3 ms·
Patent trolls don't care about incurring liabilities; they simply fold up shop and start over with a new shell company. The winner never sees a dime.
by chongli 12y ago
Patent trolls don't care about incurring liabilities; they simply fold up shop and start over with a new shell company. The winner never sees a dime.
- riffraff 12y agopresumably if the company goes bankrupt and it ows money to someone (i.e. the sued company) the assets of the troll (the patents) should go to the debtor, so hyow would this work? Or does US law permit you to close a company keeping all it has while not paying debts?
- chongli 12y agoThey don't hold all of their patents under one company, they split them up. If you prevail against them in the lawsuit, the only patents you'd collect from them are the ones you just overturned.
- nikanj 12y agoIANAL, but I would think it would be possible to license the patent out to the shell company for relicensing. Something similar to how Microsoft Ireland is able to sell, license and sue companies using MS products without actually holding the copyrights to those products.
- spacemanmatt 12y agoThis is why some of us believe standing in patent cases should not include non-practicing entities.
- chongli 12y agoSo then what happens to lone inventors or universities or anyone -- business or individual -- who develops an idea, patents it but cannot afford to bring it to market? Should they just forfeit their efforts to a large company without any compensation?
- spacemanmatt 12y agoI don't know how someone develops a patentable idea without practicing the related art. I don't think NPE means actual original inventor by any stretch -- but I could be wrong and would be curious if you can point me in the direction of examples where a court or even a reliable pundit has made that stretch.
- chongli 12y agoHere's a scenario for you. Imagine you are an aerospace engineer working for a company such as Boeing. After a nice career, you decide to retire. One day, while in the shower, you imagine a brand new design for an airplane wing and you decide to model it on your PC using the software you'd always used at work. To your shock, you discover that this new design promises a substantial reduction in fuel costs. You obtain a patent for your design. Now what? Are you going to start your own company to manufacture aircraft wings? No, you decide to remain a NPE and license your patent to companies such as Boeing and earn a nice living from it.
- spacemanmatt 12y agoJust to put a stake in the ground, I mean patent trolls specifically, when I call out bad NPE behavior. Not all NPE behavior is bad, and I only hope to limit the bad behavior. Wikipedia says: Non-practicing entities are generally not considered 'patent trolls' when they offer their patented technologies to licensees in advance, such as individual inventors, university research laboratories, development firms, and licensing agents that offer enforcement and negotiation services on behalf of patent owners. I think that's a pretty reasonable statement.
- chongli 12y agoJust to put a stake in the ground, I mean patent trolls specifically, when I call out bad NPE behavior. Not all NPE behavior is bad, and I only hope to limit the bad behavior. How do you do that, legally speaking? What is the fundamental technical difference between our hypothetical aerospace engineer suing Boeing and some troll suing Vizio? It's not enough to say that the patents of a troll might be invalid; invalidating patents is extremely expensive in court.