5 ms·
Many of the examples looked borderline to me. How much contrast is 'enough'? Also - surely this is something that should be fixable in the OS or browser? OSX h
by andybak 12y ago
Many of the examples looked borderline to me. How much contrast is 'enough'?
Also - surely this is something that should be fixable in the OS or browser? OSX has an high-contrast accessibility mode. Do we really need to fix this at source?
- hawkice 12y agoGood rule for contrast: If you would refer to the text color and background color by the same word, that's not enough contrast. Compare the good contrast examples, largely black on white or white on black, with the bad examples, universally gray on gray (or off-white on off-white).
- randallsquared 12y agoSo, the fewer words you know to refer to colors, the more contrast matters to you? :)
- kristopolous 12y agoAbsolutely correct. It's called the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis. You can refer to the Himba color experiment for more information : http://www.vidipedia.org/vidipedia-the-video-encyclopedia/viewvideo/166413/science/himba-colour-experiment.html http://www.vidipedia.org/vidipedia-the-video-encyclopedia/vi...
- mikeash 12y agoYou joke, but I bet it correlates pretty well.
- EliRivers 12y agoThis rings a bell inside my head; given people from a language/culture with two different words for what English speakers would identify as barely different shades of the same colour, they are objectively better at identifying those two shades than the native English speaker. Which essentially gives the answer "yes" to your question. Here's a reference that might be what's ringing inside my head: http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn11759-russian-speakers-get-the-blues.html http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn11759-russian-speakers... Particularly relevant quote: "This is the first time that evidence has been offered to show cross-linguistic differences in colour perception in an objective task" Here's more: https://eagereyes.org/blog/2011/you-only-see-colors-you-can-name https://eagereyes.org/blog/2011/you-only-see-colors-you-can-...
- sukilot 12y agohttp://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linguistic_relativity http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linguistic_relativity
- krick 12y agoThis "Russian experiment" is a bit weird, as though it's true that "синий" usually refers to darker colors and "голубой" to the lighter ones, both colors to chose from could be referred to as "синий" or "голубой" interchangeably. Actually, it's not that clear what is "синий" and "голубой" anyway: sky is like The "синий", but quite often referred to as "голубой" instead, but somebody's eyes almost never are referred to as "синий": maybe only if you want to emphasize how unusually bright they are. But if your dress would be the same color as the eyes, it could be called "синий" easily. What I'm trying to say, there's no that big difference between these two words in Russian to explain the experiment results, unlike what was shown to us on that video about some African tribe. More like "purple" and "violet" — there clearly is a difference, but many people would fail even to point which one is which, and some might even argue about that.
- thaumaturgy 12y agoYou might be right! I am colorblind, and for example I can't see the red component of violet, so most "violet" is just "blue" to me. Purple, too: I have trouble distinguishing the blue in purple, so a lot of purple simply looks "red". If it were up to me, there wouldn't be a word for violet, because it doesn't exist.
- DanBC 12y ago> do we really need to fix this at source? Yes. Otherwise you are chosing to exclude people.
- TheDong 12y agoAny choice you make will exclude some people. The colorblind won't be able to read it if you use some color combinations. Using such high-contrast fonts hurts my eyes and thus excludes me from enjoying it as much. It's likely people arenot "chosing to exclude", but rather happens to as a byproduct. It's far more likely someone chose low-contrast because they wished to help visitors eyes or for aesthetic purposes, not because they woke up that morning and said "Gosh I hate the sight-impaired". Being able to read a webpage is not a universal right. It is not the onus of the webpage to make itself readable. You don't demand that japanese webpages offer klingon translations when they only wish to reach a japanese audience simply because they're excluding those poor soles who prefer to read klingon, do you? It's perfectly reasonable to expect a user of the webpage to make it usable for themselves, whether that be by running it through google translate or turning on their OS's high contrast mode or whatever. The fact that the choice excludes people should not be bandied as if it's a real argument.
- DanBC 12y ago> It's perfectly reasonable to expect a user of the webpage to make it usable for themselves, whether that be by running it through google translate or turning on their OS's high contrast mode or whatever. No, it isn't. By deliberately choosing terrible contrast a designer is choosing to exclude people with visual impairment. That's why accessible websites is written into law and contrast is written into best practice guidance for making a website accessible. > Being able to read a webpage is not a universal right. It is not the onus of the webpage to make itself readable. There's quite a few situations where accessible websites are a human right. (Eg government websites would be covered by article 21). When you say "of course you can't read this website; you have a visual impairment" you are passing the blame. But the job of a website team - the thing they are paid for - is to provide information that's accessible to the target audience. It's not my job to read that information. I'm probably not getting paid to read the website. And bad contrast choices aren't just hard to read for people with visual impairment. They're hard to read for someone on a different monitor or in different lighting. > You don't demand that japanese webpages offer klingon translations when they only wish to reach a japanese audience simply because they're excluding those poor soles who prefer to read klingon, do you? You started by saying this was not about choosing to exclude people but here you clearly show that someone has made the choice to exclude a group. The difference being that it is fine to exclude speakers of a made up language; it's not acceptable to exclude disabled people.
- DanBC 12y agohttp://www.w3.org/WAI/PF/aria-practices/ http://www.w3.org/WAI/PF/aria-practices/ Section 12 talks about how to detect the high contrast mode used by the OS. One problem is that low-contrast does not just affect those with a visual impairment. It affects people with a different OS (the gamma on mac and windows is different), on differnet monitors, in different lighting, and with different but not impaired eyes. Most people won't be using high contrast mode because it sucks, and because bad web designers refuse to use high contrast fonts - why are they going to bother detecting high contrast mode?
- vacri 12y ago> Many of the examples looked borderline to me. Check out the fourth panel of the article. It doesn't take much to turn 'borderline' into 'awful'.