that requires less social interaction. Being a good teacher (no matter the age of the student) is draining and requires a lot of patience and emotional intuition.
- oddevan 12y agoI'll agree with you with the caveat that "just a nervous breakdown" might be a little dismissive. Does he need a sabbatical? Absolutely. It sounds like after one-too-many classes of willfully unteachable students (as in students that refuse to learn, not students that are unable to learn), enough was enough and he had had it with these motherf%$&ing students in this motherf%$&ing school. I think a lot of us here on HN can empathize with overwork and burnout, and it sounds like this professor may have ignored the warning signs for too long. I hope he can get the help he needs.
- VLM 12y ago"I hope he can get the help he needs." That appears highly unlikely given past experience: "Speaking with the Houston Chronicle, he added that the university wasn’t responding to his complaints about their behavior"
- iridium 12y agoEven though this incident sounds more personal than idealistic, it keeps bringing back up the question of the purpose of universities. I am okay with universities being a medium of education, where one can take any courses they want, and passing and failing is irrelevant (MOOCs?) I am okay with universities being a place to enjoy four years of camaraderie and self exploration before committing to life or career goals. I am okay with universities being a stamp of selection, i.e you were good enough to get into harvard so you must be smart. However, universities try to be all three and fail miserably at all of them, while leaving students in a large debt that most are unable to reconcile with what they got out of it, along with a life-long 'average gpa' that barely reflects abilities.
- probably_wrong 12y agoI think you are confusing "universities" with "USA universities", specially when it comes to debt and GPA.
- iridium 12y agoI'll agree on the debt side. The grade issue is infinitely worse in a lot of competitive cultures. Even if you take the money factor away, Have non-US universities really figured out higher education? Most of them tend to either be a lot more rigid in structure, or they copy from the US system.
- arethuza 12y agoPersonally, I'm much happier I went to a UK university where the final degree "class" was based almost entirely on what you did in the final year (I think it was 80% fourth year and 20% third) as I was a terrible student in the first year, average in the second and did really well in the final two years and got a first. Not saying that this approach is "better" - just that it suited me!
- nailer 12y agoMost USA-people do this, and they're aware of it: when they talk about 'universities', or '[some class of] people', or 'VC' or whatever else. I think the reasons they do it are a combination of efficiency and a feeling that the rest of the world isn't always necessary to the discussion. Those of us outside the US may feel it's naive, but it's unlikely they'll change. The simplest thing for us to do is to assume they always mean USA-[topic].
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- ejcx 12y agoIf this college class operates like the ones I had then I think the professor is in the wrong. On the first day I would be given a syllabus that clearly outlined the grading scale and how the grade was calculated. I look at that like a contract. Professor presented students with a grading scale, students accept by staying in the class or withdraw from the class. Granted I know nothing about this particular incident, but it could be an interesting case to read about if it were to go to court.
- learnstats2 12y agoWhat you describe is exactly how it should be and is considered best practice in education. Not a contract, but the terms and expectations of the class set out as clearly as possible in advance. In this case, this has failed. The professor has then tried to punish all the students on his own whim, presumably because of the actions of a minority. What about the other students: those who didn't cheat, those who didn't spread rumours, those who didn't contribute to an unsafe atmosphere, and those who met the educational goals of the class? There's no possible way the whole class deserves a blanket fail. Thankfully the faculty realise this.
- bachmeier 12y ago> What about the other students: those who didn't cheat, those who didn't spread rumours, those who didn't contribute to an unsafe atmosphere, and those who met the educational goals of the class? There's no possible way the whole class deserves a blanket fail. As a faculty member, I can understand someone wanting to fail an entire class - some classes are just bad, and some students are bad people - but you just can't do it. If someone is disrupting the learning environment, they have to be removed. You're performing when you enter the classroom, and you have to deal with the hecklers and the critics.
