3 ms·
Here's my take on the matter, which I know quite well: * The guys in charge of Tcl/Tk, in about 2000, completely missed out on seeing that the future of Linux
by davidw 17y ago
Here's my take on the matter, which I know quite well:
* The guys in charge of Tcl/Tk, in about 2000, completely missed out on seeing that the future of Linux UI's was Gnome and KDE, and basically did not touch the Unix Tk look and feel until Tk 8.5. This was a major mistake. It would have actually been possible to make Tk look at least a little bit nicer on Linux without even touching the C code, but this was not done.
* However, Tk looks decent on other platforms, and these days looks decent on Linux too.
* Tk also gained a bad reputation because it made it so easy for just about anyone to throw together a GUI. Very often, 'anyone' did, with no prior training or knowledge of how to do a proper GUI, and the results have given the toolkit a bad name where it's not really deserved.
* Where there is some blame to go around is the lack of a culture of creating good GUI's. Brent Welch's otherwise excellent book, for instance, contains next to nothing about how to make a good looking, effective GUI, although it has chapters on how to use all the different widgets.
At this point, Tcl and Tk have themselves something of a marketing problem, because despite some very real and positive recent progress, and lots of nice features, everyone "knows" that they are so 1999. If nothing else, Tcl and Tk have been a fascinating study in how to market good technology badly; and by marketing I don't just mean 'selling/advertising' but gathering user requirements, keeping up with market trends, and so on. That's not to say they don't have some problems, but they aren't insuperable or worse than problems other systems have.
In any case, if you need to do an cross-platform GUI, or a quick GUI on any platform, Tcl and Tk are still a very valid choice, depending on your requirements.
- nailer 17y ago"* The guys in charge of Tcl/Tk, in about 2000, completely missed out on seeing that the future of Linux UI's was Gnome and KDE, and basically did not touch the Unix Tk look and feel until Tk 8.5. This was a major mistake. " You're totally right, but also the fonts in particular were terrible blocky messes on Linux (and may well still be, I don't have any Tk apps anymore).