7 ms·
Police Body Cameras: What Good Is a Video You Can't See?
- greenjellybean 12y agoI only skimmed the article but the discussion on how police body cam footage is released should be had. On the one hand, I would like the footage to be fully released but what about instances similar to people being swatted[0]? Surly there should be limits in place but can we really trust police to be ethical? Hopefully more people comment but surely there will be more of these types of articles written in the future as body cams continue to roll out. [0]https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=swatted https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=swatted
- jeffdavis 12y agoNice, balanced article on an emotional topic. I think most people would agree that the video should come into evidence if someone ends up dead. Also, most people would agree that videos should not all be released publicly. But there are a lot of difficult situations between those two extremes. Even if the rules about releasing footage are quite restricted, I think body cameras will influence the behavior of police. Not always for the better necessarily, but I think they will reduce the number of fatal police shootings.
- thaumasiotes 12y agoHow do you envision body cameras making police behavior worse?
- TheCondor 12y agoFundamentally, they are people. Maybe even more importantly, crime doesn't just happen nonstop all the time everywhere. How many of us spend time at work not working? If every one of your smoke breaks, trips to hn, and other assorted breaks were recorded, I'm sure a damning case could be made against you the next time you're up for review. You don't think that would have political implications? I can't think of all the out comes that could have. Likewise, I'll tell a personal story. I tend to drive fast. I've not had many tickets but I've had a few. Two really cool police gave me warnings a handful of years back instead of tickets; not just a warning but they reminded me of the car seat in the back, my family and suggested I slow down to be safer. It had a dramatic impact, I'd just get pissed off and pay a ticket but the warning, that they chose to give, stuck with me more and I've slowed down. Could that be done by a robot police officer that never takes breaks and follows the law literally and letter by letter? What if those cops had a record of giving certain races warnings but came down hard on other races? im not against body cameras, especially in the current world of paramilitary style police, but it seems like there is a need for some human wisdom on a case by case basis here. Simple fixes could easily have some bad outcomes.
- jeffdavis 12y agoInaction, hesitation, CYA, stay out of the way, etc.
- brc 12y agoGood cops should insist on body cameras. A good cop has nothing to lose and everything to gain. False accusations go both ways - police are accused of acting improperly and criminals are (obviously) accused of acting improperly. A good cop should never act improperly but may be accused of it, and they'd want evidence that it isn't the case.
- JshWright 12y agoMost good cops I know _are_ in favor of body cameras. However... I think it's pretty reasonable to have some reservations... How would you feel about wearing a camera that would allow your supervisor to view absolutely everything you did during the day (sans bathroom breaks)?
- slimsag 12y agoIs there good reason for the videos to be public record? Why not have our judicial system decide/review police video on a case-by-case basis, rather than having them be public records? A defendant should be innocent until proven guilty -- and those videos apply just as well. Is the police video for or against you? The court should decide. If the video is "missing", a outside authority should investigate and weight should be given to the possibility that evidence was tampered with by the police. The public should demand this just as we have body-cameras.
- nowarninglabel 12y agoThere's a real-world problem seeking a solution, video that is verifiably stored (in multiple places) and encrypted but accessible via the judiciary when a court order allows it. It's not that the pieces aren't there, but rather that someone would need to package it well and sell it to local governments.
- josephpmay 12y agoI can say as a matter of fact that the body camera system being implemented by the LAPD works exactly as you suggest. This is one of the reasons why it's taking so long to implement. Many people don't realize how important it is for a system like this to be implemented properly the first time.
- bigiain 12y agoBecause many (most?) of the classes of people most victimised by police are in no financial position to instigate a court case just to find out if the cops bodycam footage show him beating/tasing their son/father/brother.
- fnordfnordfnord 12y ago>Is there good reason for the videos to be public record? There are certainly some good reasons why such videos shouldn't be (by default). > Why not have our judicial system decide/review police video on a case-by-case basis, rather than having them be public records? The judicial system has already shown itself to be inadequate in the matter of self-oversight.
