3 ms·
'Ted Hilles, the chairman, was a remarkably kind man who was embarrassed by having to do so, but he read the student comments aloud to each of us. "This is the
by cafard 12y ago
'Ted Hilles, the chairman, was a remarkably kind man who was embarrassed by having to do so, but he read the student comments aloud to each of us. "This is the kind of teacher that I came to Yale to study with,", the student you had given a B+ or an A would say. Then there would follow the report of students like Smithers, to whom you cad given a C or a D: "This man is the worst teacher I have ever studied with, he is a disgrace to the Yale faculty and far infirior [sic] to my masters at Andover. A profound cynicism about student comments was born from the experience of hearing these absolutely opposite evaluations one after another and knowing how closely they correlated with the grades you had given."
--Alvin Kernan, In Plato's Cave
I don't recall there being student evaluations of teachers in my undergraduate days (which were not spent at Yale or anything like it). When I went back to school part time in my 30s, I wrote bad things about only a couple of instructors, both for showing up unprepared (and occasionally not showing up at all).
- balabaster 12y agoThe problem with this approach is that it's hard to evaluate the performance of your teacher until many years later, at a time when you only just came to realize that not only had you learned a lesson, but also the magnitude and how profound that lesson was. I didn't come to appreciate everything my grade school teachers instilled in me until many years into my professional career. If you'd asked me as I was getting ready for my exams how I'd rated them as teachers, those I liked the most would have gotten the highest grades regardless of how much I'd really learned from them. Those I liked the least would have gotten the lowest grades. It wasn't until many years later that those I liked the least during my academic career (if you can call it that) were the ones who actually taught me the most. It would have been a shame for them to be fired on something so subjective as how much I liked them or how dissatisfied I was that they'd just issued me the 4th 'D' grade in a row. It's only now that I genuinely appreciate everything they taught me that I feel honestly worthy of sitting in their classroom again to learn what is they're willing to impart. So I say thanks to those teachers that pushed me, those that held me accountable, those that I disliked during school. It was you that would likely have been fired by these performance evaluations that gave me the most. I just never would have had the foresight to give you the grade you deserved.