6 ms·
> you provide not one bit of argument or evidence to support that for any of the areas you say it about. Well, this isn't a very technical discussion, but I c
by pron 12y ago
> you provide not one bit of argument or evidence to support that for any of the areas you say it about.
Well, this isn't a very technical discussion, but I can quickly list them: for shared mutation I think the Clojure approach of transactional/atomic mutation everywhere rather than RT-everywhere is simpler; for correctness/side-effects, imperative effect systems may be easier (well, they don't quite exist other than in a very limited, experimental form, in Koka and Java 8's pluggable type systems -- but Haskell doesn't provide a very fine-grained side-effect-control either). For correctness, Esterel (which has been well proven) and its descendants, seems a lot more sophisticated in terms of proving correctness, while being more intuitive (of course, Esterel introduces a limited computation model, but so does Haskell -- or languages in the same vain -- if they are to be decidable).
> the problem for sharing that experience is many of them are in internal proprietary systems
Yes, that, too, is a problem, but the bigger problem is that uses in the industry are vanishingly rare -- and the bigger the domain challenge, the rarer still they are. For example, I don't think there exists a single case of a Haskell program that tackles complexity in such a way that implementing it in, say, Java or Clojure, is prohibitively expensive.
- creichert 12y agohttps://github.com/commercialhaskell/commercialhaskell https://github.com/commercialhaskell/commercialhaskell Among the companies listed are Facebook and Microsoft. This list may not be long or exhaustive but it does show a number of companies who are publicly willing to say they use Haskell. It was started in January. I can personally attest to several companies I have worked with not mentioned in the list which also use Haskell internally. Haskell is not always the bread and butter of the business software. However, it often has an extremely strong presence for developing internal tools, compilers for DSL's, and (micro)services for various tasks.
- pron 12y ago> as an extremely strong presence for developing internal tools I wouldn't go there. Awk has an extremely strong presence in internal tools; Haskell has some minor presence if you squint hard enough. If the unconventional language promising to help tackle software complexity in this modern age is used as an Awk replacement (or TCL, or Perl) then what are we doing here? The real story is that Haskell may well be an excellent first step towards the future of programming and a great breakthrough -- or it may be a dead end -- we simply don't know because it's never really been tried. Putting it in the ring with Awk or Perl -- where it's losing, BTW -- is an insult to both Haskell and Awk. Using Haskell as one more language for "small stuff" is not using it at all, because that's not what it's meant to do, and it's certainly not where it can fulfill its promise.