- lotharbot 12y agoI was impressed by the way this article introduced the relevant issues without getting caught up in trying to give simple solutions. Because body cams will capture footage of victims and associates and bystanders, as well as perpetrators and officers, there's an inherent tension between protecting the privacy of everyone in a video and allowing those in the video to see the captured footage of themselves. Every "simple" solution I can think of (including all of the ones described in the article), I can easily envision scenarios where that proposed solution would seem to be inappropriate. I suspect the way we handle police body cam videos will be a point of contentious debate for another decade or more.
- higherpurpose 12y agoThat doesn't make any sense to me. Video of bystanders? So what? Shouldn't we be outraged about other public cameras as well that the police use to catch criminals then? Don't people who film the police also film "bystanders"? I think at the very least if the videos are kept secret until judicial review, then the police officers should be forced to keep them on all the time during work hours. The videos should also be automatically uploaded somewhere where that police department can't control what happens to the videos.
- josephpmay 12y agoPolice often get calls about domestic disputes that require them to go inside houses. Would you want a video from inside your house to have to be made available to the public by law?
- higherpurpose 12y agoEven if the "one-size-fits-all philosophy" about this doesn't work, it could still be regulated in a way where most of the video is public. Cop responds to a domestic issue and knocks on the door? He records himself prior to that in front of the door saying he will close the camera for that next action. SWAT team about to enter a home or use a "no-knock" warrant? They aren't allowed to turn off the camera there. Same for the vast majority of the other police actions that happen in public. Unfortunately, I'm sure the cops will find some loopholes to abuse this, too, and turn off the cameras when they aren't supposed to, especially if nobody ever punishes cops for such actions (which they don't), but I'd probably still take that over making all footage private by default. In many cases the cops doing bad things would still get caught because they forgot to turn off the camera or didn't think ahead to do it.
- marze 12y agoA lot of police work takes place in public areas, where there is no expectation of privacy and anyone is able to take pictures and video. There doesn't seem to be any reason not to make all footage from public areas generally available.
- sdrothrock 12y agoWhat if you were being raped in a park and policemen came to assist you. Would you want that footage to be publicly available? Likewise, would you want everyone who ever hated you to have access to that footage to use however they want? Once the cat's out of the bag... Edit: Other fun situations: 1. You're attacked by someone and can't run, but have enough experience/training to subdue them; the cops show up later and the video doesn't show you being attacked, so you look like the aggressor. 2. You're attacked and can't defend yourself or fail to such an extent that people would look at the video and laugh at you. 3. You're on video doing something incredibly out of the norm for you, whatever the reason. 4. You're on video in a PLACE that you wish other people didn't know you frequented. A strip club, a gay bar, a church, a vegan grocery store, a pot dealer, etc. 5. You're on video doing something that your friends/family would react negatively to. Let's say you're a doctor and someone has a heart attack at Political Rally Green. You're up front and on camera for everyone else to see, including your family, who are all diehard Red supporters.
- spacemanmatt 12y agoAll those things are better than being attacked by police, framed by police, and having nothing to show for it.
- sdrothrock 12y agoI'm not trying to argue that they're not; I'm just saying why people could support police body cams and disagree with all video recorded being public.
- Frondo 12y agoSo that video evidence of the hypothetical rape could be sealed by the court. Problem solved. As for the rest (people would laugh at you if they saw the video?), that's pretty weak stuff.
- anonbanker 12y agothis is what subpoenas are for. Let the court force them to provide it. and if the camera "turns out" to be on the fritz, they can provide the IT support ticket, complete with dates and times entries were made.
- bigiain 12y agoMy approach? If the cop's camera suspiciously turns out to be "on the fritz, your honor", all the cops evidence loses it's "magic cop assumption of reliability", and they fail to establish any "balance of probability" in a purely he-said/she-said situation. (even _with_ backdated IT support ticket claims - make it in the individual cop's interest to have working, reliable gear - penalise him personally/professionally if he "lets it slide", just like he and his colleagues penalise you if you let your licence or insurance renewal "slide".)
- rasz_pl 12y agoPolice body cameras dont, an wont matter as long as old corrupt judges LET GO murderers recorded killing people. I mean what does it take to put a cop in prison when a video of him strangling someone to death is not enough?
- JupiterMoon 12y agoThis.
- JupiterMoon 12y agoIt was a homicide on camera. No one was charged. Hence why bother filming the police? They are already happy to kill people on camera. Filming it changes nothing.
