5 ms·
UAVs are the future. They are more affordable, they can be stealther, they can be smaller, they can stay flying for longer, and they require less ground suppor
by bhouston 12y ago
UAVs are the future. They are more affordable, they can be stealther, they can be smaller, they can stay flying for longer, and they require less ground support.
I can not believe the F-35 hasn't been completely cancelled yet. Every partner of the US doesn't really want these expensive beasts.
- Jtsummers 12y agoNot trying to justify the F-35, it's a cluster fuck, but manned aircraft will be around for a while. Unless the operator is local, the communication latency for UAVs makes them unsuitable for some types of combat missions.
- melling 12y agoMake them semi-autonomous. For the amount of money spent on the F35, surely we can make the UAV's smarter.
- Jtsummers 12y agoI was thinking mostly about air-to-air combat. Other missions (recon, bombing, ground support, refueling, etc.) can or are done with UAVs now. But on thinking about it further, the UAVs of tomorrow can be much faster and more maneuverable than any manned fighter aircraft once you remove the requirement of keeping the pilot alive. I don't know that it could be done today, but I imagine in the not-to-distant future we'll have effective air-to-air UAVs.
- outworlder 12y agoFor some types, not all of them. Also, 'Unmanned' does not necessarily means "remote-controlled". They can be autonomous. We are making progress: http://www.naval-technology.com/news/newsus-navys-x-47b-conducts-first-autonomous-aerial-refuelling-4560861 http://www.naval-technology.com/news/newsus-navys-x-47b-cond... This is after carrier landings and takeoffs and formation flying with manned aircraft. And all that developed at a fraction of what the F-35 program will spend on engines alone
- astazangasta 12y agoAutonomous military drones seem politically unlikely. At least, I hope so, what a nightmare.
- josefresco 12y agoIf you think drones, or autonomous planes will fix what governments spend (and waste) on military projects - you're in for a huge disappointment. If anything, "drone" type weapons have meant an increase in budgets. While the F-35 budgets looks atrocious now - in a couple decades we'll look back and think "how cheap!".
- outworlder 12y agoYou have a point. I remember reading a couple of years ago that the thing causing F-35's biggest delays was software, not the hardware. The software for the radar alone is reported to be a few millions of lines of C++ code.
- Jtsummers 12y agohttp://spectrum.ieee.org/riskfactor/aerospace/aviation/software-testing-problems-continue-to-plague-f35-joint-strike-fighter-program http://spectrum.ieee.org/riskfactor/aerospace/aviation/softw... An article on the topic. The summary, IMO, is that no one acquiring major systems (defense or otherwise) seems to properly understand the costs and risks of software. More money spent up front on their design, development and test framework would have significantly reduced the risks while (naturally) costing more early on, but should reduce costs over the lifetime. They ignore this and spend more after the deadlines have passed as a consequence.
- aqme28 12y agoThat is an interesting definition of "progress."
- outworlder 12y agoThe technical progress is indeed impressive. Maybe not in the ethics department.
- cwyers 12y agoProcurement is often not about warfighting but about politics. That's why they split construction up among multiple locations -- that's multiple congressmen who have a vested incentive in seeing that money continue to roll into their district and provide jobs.
- glesica 12y agoIt's basically "New Deal"-type spending that is acceptable to the right wing (which, for the most part these days, includes the Democrats). The economy is in shambles, so you have to do something about it. But fixing the economy would involve breaking from your orthodoxy and upsetting your wealthy sponsors. So what do you do? Pay the unemployed to build killing machines, everyone loves those.
- cbd1984 12y agoIt's easy to blame the wealthy sponsors, but some blame also rests on the people who are convinced that literally all of the taxes they pay on their 250%-of-poverty-line income go to support those on 150%-of-poverty-line assistance programs, and that that's a terrible thing, because of someone they met once who got more than they 'deserved' from the system. There's a whole psychology there which is missed by the usual "blame everything on the rich" reflexes. It's a problem which will have to be addressed if any social reforms are actually going to stick, as opposed to being pissed away in tax cuts and whinging about how much more deserving the poor were back before they could afford to treat two major diseases a lifetime.
- glesica 12y agoOh I agree with you. But I also think that that attitude is driven, at least partially, by the rich. If you're part of the top N%, for N<50, you must convince other people that what is in your best interest is also in their best interest. This is what has happened, the middle class have been turned against themselves and the poor.
- josho 12y agoYes. It sometimes feels like the U.S. Is a social welfare state. Except all the social welfare is given to large military contractors. Humph, I suppose that's what they mean by military industrial complex.
- yborg 12y agoEvery air force in the world wants these expensive beasts, it's the entire identity of the service - TOP GUN knights of old jousting for supremacy. The command structure of most air forces comes from the fighter pilots, it's a common complaint in USAF that transport, which is maybe the most useful day to day function, is a career dead-end. Nobody in the military will take seriously a "warrior" that runs a joystick on a RPV, and when these things gain more autonomy it's going to eliminate the necessity for whole ranks of command. So the Air Force will fight to the bitter end for these things, long after they are will be effective solely as air show entertainment.
- bhouston 12y ago> Every air force in the world wants these expensive beasts, it's the entire identity of the service - TOP GUN knights of old jousting for supremacy. I agree that these are shiny new tools for the airforce and its pilots. Here in Canada it has been a public shitstorm of rapidly increasing procurement costs and quality issues. Canada has officially delayed purchasing F-35 for the foreseeable future: http://ottawacitizen.com/news/politics/f-35-faces-further-delays-cost-increases-congressional-auditor http://ottawacitizen.com/news/politics/f-35-faces-further-de... It (the purchase of the F-35s) may still happen after the next election, but it isn't something the public wants.
- peeters 12y agoA large part of the criticism was around whether a single engine jet was really appropriate for patrolling the Canadian Arctic. I imagine that rhetoric is going to get ramped up as reports of that single engine being unreliable surface.