4 ms·
> It is here to control the population in the country. I am not even sure about that. It is there because it is already there. By that I mean it is a giant bu
by rdtsc 12y ago
> It is here to control the population in the country.
I am not even sure about that. It is there because it is already there. By that I mean it is a giant bureaucratic investment project with billions of dollars flowing through. Many careers (oh look job creation!), business opportunities, support, training, etc tied into it.
During terrorist scares its powers expanded because there was an opportunity to expand, so expand it did. But not because some cabal of Illuminati wanted to read sexting messages of every person on earth.
So now it is sort of a cancer that feeds and grows and acquires power for itself. The same with TSA and many other such, at the time, seemingly temporary institutions and measures.
- Rapzid 12y agoThis is how I see it. NSA gonna NSA. NSA gonna maximize the amount of NSA it does. This is why we are SUPPOSED to have congressional oversight. It is quite literally the point of congressional oversight; to keep things from getting out of control. To ensure the US citizen's and the US's ideals and interests are being served in organizations who have every incentive to pursue their own self-interests. However 9/11 happened and they were able to capitalize big time on fear. Our intelligence community does way to much serving its own interests under the guise of serving US interests IMHO. However, I believe it is ALSO dangerous to have all this information as pointed out by the OP. Again, this is why we are supposed to have congressional oversight and why transparency and secret courts are such hot issues.
- coldtea 12y ago>This is why we are SUPPOSED to have congressional oversight. Gongressional oversight, in the form of some special briefings, and meetings and such, means nothing. In a real democracy what you should have is oversight by the people, in an open and transparent system. Congress itself doesn't have that oversight (what with gerrymandering et al).
- kevinnk 12y ago> In a real democracy what you should have is oversight by the people, in an open and transparent system. In this context what exactly would that entail?
- coldtea 12y agoIf you mean "in the context on secret spying on citizens what would that entail" then the answer is that not all contexts are appropriate for a democracy. Those who are not should be altered to fit democratic procedures or be abolished. If spying needed to happen, the procedures should be open and transparent. All the stuff Snowden brought forward, should have been released officially in advance. But before of that, the democratic thing for such a mass offense against privacy would be a referendum: "We need to massively track you, including such and such information and sources. Yes / No". Furthermore, nothing secret should go on that's not explicitly voted, e.g. absolutely no sharing of the data meant for national security with police departments to head-start a case against a citizen etc. No indefinite storage of those items either. Delete them with a rolling delete every few years or so.
- coldtea 12y ago>I am not even sure about that. It is there because it is already there. By that I mean it is a giant bureaucratic investment project with billions of dollars flowing through. Many careers (oh look job creation!), business opportunities, support, training, etc tied into it. "It's there because it's there" is probably true, but that doesn't preclude the "population control" part. Such a system, will: 1) fight tendencies for change that doesn't play well with it ("self preservation"). 2) Find ways to justify its existance and funding, including targeting people, labelling them as "threats", and convincing politicians and the public about its necessity. For targets of such a system think Aaron Swartz, Snowden, Assange, activists and such (and back to the past: the red scare, the huge FBI files and government interference with people like MLK, etc). >But not because some cabal of Illuminati wanted to read sexting messages of every person on earth. No, but a cabal of high ranking officials and corporations wanted a multi-billion system they could profit from, and have forever wanted a populace that plays by the establishment rules. It doesn't have to involve ancient orders to be a conspiracy, all power decisions taken behind closed doors and in a non democratic way are.
- cm2187 12y agoI agree. Intelligence services always liked collecting data. In fact, before facebook and computers, they had whole departments maintaining big paper files on who published what opinion, what any informer said on anyone, people's CV, relationships, etc. Browsing these files efficiently was a discipline in itself. The move to electronic files was only natural and they collected more data automatically just because they could, but it is sort of in their DNA, nothing to do with terrorism. The problem with these files is that they are only going to really bite us over a longer period of time. When intelligence services get more reckless about them (procedures becoming more lax over time is a natural decay), and when they contain sufficient data over a long period. Imagine what Nixon would have done with this data. We don't even need to invoke dictators!