- Shivetya 12y agoWelcome to the world the public employee unions have created; where once your employed its damn near impossible to fire you, let alone get you charged with a crime. A great article on how hard it is to fire a cop because of the rules police unions have managed to get into place. http://reason.com/archives/2012/10/19/how-special-rights-for-law-enforcement-m http://reason.com/archives/2012/10/19/how-special-rights-for...
- KMag 12y agoI agree that public servant unions generally have too much power. However, I'd like to hear more about your theory about how police unions have leverage over judges. Firing someone is much different from not throwing out a court case against them. I can see how police unions have a lot of leverage over the executive branch, but I'm not sure how they extend that leverage over the judicial branch.
- Shivetya 12y agoWell lets return to the Atlantic for an article on how. http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2014/12/how-police-unions-keep-abusive-cops-on-the-street/383258/ http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2014/12/how-poli... You have to be accused of a crime before a Judge gets involved. That was the whole point I was making. The unions do their best to keep the officer from ever being charged. Got to love the down votes on my previous post, ignorance is of the power of these unions are why we have the problems in the police we do today. Even politicians run scared as some city unions have put up billboards next to homes of politicians who dare challenge them.
- poqi 12y agoThis is a much better article: http://www.salon.com/2015/04/24/we_must_disband_the_police_body_cameras_arent_enough_only_radical_change_will_stop_cops_who_kill/ http://www.salon.com/2015/04/24/we_must_disband_the_police_b...
- tomohawk 12y agoThis illustrates exactly why having the gov't do something is a much different thing than when private citizens or groups do something, and why the gov't often ends up with a solution that "doesn't make sense". I have to wonder if, in the end, what what we'll end up with is universal surveillance, not imposed by police, but imposed on ourselves. It will just be assumed that everyone and every building will be recording video all the time. At that point, it won't matter if police are recording or not.
- lorddoig 12y agoIf the victim/complainant/whatever was the one with the camera, you'd still get most if not more of the benefits of accountability. So how can we make that happen instead? Simple - have the police there in two distinct roles: 1) a cop; and 2) your own personal film crew. They'd film it and perhaps even hold it "in trust", but you'd own it. Such a system would empower citizens a lot and contribute almost nil to the scary mega-state. We're currently experiencing a shift to authoritarianism by the backdoor with NSA and friends, and in such times cheap and effective solutions such as this, which achieve the stated goal and no more, should be championed I think.
- nevinera 12y ago>“If you just put a swirl blur on somebody’s face, it’s not very difficult to unswirl that blur, and then all of a sudden it’s un-redacted,” Shaw said. Then use a REAL BLUR.
- thejrk 12y agoHN turning into Reddit one post at a time.
- greenjellybean 12y agoStraight from the HN Guidelines: "If your account is less than a year old, please don't submit comments saying that HN is turning into Reddit. It's a common semi-noob illusion, as old as the hills." A lot of the posts here end up on Reddit and vice versa. Big part of this I suspect is due to the fact that most people here use both sites pretty regularly, I surely do.
- thejrk 12y agoJust because an account is less than a year old doesn't mean the person behind the account is new here. I'm certainly not. But thanks for trying to be the internet police. Also, just because a person visits both sites doesn't mean we NEED the circle-jerk BS here.
- jrs235 12y agoAnd if officers can turn them off when ever without accountability then what's the point? We won't have accountability, we'll have accountability theater. If this cadet (not an officer) hadn't (probably) thrown his career chances out the window, the officer involved would never have been held accountable and probably would continue to do it again in the future: http://thefreethoughtproject.com/police-cadet-turns-cop-turning-body-cam-pummeling-victim/#Xf7oUQvQH1rdESvr.99 http://thefreethoughtproject.com/police-cadet-turns-cop-turn... And, as others mentioned, as long of departments just hand out paid vacations, prosecutors refuse to press charges, and judges let officers go, video cameras won't matter.
- sblom 12y agoI think this made the HN front page the other week, but Seattle PD actually hosted a hackathon with the goal of getting good auto-redaction technology in place so that they could default-release body cam footage: https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20141222/14345929507/seattle-pd-holds-hackathon-to-solve-body-cam-footage-redaction-problem.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20141222/14345929507/seatt...