4 ms·
> When people are talking about "safe areas" to protect students from words spoken by a speaker, then criticism is dead. I understand what you're getting at, b
by derefr 12y ago
> When people are talking about "safe areas" to protect students from words spoken by a speaker, then criticism is dead.
I understand what you're getting at, but some people really do have PTSD, and some speeches really do contain things like graphic recountings of abuse. Should those people just not attend university? (I'm actually undecided.)
- click170 12y agoWhen specifically did you gain the right to not be offended? As far as I'm aware, nobody has any such right. If you don't like what someone is saying, walk away.
- kaonashi 12y ago> When specifically did you gain the right to not be offended That's an unbelievably dismissive view. What makes you think these areas are merely about exclusion from offense?
- alextgordon 12y agoUniversities exist for the benefit of society at large, not for the benefit of individuals. If people are afraid or forbidden to speak their minds, then the university won't be able to function as a place to advance our understanding of the world.
- kaonashi 12y agoThat would make sense to say if we were talking about the entire university; but we're not.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- derefr 12y agoNot being offended, and not entering a dissociative fugue state and shaking and screaming and muttering for 30 minutes and quite disrupting the speech in the process, are very different things. PTSD is not Tumblr-fairy disease; it's the thing you get from being interned in a POW camp or locked in someone's sex dungeon for months/years. People do have a right to avoid reliving that sort of experience. Which, like I said, might mean that they'd have to avoid going to university altogether. It's probably nearly impossible to have an environment that both allows for a free-flowing exchange of ideas, and yet protects people with this sort of permanent mental disability. But making an allowance for rape survivors to leave the room when there's going to be a live screening of Salò isn't all that hard, is it?
- reality_czech 12y agoYes, they are very different things, which is why you are arguing against a strawman. You know perfectly well that letting someone voice his conservative political opinions is not going to trigger PTSD. Pretending to be offended in order to stop the debate is the left's version of invoking terrorism in ridiculous contexts. The biggest irony, which you probably can't even see, is that your own comment is an example of the disturbing and vile speech you claim to hate ("sex dungeon", "POW camp", "Salo"). You didn't need to bring those up to make your point, but you did. Somehow disturbing and vile things like burning the flag and condoning drug abuse never seem to upset the left (and I could go on...), but talking about individual rights and respnsibilities does. Funny how that works.
- derefr 12y agoI... didn't claim to hate anything? I was making an argument that some people will get sick from some speech. It's a medical issue, and there are several solutions. I'm not sure you read my comment charitably. Now, I'm not from the US, haven't been to a university for quite some years, and so am not personally experienced with what these "safe zones" are about in practice, the politics surrounding them, etc.—but I was trying to say that, if they had any justification at all as a theoretical construct, it was in giving people with PTSD a way to get away from "broadcast all over campus" things like graduation speeches, if and when a planned speech is found to have content that might trigger specific kinds of traumatic stress attacks. Not because it might offend someone. Not with voluntary ability to leave for any reason one might like. Just a medical excuse from attendance, like a person with acrophobia would get from a field trip to the roof of a skyscraper. And again, even then, it might be better for those people to just leave the university campus, or avoid coming in the first place.
- xienze 12y ago> I understand what you're getting at, but some people really do have PTSD, and some speeches really do contain things like graphic recountings of abuse. Should those people just not attend university? Perhaps don't attend that speech then? Life at a university doesn't involve dodging "pro rape" speeches blasted over the PA system multiple times a day. The recent article about the "safe spaces" full of coloring books and toys notes that people were fleeing to those rooms simply because _someone was on campus giving a speech that challenged their beliefs / "triggered" them_. If universities are catering to folks that simply can't handle the thought of someone with a conflicting viewpoint talking on campus then the ideals of the university truly are dead.
- derefr 12y agoMy argument is that whether the idea of a "safe space" is warranted, and who should be allowed to make use of such a space, are different questions. A "safe space" might have valid medical reasons to exist—in fact, it would likely be a concept quite easily unified with that of a counselling office. But, for it to have the correct incentive structure, it would probably require you to get a note from a real honest-to-god psychiatrist at the beginning of the year before you could make use of it. Otherwise you end up in the stupid rut of the "ignorant-but-unaware-of-it" people avoiding the very properties of an education designed to bash their narrow views open.
- chippy 12y agoOne line I read recently from an article stuck with me. By allowing a "safe space" it implies that everywhere else is an "unsafe space".
- mattlutze 12y ago> I understand what you're getting at, but some people really do have PTSD, and some speeches really do contain things like graphic recountings of abuse. Should those people just not attend university? (I'm actually undecided.) Contrary to the collective opinion of certain Internet communities, I think it quite likely that reports of PTSD in the average person have been greatly exaggerated. It's great to provide support in the rare case that a person really does have an unmanageable reaction to certain memories. But mitigating this edge case by making that support a default condition in every interaction on a campus stymies the free thinking and free expression that are supposed to flourish in a liberal learned environment.
- A_COMPUTER 12y agoI guess I am in the minority because I think that the concepts are good and useful in a limited scope but that they're obviously being abused by a cynical group of people to shut up other people they disagree with. Like, you have people arguing with a straight face that Christina-Hoff Sommers even being on their campus makes them feel unsafe. The entire thing has turned into a bizarre group-performativity ritual that has nothing to do with protecting PTSD-sufferers. Trigger warnings are supposed to protect the most vulnerable people from being blindsided, safe spaces are supposed to be places where emphasis is on support. They are not general, universally-applicable concepts.
- learc83 12y agoIt's because people have realized that if they say they feel unsafe, then the university takes them more seriously than if they said they were merely offended.
- Lawtonfogle 12y agoI took a class on child abuse while at college. To say it had graphic recountings of abuse would be an understatement. It was one of the most extreme experiences I had during my time there. On the first day, the professor told the class that we would be getting into some pretty extreme material, and if at any point someone needed to leave class or even skip it, to just let him know and schedule some one on one time with the professor. That seems to have worked as a good solution. Far better than banning that class or censoring material.