- rayiner 12y agoIf the syllabus is a contract, cheating is a breach of the covenant of good faith and fair dealing. I'm all for failing classes pervasive cheating. There isn't enough social pressure in schools to name and shame cheaters.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- aaron695 12y agoThis really is a pointless article of he said, they said. There is nothing at all to be gained in reading it. There's no actual evidence of who was in the wrong or what the real story is. (You could easily argue after 20 years in the game he fully knew all the students wouldn't actually get a F, even this is unknown)
- DanielBMarkham 12y agoI agree there is nothing of immediate value here. The story is part of a larger narrative. Those interested in that narrative will enjoy watching how it plays out.
- madaxe_again 12y agoThe larger narrative is the commoditisation of education, degree-mills, disgruntled educators who find they are no longer able to educate (the word comes from educere - to lead or to draw from, and implies a two-party process) their disengaged students, and the even larger narrative is the result of entitlement culture, which is part of the broader narrative of social change in north america, 1770 - 2015. I know far too many talented and insightful educators who have found themselves either unemployed or fleeing to commerce.. those who remain are increasingly embittered, embattled, or just don't care. Things will get better when and if folks stop believing that all of their dreams will come true because they're a unique special flower, and start realising that most of life requires knowledge and hard graft, if you want to achieve anything worthwhile - and that you are just another head of corn in a field of billions.
- baldfat 12y agoHappened at the College I use to work at (Systems Librarian and in Student Life) Whole class plagiarized their papers and it wasn't a he said she said. Clear as day guilty. Some of the papers were word for word the same (The kids forgot to change words). Professor gives the complete class a failing grade. College within a week lets all the Seniors graduate and changed their grades to C and fires the Professor. Professor appeals and is re-hired. Than he is fired 2 years later due to complaints that his classes are to difficult. Once again appeals and is rehired. He is now the easiest professor to get a D or C as long as you don't cut three weeks (AKA 1/4 of the class). You have to do projects for different grades. D = writes out 50 words and their definitions with hand drawn pictures. C = Pass a definition test of a possible 100 words (Super Easy). B = do research and turn in a short half page synopsis of your findings with printed out web pages or copies of books. A = write one 10 page paper and get at least an 80 on the paper with his simple rubric (AKA Jr High level). Only 10% actually ever attempt an A and he has a perfect Bell Curve the past 15+ years now. His lectures are incredible deep (Philosophy and Theology) and you can either sit there and learn very little (Most do) or you can engage him and he will give the best lecture tailored for whoever tries hard and talks during class. When my friends who were alumni would come to visit I always took them to this professor's class and they were blown away at how foolish they were to dismiss him and think of him as a easy C or B class. So this actually happened and it caused a professor to just not engage his classes brains or challenge them academically due to fear of being fired again. Philosophy and Theology field is incredibly competitive and there would be over 150 applications for his position if it ever opened up. You also would than be a person who was fired trying to get into a field where hundreds trying for the same job.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- erikb 12y agoI also experienced that twice during my student years. That the professor not makes a decision with his fellow profs and school organizers looks quite poor. In any conflict you must choose one side, at least I believe so, and then support that. If you fight with the students, that's okay. If you fight with your fellow professors that's also okay. But just making trouble to both groups and then running away... That can't be reasonable or achieve anything. From the experience with the two professors I knew trying something like that, I think that guy will be surprised that students and the other profs will bond together simply to avoid more trouble and continue with the university life.
- nickthemagicman 12y ago“Just ridiculous, I had never had a problem in the class. I thought I had done pretty well, done pretty well on the first test and then I get an e-mail saying I am going to get an F in the class, it was overwhelming,” Shaw told KPRC.
- goodcanadian 12y agoI have little doubt that (some of) the students were childish assholes. I also have little doubt that the professor handled it poorly. Probably, he treated them like children. This is incredibly insulting to the majority of students that do care, and it does not solve the problem. I have seen that play out in university classes. In the end, rather than telling the assholes to get the fuck out, he throws a temper tantrum. No one is in the right here.
- nashashmi 12y agoThis is not the first time it has happened that a professor tries to fail a whole class, but it maybe the first time a professor prematurely failed an entire class without any chance of recourse and without letting final performances materialize.
