4 ms·
Ask HN: Chatbots ...
I've got a robot on Richard's Play By Email server that plays CoNeutron, and I've been thinking of adding a "ChatBot" on the side. I've played with Eliza and a few others, but I was wondering if anyone here on HN has some experience, recommendations, warnings or suggestions.
- jacquesm 17y agoI've written a couple and I had great fun with them. One of the best attempts was a really nasty little trick, basically a human-backed chatbot. The way it worked was like this: You get an icq (at the time) client and proxy it through the bot, the bot goes and makes random friends. When someone reponds to the bots 'opening' line (Hi how are you?) you get back a response. You now answer with two things at once, the first a regexp that matches the response and puts in wildcards for linguistic fluff, and the actual answer. The bot stores both in its database, and passes the answer to the user. Who then replies. Meanwhile the bot continues to find new 'victims', and everytime it gets back an answer it tries to make a match based on it's canned responses. It knows where in the conversation it is (context), so a response will only be matched in the right spot in a conversation. After being the bots 'backend' for a couple of days it could keep up a conversation for a good 20 minutes from the 'hi how are you' until it would run out of steam, by using wildcards in a smart way it is amazing how 'relevant' an answer can be even though the match is only on one or two words. It was some of the most fun I ever had with computers, not because it 'fooled' the users, simply because of seeing all these patterns in language.
- spicyj 17y agoSounds pretty amazing. It sounds better, at least, than any bot that I've seen. Is it open source? ;)
- jacquesm 17y agoThere is really nothing amazing about it, it just substitutes a human for any smarts. It's just as 'amazing' as the mechanical turk playing chess :) You could probably re-implement the basics using a webform and some ajax in a couple of hours. The hardest part was to figure out how to get on the ICQ network, someone was friendly enough to write micq and it was easy enough to splice the proxy bit in there. The real challenge in making a chatbot is writing one that comes up with original stuff, this one just basically regurgitated whatever it was told on an earlier occasion. edit: I've found the code, if you are really interested drop me an email and I'll send it to you, warning this is very ugly code, it was spliced together in a very short time from a bunch of stuff and it should really never see the light of day again. Frankenstein looks pretty in comparison :) It will also almost certainly not work (if you can find the micq it wants that might help, not sure if that is even working), fry your computer and so on... Here is a small sample of what you could do with it (an attempt at getting people to visit camarades.com: (I used a different domain to be able to track who actually visited the site), this the 'ruleset' after a couple of sessions. color off # info 12089101 rand 1 awaittarget 60 servertimeout msg $target/Hi There !, I'm Jacques\nDo you like webcams ? await 300 abort !sleep 10 match explainfree (free free? cost?) match explainrand how find match languageno no do speak match apologise (remove | fuck | go away) match apologise fuck match apologise go away macro affirmative (cool | yes | yeah | yeh | yep | yup | da | si | sure | I do | very | like much) match payload $affirmative match explain need match explaincam what match maybe (dont know | maybe | could be) match pity (no | nope) match pity nope match explain don't have q explainfree: msg $target/Sure it's free ! await 300 abort !sleep 10 match languageno no do speak match apologise remove match apologise fuck match apologise go away match payload $affirmative match explain need match explaincam what match maybe dont know match maybe maybe match maybe could be match pity no match pity nope q apologise: msg $target/Ok, sorry to disturb you, goodbye ! !sleep 10 q explainrand: msg $target/I found you through Linux/micq random people finder. So do you like cams ? await 300 abort !sleep 10 match apologise remove match apologise fuck match apologise go away match payload cool match payload yes match payload yea match payload yeah match payload yeh match payload yep match payload sure match payload I do match payload very match payload like much match explain need match maybe dont know match maybe maybe match maybe could be match pity no match pity nope q explaincam: msg $target/A webcam is a camera connected to the internet await 300 abort match apologise remove match apologise fuck match apologise go away match payload cool match payload yes match payload yea match payload yeah match payload yeh match payload yep match payload sure match payload I do match payload very match payload like much match explain need match maybe dont know match maybe maybe match maybe could be match pity no match pity nope q apologise: msg $target/Ok, sorry to disturb you, goodbye ! !sleep 10 q payload: url $target http://www.camerades.com/ Great !\nYou can see me *live*\non www.camerades.com\nEnjoy !\nThere are 100's of live cameras there and free software too ! !sleep 10 abort: q maybe: msg $target/Hm, if you want to try check out www.camerades.com\nEnjoy !\nThere are 100's of live cameras there !sleep 10 abort: q pity: url $target http://www.camerades.com/ That's a pity, You can see\nme *live* on www.camerades.com\nThere are 100's of live cameras there\nAnyway, sorry to disturb you...\nGoodbye await 180 abort match describe what see match explain what match explain need !sleep 10 abort: q languageno: msg $target/No, I don't.\nThat's a pity, You can see\nme *live* on www.camerades.com\nThere are 100's of live cameras there\nAnyway, sorry to disturb you...\nGoodbye await 300 abort match describe what see match explain what match explain need !sleep 10 abort: q explain: msg $target/You don't need any software, or camera just a browser is enough.\n !sleep 10 q describe: msg $target/Lot's of people and out door views from all over the world\n !sleep 10 q servertimeout: !echo no response ! q
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- mikexstudios 17y agoI saw a modern version of the "human-backed chatbot" on reddit last week, and it fooled quite a number of people. It's called Cleverbot (http://www.cleverbot.com http://www.cleverbot.com).
