3 ms·
If we take silence as indicative of lack of knowledge, then nobody needs to speak. Bernard: Silence (he doesn't know the answer) Albert: Silence (he doesn'
by Nursie 12y ago
If we take silence as indicative of lack of knowledge, then nobody needs to speak.
Bernard: Silence (he doesn't know the answer)
Albert: Silence (he doesn't either)
Bernard: I know it!
Interestingly it then becomes relevant who was silent first.
Basically it's nonsense.
- sukilot 12y agoIf you assume Albert and Bernard are identical computers running identical programs, then it isn't nonsense. And that's not just a gimmick , timing analysis is how some side-channel attacks work in crypto.
- anigbrowl 12y agoThank you.
- Nursie 12y agoOf course it's nonsense. If we can deduce the answer from silence then there's no need for any of the information given in the question, it's not a logic puzzle it's bullshit. I don't assume Albert and Bernard are anything, if you've made assumptions beyond what's stated in the question then you've done it wrong. And yes, I understand timing oracles.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]