- Casseres 12y agoI graduated from the college in question - Texas A&M University at Galveston (TAMUG). Off the bat, I don't know that professor or any of those students (I was in a different major, and had great professors). The problem I have with this story is that someone went to the media with rather than dealing with the school administration. Based on KPRC's online video of the report, it was probably John R Shaw Jr. The video was poorly made. About half of the video is shots of the same empty classroom. Another part is where they stage John walking on the sidewalk. Due to poor editing, you can see him turn around before walking and suppressing a smile. The only reason that I can surmise that this is in the news rather than being dealt with appropriately, is because John R Shaw Jr probably wanted 15 minutes of fame. He says he has a job offer, but after this, I can't imagine what company is going to want to hire him if he goes to the media instead of the appropriate route every time he feels slighted.
- gdulli 12y ago> The problem I have with this story is that someone went to the media with rather than dealing with the school administration. "...he added that the university wasn't responding to his complaints about their behavior, pushing him to take this drastic step."
- fluidcruft 12y agoThat quote is from the professor (Horwitz). John R Shaw Jr is apparently one of the students.
- jmilloy 12y agoThere are students everywhere who are graded unfairly. Certainly punishing students who break the ethical rules of the school or terrorize the classroom with a failing grade is not the appropriate response, though many of such students probably do deserve poor grades for the actual academic performance that corresponds to such behaviour. More interestingly, why should a single grade matter so much? Especially when it can so easily be due to the whims of the professor or to extraordinary personal circumstances of the student? Of course, it does matter in practice, and that's the bigger problem that I think is showcased by stories like these.
- skywhopper 12y agoBreaking News: sometimes teachers have depressive flameouts just like every other kind of person. There's not really anything to take from this article. When this sort of thing happens, the department hands the class off to someone else, the instructor is disciplined in some way, and life goes on. The students won't receive an ideal semester's worth of instruction, but that happens sometimes. The university probably ought to find some way to let students who want to take the class over to do so at no cost, but I have no idea if that's likely. The students who would rather not take the class over shouldn't have to. One class is not going to make or break their education. Meanwhile, they've learned that sometimes spectacular flameouts happen, and they have an interesting story to tell for the rest of their lives.
- heapcity 12y agoI flamed out on cheaters once by telling students they could decide for themselves what their grade was. "Go ahead live the rest of your life with the false assumption you understand statistics."
- marincounty 12y agoSlightly off topic, but I have a bachelor's degree in Management. The courses were a joke. I wish I followed my passion in college, but figured a degree in Management would get me a job. The Manaagement classes were basically business classes. I was young, and naive.
- edw519 12y agoHorwitz, who has taught management for two decades... What exactly did he teach? It doesn't appear he learned very much about "management". Imagine a manager firing all 30 of his direct reports. What would you suspect was the problem, the manager or the workers? Same thing here. Perhaps Professor Horwitz should get a real management job. Then he'd learn how easy he'd had it for the past two decades.
- jerf 12y ago"What would you suspect was the problem, the manager or the workers?" Well, "the manager's manager" is an option here too. "Mismatch of responsibility and authority" is certainly a fundamental problem that schools at all levels from kindergarten to university have been struggling with as our society goes through its social changes, as we keep loading responsibilities on to the teachers even as we strip away their authority. Whether or not this is the case, I don't know. As others have observed, there isn't anywhere near enough info to conclude anything here.
- VLM 12y agoThats covered in the article by a quote: “The administration is all about passing these kids through and making as much money as possible,” he said.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Imagine a manager firing all 30 of his direct reports. What would you suspect was the problem, the manager or the workers? Failing isn't like firing, its more like giving an maximally unsatisfactory performance review (and, really, more like being doing so as one of a panel of reviewers .) Professors, generally, neither admit nor dismiss students from the university (which is the nearest parallel to hiring and firing), and don't generally act as "supervisors" in other respects (except in the case when a faculty member has an "advisor" relationship to a student, particular a graduate student, but that's different than the relationship of an instructor to students enrolled in a course.)
