3 ms·
Flavors of programming ...
- infinibuy 17y agoYou have a candle, a slice of cheese, and a pair of old boots. You need a fork-handle. This one really made me laugh.
- diN0bot 17y agoat first i thought this would be good. data munging is definitely a time of programming that occurs. but then the list just gets ridiculous, almost poking fun at the different jobs one might do. more importantly, real tasks are left off. i flagged this submission for being boring.
- RiderOfGiraffes 17y agoI appreciate your point of view, but would find it more interesting and useful if you could give an example of the sort of programming you feel has been left off, rather than just dissing the item without being constructive. I look forward to your contribution.
- jacquesm 17y agoThe list is meant with a wink, the references to the maze are really a funny way to get the point across. Grow a sense of humour and flag stuff that really needs flagging, such as this: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=943367 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=943367 In case you missed, it, let me spell it out for you: Programming is idiomatic at a higher level than you'd think by casual inspection of the code, when you zoom out to the level of individual programs, maybe even projects there is a very limited set of classes that you can group most if not all programs in to. I'm missing one for web programming, so let me supply that one here: WebApps: data gets moved from some datastore, through some processing machinery to produce html, then gets sent to the user, the interactions get captured in forms or ajax and pass a bunch of processing machinery on the way to some datastore. Repeat until machine failure.
- RiderOfGiraffes 17y agoHave you put that in the comments on the site? It fits ...
- mindstab 17y agoha this amused me because I've been at most of these stages. The last one, API spelunking is what every trip to Java land feels like.
- jacquesm 17y agoIt's actually quite painful to realize when you look at your last 10 projects or so and you find that indeed almost all you've done can be reduced to these few categories. My pet peeve about java is that I have to use an IDE to work with it because of all the APIs there are so many of them that I can't seem to remember all the function names and parameter sequences. An IDE is like a crutch, you use if for a bit and then you find out you're now so atrophied you are dependent on it.
- mindstab 17y agoalso it doesn't help that java is staggeringly inconsistent. Even something as simple as getting the size/length of something in the core Java API is inconsistent: array.length string.length() arrayList.size() awesome. How could I not remember that. And how about number type conversions? Interger.parseInt Interget.toString BigInteger.valueOf oh yeah, common sense. verses something like ruby 7.toString "7".toInt A sane and consistent API goes along way to not requiring you to memorizing a epic amounts of useless API and essentially going API spelunking. Also with java it does seem that alot more of the coding is just calling more API to do things, plugging things together, rather than actual coding and problem solving.
- brianto2010 17y ago> ...verses something like ruby 7.toString "7".toInt do you mean... 7.to_s # Convert to string '7'.to_i # Convert to number
- mindstab 17y agoha yes, even better, my bad
- ramchip 17y agoFlagging isn't downmodding. Please don't flag for being boring. Actually, I don't think you should downvote for being boring, either!
- gruseom 17y agoI find it interesting that you (implicitly) like Data Munging better than Clever Algorithms. I agree that the former is orders of magnitude more common. I haven't encountered a Clever Algorithms problem very often at all on commercial projects. My current project is an outlier insofar as we've been doing algorithmic work for months. It's fun, in the way any good hacker would expect such a challenge to be, but it's also stressful to work on something for a long time and not know for sure whether you'll end up with a solution. (Especially when the context is a startup and not a research project.) It's much easier when you know for sure you can get there, you just have to figure out how. Thankfully, the Algorithms category gets more and more fun as you knock off significant chunks of the problem. Once you see the light at the end of the tunnel, you're home free. Unless, of course, you got it wrong. :) Edit: by the way, do you actually use APL/J/K in the way you mentioned? I really like that paradigm. I think it deserves a place alongside OO and the others as a fundamentally different approach to programming. However, I haven't used it nearly enough. Edit 2: I would distinguish two different kinds of Data Munging. One is Data Transformation, where you have data in some original context and it needs to go through a series of transformations or passes until you've extracted or computed what's suitable for your problem. That is way fun. The other type, though, sucks rocks. I call it Meat Grinding. That's when you have the exact data you need in a form that you can't use because of some purely technical limitation. A common example is you have data in a database or a DTO when what your code need is a domain object, so you have to copy the properties over like this: myStupidObject.CustomerName = stupidDataObject.CustomerName This isn't so much a programming problem as an integration one. (You sort of touch on it at the end.) It's also one of the worst things about programming in less powerful languages where you can't easily write a program to do the gruntwork for you. Edit 3: I'd also argue that your "API spelunking" nightmare is at its nastiest in OO systems. In poorly designed pre-OO APIs (like Win32), it might take a long time to figure out how to call a function or what to do next; there might have been some ugly one-off struct you had to populate, etc.; but at least you didn't have to figure out how the hell to make a Bar out of a Foo so you can pass it as the third argument to Baz, when neither Foo nor Bar has anything to do with your problem. But with poorly designed OO APIs, these absurd hurdles seem endless. I used to compensate for this by studying such code archaeologically (if I couldn't avoid it altogether), in order to learn how the absurdities had arisen over time. This was a way to escape Dostoevsky's definition of the easiest way to drive a man insane: make him move a pile of dirt from one end of a prison yard to another and then move it back.
- david 17y agoI don't think one of my favorite (OOPish) flavors was included. I think of it as something like designing an organism out of various independent parts, figuring out how they will work together and respond to input. For me a lot of more complicated UI design is like this, I have objects representing each part of the interface and spend a lot of time sending messages between objects and figuring out how to handle user events. I guess the focus isn't so much on algorithms or if-statements so much as high-level architecture.