3 ms·
Breaking news: An employee of a giant multi national bank, is suggesting we stop using a form of payment that works without any involvement from a bank. More
by stephenr 12y ago
Breaking news: An employee of a giant multi national bank, is suggesting we stop using a form of payment that works without any involvement from a bank.
More at 11.
- anentropic 12y agoexactly... one important property of cash is it is printed debt-free by the state, which can profit from the seigniorage this is the story of latter half of 20th Century, rise of credit cards and electronic transfers displacing cash in UK, 1946, fully 46% of the money supply was printed debt-free by the state (with the profit added to govt bottom line), now it is a pitiful 2-3% with a corresponding explosion in debt money http://www.positivemoney.org/2011/10/debt-free-money/ http://www.positivemoney.org/2011/10/debt-free-money/
- nhaehnle 12y ago> one important property of cash is it is printed debt-free by the state, which can profit from the seigniorage This is actually not true in current typical monetary systems. There may be exceptions, but the typical setup is that the central bank prints physical money solely as a reaction to demand by banks (who need it to stock their ATMs). From an asset point of view it is an entirely neutral operation that is irrelevant to the state's fiscal position. In some countries (including the US), coins are minted by the treasury and then sold to the central bank for distribution. In those countries, the state does profit from seignorage - but only of coins, so it tends to be irrelevant in practice (modulo the occasional amusing trillion dollar platinum coin debate).
- pif 12y agoWell, another fundamental property of cash is that it is anonymous, and this can be seen as wrong on many levels.
- zhte415 12y agoIf money is either 'debt money' or 'non debt money' then a relative decrease in one would imply a relative increase in the other. The linked article is full of apples and oranges. 'debt free cash' from the article's seeming definition is M0. While 'non debt free cash' appears to imply M2 (or M4). They're not opposites, but products of each other. Cash simply passes around the economy much faster, instead of sitting under the mattress or in the draw of the accountant for the best part of a week before wages are paid, it sits in an ATM, efficiently on-demand for who needs it when they need it. The velocity of money (how fast it moves from one person's hand to another) has simply increased, substantially, due to technological improvements. Money * Velocity of Money = Read Economic Production * Inflation Rate The above is always true (which is why money supply is a good predictor of nominal growth (and on the assumption economic growth changes slowly, inflation, which can vary more, but that takes a qualitative judgment), as it is more accurately and in a more timely manner. 'Debt money', or M2, is more better compared to M2L, the corresponding side of the monetary balance sheet (balance sheets also being an identity: Assets = Liabilities + Capital). And M2 is a much more realistic of the concept of 'money' as it includes deposits and other short term bank liabilities. So compare that to M2L, not M0 to M2, apples to oranges, as M2 is a product of M0 and M0 velocity. Edit: The referenced article mentioned sterling. For similar definitions of money for the Euro or Dollar substitute M2 for M1, and M4 for M3.
- watmough 12y agoThe article doesn't spell it out, although it should be obvious, "negative interest rates" means "charging you to hold your own money".
- nine_k 12y agoCharging to hold your own money makes all the sense if an institution actually holds your money. E.g. you pay a certain amount to store a brick of gold in a safe. The problem is that current banks are not banks in the 18th century sense, that is, not institutions that just hold your money safe, ready to return it on your demand. Instead, they invest this money, giving it to other people in the form of loans. This is the problem with "fractional reserve banking" and "bank runs": the banks don't have your money, they've given it to other people for some interest. For some time, this scheme worked relatively nicely, and you could get some interest accruing on your savings account. But obviously the system is not very stable: if a major investment crisis happens, your savings may be lost (what savings? they were investments!). Not all people are quite comfortable with this, but we have little choice.