- JadeNB 12y agoHorwitz acknowledged that “a few” of the best performers might not deserve an F. But the school wouldn’t let him teach just those students, so he had no choice but to flunk everyone and leave the course, he said. Wow—as a teacher myself, I went to this story all prepared to root for this guy, but can't. "[T]he school wouldn't let him teach just those students, so he had no choice but to flunk everyone"? Who knows what's going on inside the classroom that we don't know—but, whatever happened, regardless of the provocation, comments like this [0] are a stain on the profession of teaching. It is our (teachers') job to deal with our students professionally, and that professionalism on our part becomes more, not less, important when it is not demonstrated by our students. [0] Assuming that it is an accurate representation of what he said. I was once the subject of a friendly story in my local paper, and, even with the best of intentions on the reporter's part, I was amazed at how different what she wrote was from what I meant (and, I believe, said).
- wahsd 12y agoI am not sure that it really is a teacher, let alone professor's professional responsibility to have to deal with the student's lack of basic human decency. I don't know what happened in that class and I also don't know if his statement about "a few" not deserving being flunked is accurate, but it does not change the fact of the matter that a teacher / professor / lecturer's only job is to teach and educate. Their job is not crowd control or behavior modification therapy. I don't see any way how A&M is not negligent in performing their duty to assure an environment to allow him to perform his contractual obligation to teach the students that are there to learn. Especially if he requested that the disruptive students leave and / or be removed from the class, he and the affected students that were possibly not contributing to the disruption should really be suing the university for contract non-performance. If you go to a university and expect education and instruction and the school does not perform it's duty to assure that happens, they are in breach of contract. There doesn't seem to be any real difference from any other service contract.
- JadeNB 12y ago> I am not sure that it really is a teacher, let alone professor's professional responsibility to have to deal with the student's lack of basic human decency. It is every professional's responsibility to deal professionally even with unprofessional behaviour. That doesn't mean tolerating or excusing the behaviour. For example, as a teacher, if I am repeatedly provoked and harrassed by students (which has never happened!), then I am within my rights to ask them to stop, to call security, and even to refuse to return to the classroom until some assurance is made that it is a safe environment. That is a professional response to unprofessional behaviour. What I am not entitled to do is to say that there are some good apples, but, because of the few (or many) bad apples, I am going to fail everyone. That is an unprofessional response.
- aggieben 12y agoI've taught a graduate-level class in which I caught every single student cheating at least once (18 students), including 6 of them on the final paper (for which I set an absurdly low bar). I failed those 6, and I gave zeros for all the other individual instances. I should have failed them all.
- ggchappell 12y agoProfessor here, with a viewpoint that seems to be underrepresented. The kind of thing discussed in this article would absolutely not fly at my university. We are expected to formulate standards for grading, inform the students of these standards, and follow them when assigning grades. A relatively standard term for grading in ways that does not follow announced standards is "capricious grading". And many -- perhaps most, perhaps all -- U.S. universities now have official policies against it. Egregious violations of such policies would be grounds for various kinds of penalities/punishment. That is not to say that cheating is irrelevant. For example, every syllabus I write contains the line, "Academic dishonesty will not be tolerated, and will be dealt with according to [my school's] procedures." In another comment, user hn_ says, "A syllabus is not a contract." This is correct. That means that a syllabus is not enforceable in a court of law. However, university policy may still dictate that a syllabus is an ironclad statement of how the course will be conducted. So, for example, I have seen a student make a complaint against a professor and take it up the chain of command. The first question asked by each of the administrators the complaint came to was, "What does the syllabus say?" If the professor is found to be acting in accordance with the course syllabus, then the student has a much harder time making a case -- at the very least. A related issue, which seems to be an important one in the case mentioned in the article, is that grading standards are generally to be applied individually. There is such a thing as group work, of course; in such cases we make it clear that each person in the group is judged by the performance of the group as a whole. Now, I don't know how accurately this article is representing the actual events that occurred. But if Horwitz really is assigning individual grades based on a nebulous judgement about the class as a whole, then I would say he is clearly guilty of a violation of professional ethics. What "the class deserves" is simply irrelevant to an individual's grade.