4 ms·
To paraphrase Ian Fleming: No, Mr. Noakes [, I don't expect you to admit to even changing your mind], I expect you to continue to offer evasions, misrepresentat
by mannykannot 12y ago
To paraphrase Ian Fleming: No, Mr. Noakes [, I don't expect you to admit to even changing your mind], I expect you to continue to offer evasions, misrepresentations, irrelevancies and self-contradictions in an attempt to rewrite the record.
Your response is exactly what we could predict: after a couple of posts in which you try to ignore the first paragraph of eslaught's post, you attempt to rewrite the issue by bringing in his following two paragraphs, which are about a different topic (ironically, their topic is the unsuitability of C++ for this discussion!) The first paragraph stands on its own and is not dependent on, or even supported by, on the following two paragraphs.
So you really would like us to believe that your judgement is such that you find this straight-to-the-point ("you still have no way to modify the variable binding on the caller's stack") argument slightly more complicated than yours, which includes a couple of other long, snide-remarks-laden threads (something you obviously have a predilection for), and a couple in which you finally abandoned your approach, telling people to read the JLS instead?
Tobani, for one, found eslaught's post helpful: "I get what you are saying."
Furthermore, the most you are claiming now is only that eslaughts's post (even in its entirety, including the parts not relevant to this discussion) is just a little more complicated than yours. This is very different from your initial claim (despite your attempt to mis-characterize it as "conversational prose" when it contains an explicit argument attempting to establish a fact - see my recent post above.) Even if we consider the use of 'exponential' as misleading hyperbole, it is still a claim that any such alternative would be inordinately more complex. Therefore, the fact that you are now arguing for only a little more complexity is a tacit admission that you now realize your initial claim was mistaken.
Until you are ready to demonstrate some level of courage in your convictions, there is no point in me posting an alternative explanation here, only to have you willfully misrepresent it in the same way as you did for eslaught's post. If, however, some genuine third party joins in the discussion and requests it, I will be happy to present an alternative.
- jjnoakes 12y ago> after a couple of posts in which you try to ignore the first paragraph of eslaught's post I wasn't ignoring it - it was irrelevant. > This is very different from your initial claim No it isn't - I never claimed anything about eslaught's post, directly or indirectly, before that. > 'exponential' [...] it is still a claim that any such alternative would be inordinately more complex You repeat this as often as you can, like it's somehow your only real point here. And every time, I point out that I made no such claim. The only claim I made was that your specific explanation (which you never actually wrote), which you said would include stack frames, machine addresses, and the like, would be much more complex than referring to C++, in my opinion. You haven't refuted that, even though I am amused that you keep trying. You also haven't changed my opinion, and as you can guess, I'm equally amused that you keep trying there too. Continue, please.
- mannykannot 12y agoNo problem - these replies practically write themselves. I usually have a good idea what I am going to write even before I read your next evasion, and you keep giving me new material to work with. A case in point: your attempt to claim that eslaught's explanation is irrelevant. Of course, it is not - characteristically, you have offered no counter to my explanation of how it gets directly to the point - and of course you were not thinking it was irrelevant when you tried to argue that it is marginally more complicated than your approach. Only after I pointed out that by doing so, you had tacitly admitted to a complete reversal of your position, did it occur to you that it was a mistake, and decided that you would have been better off claiming that the explanation is irrelevant, even though that claim won't stand up. So instead of expunging one of your inconsistencies, you have added another case where you contradict yourself in attempting to rewrite the record. You also claim that this isn't what you were thinking of. Well, if you didn't think through the full scope and implications of what you were writing, that would be yet another mistake on your part, wouldn't it? We are, however, now entitled to wonder why, precisely, you think you can retrospectively rule this explanation out. As I wrote before, until you can demonstrate the integrity of committing to something definite that you will not attempt to rewrite later, there's no reason for me to post an explanation here.
- jjnoakes 12y agoYou seem to start your posts with a lot of rhetoric, and then you repeatedly fall flat on your face with substance. > you had tacitly admitted to a complete reversal of your position > until you can demonstrate the integrity of committing to something definite My position has never changed, nor has my opinion. I still believe C++ was a useful analogy to the problem at hand (people misunderstanding Java references and pass-by-reference), and I still believe that any explanation involving machine addresses and stack frames that you could write (which you continue to refuse to do) would be more complex than comparing to C++. If you care to take your umpteenth failed swing at that, go right ahead. I already know what's going to happen though. "Failed attempt at rhetoric, misrepresenting of opponent's position, arguing against the failed position". I should advise you, though, that if you are going to keep wasting your own time flailing around in this thread, you should try to have a modicum of self-respect by sticking to what I say in your replies. Arguing against positions that don't exist may make you feel like you are getting somewhere, but really all you are doing is entertaining me. But if that's your goal, and I'm misunderstanding you, then ignore the previous paragraph, and keep it coming :)