- benmathes 17y agoI asked "Are you a computer?", it said "I am a computer". Not particularly clever.
- sli 17y agoMegaHAL is open source and a lot of fun to play with. Be ready to feed it a lot of text, though.
- flashingpumpkin 17y agoI second that. It's a lot of fun to tinker with. I've once fed it 20k+ posts from an online game I was playing, basically the whole usergenerated story and put it online in the game's IRC channel. And as it is, the users indulged in nostalgia every now and then, which triggered the bot to happily tell about old times. :)
- intellectronica 17y agoA.L.I.C.E [ http://alicebot.blogspot.com/ http://alicebot.blogspot.com/ ] is a 'brute-force' chatbot model that has been developed for many years. It has several free software implementations and is very easy to work with.
- RiderOfGiraffes 17y agoA.L.I.C.E. now has a "Fake Kirk" personality, so I thought I'd try it. Here's the "conversation" we had: Lieutenant: What's our mission, captain? Fake Kirk: Our five year mission: to seek out new worlds and new civilizations. To go boldly where no man has gone before. Lieutenant: Did you not originally split the infinitive? Fake Kirk: No. We beamed it out into open space, Lieutenant. Widest possible dispersion. Lieutenant: But didn't that kill it completely? Fake Kirk: How? Lieutenant: By ensuring it could never come back. Fake Kirk: Explain. Lieutenant: On widest possible dispersion you could never re-integrate the original confinement beam. Fake Kirk: To read minds? Lieutenant: Oh dear. Fake Kirk: Lieutenant. Lieutenant: Yes captain? Fake Kirk: Lieutenant, get the doctor up here on the double. How bad is it? Lieutenant: It's not at all bad - just a flesh wound. Fake Kirk: Oh, yes, it is. It's exactly the same. Only this one works. I'm afraid this just screams "Eliza!" at me ...
- viraptor 17y agoI had a bit of fun with chatbots. If you want OS and easy way, you have 3 choices really: - AIML engine - MegaHAL engine - proper parsers (most of them are written in lisp-like languages for some reason) Now it really depends on what you want to do - only waste someone else's time? MegaHAL will do just fine. You can feed it conversations all the time and it will learn to interact in some environment rather quickly. If you want some basic scripting, you should look at AIML-based soft. You can write your scripts and basic expression reduction in XML. There's a "javascript" tag in the specification, but noone really supports it. I map it to python functions in my bot and it works quite well. You will never parse more exotic sentences though - just basics. And your bot will not learn automatically. If you want to use it for something really useful, look at the http://www.generation5.org/ http://www.generation5.org/ articles. You'll find a lot of code that's easy to port to your favourite language there. Serious language parsers connected to something like word-net are the only way to go if you want good quality. And you need to create a lot of stuff yourself - afaik there are no standard response libraries like alice, because the parse format is not really standardised.
- paraschopra 17y agoI had made one very silly bot called SPEAK. It used simple matching algorithms to learn. I wondered who would use it, but people actually used it for real. http://paraschopra.com/software/ http://paraschopra.com/software/