3 ms·
> To me it seems absolutely imperative that criminals - up to and including those guilty of capital crimes - be given a new lease on life, contingent upon the t
by anamax 17y ago
> To me it seems absolutely imperative that criminals - up to and including those guilty of capital crimes - be given a new lease on life, contingent upon the terms of their sentencing.
Oh really? So if you have kids, you're perfectly happy not knowing that you're living next to a pedophile?
> My point is that the spirit of the law - that convicted criminals who have served their time have the right to be judged on their own terms subsequently without that cloud hanging over their head - deserves at least some intellectual consideration in this case.
Yes it does. But it isn't the only point that deserves consideration. Past behavior is relevant, and the relevance is circumstance dependent. (If you don't have kids, living next to a pedophile may be no big deal.)
The best solution is likely to be accurate and useful information. (Note that all of the above poster's complaints are actually due to inaccurate or incomplete information.)
> just because someone committed a crime does not mean they are not a human being and do not deserve your thoughts and your empathy.
No one ever said tht they weren't a human being, but you don't have the right to decide who gets my thoughts and empathy. (Note that this has nothing to do with prison records.) Or rather, if you insist on trying to impose your decisions on me, you'll find that I can play that game too and I don't care whether you like the result.
I'm only willing to let you make the decisions that you prefer if I get the same consideration.
- foldr 17y ago>Oh really? So if you have kids, you're perfectly happy not knowing that you're living next to a pedophile? What would I do if my kids /were/ living next to a pedophile? Move? Lock them indoors 24/7? Burn the guy's house down? Ask him to move in next to someone else's kids instead of mine? Knowing that my kids are living next to a pedophile would most likely just cause me needless stress.
- abalashov 17y agoOh really? So if you have kids, you're perfectly happy not knowing that you're living next to a pedophile? Maybe I am and maybe I'm not. I'm strongly inclined to agree with foldr that it would be mostly pointless to know that and cause me unnecessary angst. What I am sure of - and this was closer to the general thrust of my post - is that I don't need to know if my neighbour once had sex with his girlfriend in high school when, I don't know, say he was 18 and she was 16 (in states where age of consent is 18). In fact, there is absolutely no reason I should be mentally prejudiced against him as a "dangerous sex offender" and tell my kids to avoid like the plague on that basis. Yet that is exactly the kind of thing we do to people in this country.
- anamax 17y ago> Maybe I am and maybe I'm not. Good for you. However, it's unclear why your choice, either way, should bind someone who'd rather choose the other. > What I am sure of - and this was closer to the general thrust of my post - is that I don't need to know if my neighbour once had sex with his girlfriend in high school Not so fast. You're using inaccurate/irrelevant knowledge to argue against having accurate knowledge. (That's why I used the word "pedophile" and not "sex offender".) In this world, there's going to be knowledge. We can only affect how accurate it is. The public sex offender lists were in part a reaction to semi-public lists. Which would you rather have?