2 ms·
Another study undermined by the fallacy of controlling for an intermediate variable. Fulltext: https://www.dropbox.com/s/zn87fm4mmzkicjs/2014-mcclintock.pdf ht
by gwern 12y ago
Another study undermined by the fallacy of controlling for an intermediate variable.
Fulltext: https://www.dropbox.com/s/zn87fm4mmzkicjs/2014-mcclintock.pdf https://www.dropbox.com/s/zn87fm4mmzkicjs/2014-mcclintock.pd... / http://sci-hub.bz/3e46d909c73b1bf06a440eb0515c8c7b/mcclintock2014.pdf http://sci-hub.bz/3e46d909c73b1bf06a440eb0515c8c7b/mcclintoc... "Beauty and Status: The Illusion of Exchange in Partner Selection?", McClintock 2014
Table 3, pg 14: all the correlations are positive, but that also includes the female attractiveness / male SES bivariate correlations, exactly as common wisdom has it - beautiful women do tend to marry rich men.
(Arguments about matching vs exchange are causal arguments, and 'controlling' is implicitly making some very strong and implausible assumptions.)