4 ms·
The problem with that theory is I don't know of any women who are actually able to miscarry at will. A garbled version of that theory got some politicians in h
by ars 12y ago
The problem with that theory is I don't know of any women who are actually able to miscarry at will.
A garbled version of that theory got some politicians in hot water with the whole "during rape, their body can shut it down" comment.
- dhimes 12y agoAgree. I've seen ability to orgasm linked to selectivity for fertilization, as the speculation (I don't follow it enough to know if it is a theory or not in any allowable sense of the word) is that (female) orgasm during intercourse helps the sperm reach the egg.
- Jun8 12y agoIt doesn't have to be "at will", our bodies do a lot of processing without us being consciously aware of it. I think it is well within reason that the body may detect an abnormal embryo and respond to it.
- derefr 12y agoIt's not in the control of the conscious mind. It is controlled by the body (or, you might say, by an evolutionary adaptation instantiated in the linkages of hormonal pathways in the brain.) Note that miscarriage and spontaneous abortion are separate things. Miscarriage happens because the foetus dies in the womb, or the womb is ruptured, and the mother's body detects this. Any other cause is spontaneous abortion—effectively "something the mother['s body] did." In humans, at least the experience of the emotions of extreme stress, and extreme fear, can cause spontaneous abortion. In a number of other animals (with a large subset of those being the ones that menstruate), there is the Bruce effect[1]: when the detection by the vomeronasal organ of an unfamiliar male's pheromonal signature precedes/causes spontaneous abortion. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bruce_effect http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bruce_effect
- XorNot 12y agoThat is a poor explanation given that extreme stress is known to have all sorts of physiological effects and is noted to negatively effect reproductive success in numerous species. But not all those species menstruate as noted by the article.
- derefr 12y agoThe thing muddying the water with stress, is that most things that trigger stress are also bad for the body, and thus for foetal development. Making rats run until they collapse from exhaustion might cause miscarriage, but it's unclear whether that is due to stress-hormone-induced spontaneous abortion, or due to the mother's body using up some micronutrient necessary for the foetus, thus causing a developmental defect which either kills the foetus or stalls its metabolism enough to be detected. I'm unaware of whether there has been the study of the effects of purely psychological (or synthetic, using injected epinephrine) stress on spontaneous abortion rates. It's much clearer with fear, though; things that cause a fear response don't tend to harm you (in fact, in an adaptive environment, to the degree that a fear response is created, you tend to avoid harm you would otherwise succumb to) but do trigger spontaneous abortion anyway. This would be much simpler to prove/disprove a purely-hormonal effect.