2 ms·
Perhaps they just don't agree with it? I'm not complaining about the concept of downvoting. My only concern is with the implementation, and the implication th
by yellowapple 12y ago
Perhaps they just don't agree with it?
I'm not complaining about the concept of downvoting. My only concern is with the implementation, and the implication that dissent is a bad thing worthy of suppression. A better approach would be to provide a visual indicator of controversy that doesn't make the comment in question more difficult to read (perhaps some smiley/frowney face below the voting buttons or some other graphical indicator?).
- DanBC 12y agoDo you have any examples of dissenting views that have been supressed?
- yellowapple 12y agoYou can find plenty of examples in a lot of the more heated/busy HN discussions. I'm too lazy to dig up more examples, but they're pretty common (especially once politics comes into play; I've noticed a bit of a left-wing bent on HN over the last couple of years (which isn't much of a surprise considering how much of an influence Bay-Area/"Valley" culture has on HN)). By using the downvote button as a disagreement button, and by observing that using said downvote button causes the comment's text to fade further and further from black to grey to white, it can be observed that any case of disagreement expressed via the downvote button results in supression of the comment's content (by making it harder to read).
- DanBC 12y agoI asked for an example because the majority of comments I see that are heavily downvoted are probably downvoted for something other than disagreement. So, do you have any examples of comments that were downvoted for disagreement? Especially if they were heavily downvoted?