4 ms·
It's easy to forget living in 21st century Britain how far we've come generally. Thanks for the reminder.
by noir_lord 12y ago
It's easy to forget living in 21st century Britain how far we've come generally.
Thanks for the reminder.
- pjc50 12y agoAnd the death penalty was only formally abolished by the Human Rights Act 1998 (for the remaining offences of high treason or arson in a naval dockyard). I believe that polls on the subject of reintroducing it for serious crimes regularly return over 50% support. Edit: oh and you can still get disproportionate sentences for trivial crimes in California under the "three strikes" law. There are people serving life sentences for minor shoplifting.
- noir_lord 12y agoIndeed and the world is not perfect but it's a damn sight better than it was 200 years ago (in the west) anyway. To quote William Gibson > "The future is already here — it's just not very evenly distributed."
- runarb 12y ago> I believe that polls on the subject of reintroducing > it for serious crimes regularly return over 50% support. To some degree understandable. I used to be against the death penalty for humanitarian reason, but after Anders Behring Breivik gunned down 69 people, mostly children, and got only 21 years in prison [0], I think it would have been better if we just had hanged him. At least then the families of his victim could get to move on, knowing that they will not meet him on the street sometime in the future. 0: 21 years is the maximum prison sentence in Norway, but the prison term can then be repeatedly extended by five years as long as he is considered a threat to society. However that someone is being a threat to society can be hard to prove, so it is totally possible that he will be getting out some day.
- matthewmacleod 12y agoso it is totally possible that he will be getting out some day. Isn't that the whole point of a maximum prison sentence, though?
- iaskwhy 12y agoI have some curiosity about how you went from 21 years of jail time to the death penalty without even thinking about something else like a life sentence.
- emn13 12y agoCases like these - you could try to argue what's best with all kinds of arguments, ideas, principles and aim. Death? Life? 21 years + you need to make a shrink happy? So the interesting question is: why does his current sentence bother you? I'm honestly curious on your perspective.
- lootonbaynard 12y ago"There are people serving life sentences for minor shoplifting." So don't repeatedly shoplift and you won't have any problem. Seems fair to me.
- vixen99 12y agoSo why bother with minor shoplifting if, bar the death penalty, you can commit some really lucrative crime and receive the same penalty? Fair? Hardly! It's a law best described politely as 'short-sighted' in that someone hasn't bothered to work out its implications.
- Lawtonfogle 12y agoIf possible, go big. Once your crime is large enough, you just need to pay a really large fine to make your troubles all go away.
- chizthtor 12y agoIt seems fair to him.
- emn13 12y agoPerhaps. But is the outcome really in anyone's best interests? Is it cost-effective? This isn't exactly a value-adding business, so you're paying for some unlucky idiot's incarceration instead of healthcare, policing, infrastructure... It sounds insane to me. Also, are you sure you know every law on the book? I suspect quite a few people break more laws than they think, they're just never enforced. Until some DA wants to set an example, and throws the book at you - at which point this is more about personal gain (for the DA) than benefit to society, let alone fairness. Let's put it this way - unless all laws are uniformly and blindly enforced, they're never going to be entirely fair. With so many laws on the book, and with each instance at the whim of very few people (law enforcement) with virtually no checks and balances, you can be absolutely sure it's not fair. If furthermore even the judiciary is explicitly forbidden from using common sense... ...it's about as fair as cancer. Sure, you can be really stupid (or get really screwed), but nothing you do can entirely protect you - and even those taking risks don't always pay a (significant) price. Some people are unfortunately born with genetic or cultural risk-factors that you really can't call fair. It's not the end of the world, and it's not societies worst problem, but let's not kid ourselves that the justice system really deserves that name.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Shihan 12y agoUnfortunately not all parts of the world are on the same civilized level yet. There are many countries in which the law is based on so called divine rules and there it is seen as something positive/progressive that the woman can give birth to her child before she is being stoned for her "crime" (e.g. adultery (true meaning: have been raped)). Way to go humanity.
- sneak 12y agoThe lines are imaginary. They still execute people all of the time in America, oftentimes for things just as trivial.
- maob 12y agoAlthough I'm against the death penalty and I think it's used too much here in the US, I don't think it's used 'all of the time' and I'm pretty sure it's never for something trivial. Please correct me if I'm wrong.
- logfromblammo 12y agoAn alarmingly large number of police have acquired the delusion that it is permissible for them to exercise the state's power to punish suspected criminals, without affording them the courtesy of due process. I don't think this behavior is increasing by all that much. I think the increasing ubiquity of cameras capable of recording decent quality video and the increasing ease in distributing that video is making the existing behavior more noticeable. The fact that police killings are not capital punishment executions is largely a semantic distinction. Some people feel it is important, while others are less apt to recognize it. As such, whether the death penalty is used "all the time" or not, and whether it is used for "something trivial" depends largely on how you count the bodies. People have been killed by police for misdemeanor offenses, or even no reasonable suspicion whatsoever. I don't erase that semantic distinction entirely, but it is rather counterproductive to abolish the post-conviction capital punishment without also rigorously investigating and prosecuting all police-involved deaths. If cops believe that a suspect deserves the death penalty, and the state does not employ it, that person may never get the benefit of a single hearing before a judge.
- iak8god 12y agoAround 1,000 people were killed by police in the US last year[1]. I assume that in the vast majority of those cases the use of lethal force was justified to protect the officer(s) or bystanders. Then there are the mistakes. In what percentage of these cases would you guess that suspect was killed because the officer decided to play judge, jury and executioner? 1%? Even a shockingly high 10%, that would not be an order of magnitude more than the number of capital punishment executions per year. [1] http://reason.com/blog/2014/12/09/more-than-1000-people-have-been-killed-b http://reason.com/blog/2014/12/09/more-than-1000-people-have...