7 ms·
Forget Rand Paul, Let's Talk Paul Rand
- mitchi 12y agoVery interesting. Great designs. Now I know who is Paul Rand and hopefully, a little more aboutt the importance of logo design.
- gweinberg 12y agoDo Presidential candidates usually have logos? Before today I didn't know Rand Paul had one. In fact, the only one I had seen other than Hillary's was Obama's.
- zachrose 12y agoGeorge W. Bush had the blocky "BUSH" with an American flag coming out of the "W." above it. That's as much of a logo as Rand Paul's.
- IvyMike 12y agoNowadays, most of them do. Romney had the funky R that you probably forgot about: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mitt_Romney_presidential_campaign,_2012 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mitt_Romney_presidential_campa...
- jsprogrammer 12y agoDon't you have a logo?
- keevie 12y agoIf you're spending hundreds of millions of dollars on what is essentially a marketing campaign, it would be rather shocking not to have a logo.
- bluthru 12y agoDoing some image searching, it looks like Clinton in 1992 was the first to have consistent branding.
- researcher88 12y agoRand had a cool limited bumper sticker silhouette with just his first name, like this. Seemed like good branding-http://static4.businessinsider.com/image/5522b0ec6da811ae3f3e025e-1069-381/mad%20man%20vs%20rpaul%202.jpg http://static4.businessinsider.com/image/5522b0ec6da811ae3f3...
- wyclif 12y agoWhere is his first name? I don't see it in this image.
- bmelton 12y agoHe linked an unrelated image. The one he was talking about is this one: https://store.randpaul.com/get.php/media/catalog/product/cache/1/image/9df78eab33525d08d6e5fb8d27136e95/r/a/rand_1024_4x6_ovalbumpersticker_limited_blue2.jpg https://store.randpaul.com/get.php/media/catalog/product/cac...
- wyclif 12y agoThanks, I'd actually never seen that one.
- bmelton 12y agoEven as a general supporter of Rand, that silhouette logo, to me, looks a little more "Satan" than "Mad Men".
- afarrell 12y agoI am genuinely surprised to learn that Rand Paul is not named after Ayn Rand.
- iwwr 12y agoHis name was Randy, which he shortened to Rand when he got married, at the behest of his wife. There could be some tenuous connection to Ayn Rand, but he has not acknowledged it. He definitely knows about Ayn Rand and her philosophy, as does his dad (Ron Paul).
- tptacek 12y agoGoogle's job is to show the search results that most closely match what users are actually looking for. In 2015, far more Google users are looking for Rand Paul than Paul Rand. Would that it weren't so, but it is. Paul Rand's logos might touch millions of people every day, but Rand himself is not relevant to the majority of Google users.
- brc 12y agoThat's what I came to say. The job of Google is to interpret and return relevant results. If you're looking for the designer, then you'll need to tack on 'designer' to the search. I was watching one of those 'investor pitch TV shows' on TV, and a young girl was pitching her site, which was named using a misspelled word (presumably to secure a domain name otherwise unavailable). If I was on that panel, I would have told her to go back to the start and find a new name and branding. She even admitted on the show that she wasn't turning up in results because of auto-correct spelling. These days, you can't pick company names or brands that closely match something else. You are better off starting with a completely new word than trying to misspell something slightly.
- natural219 12y agoI enjoyed this piece as sort of a tongue-in-cheek way to justify this article's existence -- if more people read or link to this article, it might end up showing higher in Google's results :)
- morbius 12y agoThe problem is that even when you put "Paul Rand" in quotes, the search results still show "Rand Paul" half the time.
- bane 12y agoThis is ever the problem of general purpose data handling systems. They optimize for popularity not for some kind of domain desirability.
- greghendershott 12y agoI'd say that Google's job is to show the search results that _each_ user is actually looking for. (Not an aggregate user with 2.5 children.) Come to think of it, doesn't Google aspire to personalized search? But in any case, at least I'd like old-fashioned quoted search -- i.e. I want "this phrase" exactly -- to give useful results.
- darkstar999 12y ago> The logo is hard to read at a distance What?? No, it's literally 4 letters with a flame above it, it can't get much simpler.
- ddoolin 12y agoI didn't really agree with that point either. I don't care much for the aesthetic but it's pretty recognizable at that size.
- clay_to_n 12y ago"You may have to squint to get the message that it's trying to get across" I think he's referring specifically to the torch imagery. From far away it mostly just looks like a word with a dot above it. The torch deal is small in comparison to the letters.
- shortformblog 12y agoAuthor here—yep, this was my intention. Sure, you can make out the letters, but the liberty imagery is lost if you're looking from half a mile. Look at the Obama logo (for example), and it holds up better. The Hillary logo, for all its faults, will similarly hold up better at long distances because the imagery is simple.
- EGreg 12y agoI think he meant recognize at a distance
- tedunangst 12y ago> This is a situation where someone who has had more influence on millions more lives than Rand Paul ever might There's a statement I'd love to see quantified.
- guelo 12y agoWhat is a logo for a political campaign good for? It is used to try to create some kind of positive impression on voters based on the visual design. Visual marketing in general is about trying to hack the human brain's bugs in order to influence it. Their is little actual information that is communicated, it is all about manipulating the lizard brain. This kind of hacking is awful for democracy. Voters should be encouraged to use their rational brains as much as possible when making these decisions. I consider it immoral and think it should be frowned upon.
- kriro 12y agoI think the most interesting point is that the logo was crowd sourced (and used SVG) which I didn't know before. The logo seems fine to me but the process is pretty exciting. The author of the blog post seems to think the crowd sourcing is not the greatest idea and it should be "left to the pros". I disagree with that general sentiment, why shouldn't wisdom of the crowds also apply to design tasks? At the very least it's dismessed a bit too quickly.
- shortformblog 12y agoHi, author here. I'm not personally opposed to the idea of crowdsourcing, nor the idea of changing a logo as needed—I respect Rand Paul for doing this, actually. But I was writing that section of the piece with the assumption that _Paul Rand_ might not like it, considering that some of his commentary near the end of his life (in the early age of computers) questioned the negative effects that democratized design, specifically through desktop publishing, had on visual identity. Design has gotten better online in recent years, and many more people are handy at Photoshop/InDesign than they were two decades ago, but this philosophy was one common in the early desktop publishing age, when people commonly screwed up things like kerning, typographers' quotes, and so on.