6 ms·
"It would also seek to restore the honorable lineage of the university as one of the few arenas in modern society (another is the arts) in which prevailing ideo
by protomyth 12y ago
"It would also seek to restore the honorable lineage of the university as one of the few arenas in modern society (another is the arts) in which prevailing ideologies can be submitted to some rigorous scrutiny."
Then the battle is lost, because universities, at least in the USA, are the home of "free speech areas" and not letting people speak who a group disagrees with. When people are talking about "safe areas" to protect students from words spoken by a speaker, then criticism is dead. Political parties have more diversity of allowed thought. STEM is often criticized as unwelcoming, but humanities has become a place of "agree with me" or be condemned.
If you didn't forge your ideas in the fire of criticism at university, then you were cheated by others or yourself. The best teachers will make you argue both / multiple sides of a scenario and be offended that you parroted their opinion back to them. The worst teachers only see one valid way to think and are doing "missionary work" instead of teaching.
It is often depressing to read https://www.thefire.org https://www.thefire.org
- blhack 12y agoHere is an excellent speech on this by one of the best people to speak on this topic (Steven Pinker): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HcdFI6Sda0k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HcdFI6Sda0k FIRE is an EXCELLENT group.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- wozniacki 12y agoThen the battle is lost, because universities, at least in the USA, are the home of "free speech areas" and not letting people speak who a group disagrees with. STEM is often criticized as unwelcoming, but humanities has become a place of "agree with me" or be condemned. It is a mistake to assume that this is a localized phenomenon limited to the United States. Lately - and as somewhat of a testament to how disturbingly uniform and inauthentic, millenial culture has become everywhere - the same kind of intolerance for discordant views can be seen on campuses from Canada to the UK. I'll leave you with an excellent write up on the topic of this brand of groupthink and shutting down opposing views, on campuses, by Brendan O'Neill in The Spectator : Have you met the Stepford students? They’re everywhere. On campuses across the land. Sitting stony-eyed in lecture halls or surreptitiously policing beer-fuelled banter in the uni bar. They look like students, dress like students, smell like students. But their student brains have been replaced by brains bereft of critical faculties and programmed to conform. To the untrained eye, they seem like your average book-devouring, ideas-discussing, H&M-adorned youth, but anyone who’s spent more than five minutes in their company will know that these students are far more interested in shutting debate down than opening it up. [1] [1] Free speech is so last century. Today’s students want the ‘right to be comfortable’ http://www.spectator.co.uk/features/9376232/free-speech-is-so-last-century-todays-students-want-the-right-to-be-comfortable/ http://www.spectator.co.uk/features/9376232/free-speech-is-s...
- eli_gottlieb 12y agoWait. Book-devouring, ideas-discussing students? Where the hell are these creatures, and where were they when I attended undergrad!? All I've ever seen was job-seeking, exam-studying things. Also, doesn't the constant talk of debate and free exchange of ideas rather presuppose a form of antirealism about everything under the sun? After all, we don't talk about a free exchange of ideas on the laws of motion. You can be accurate or incorrect about those.
- protomyth 12y agoThanks for the links. I did not want to state beyond the U.S. because I have not done the research myself on this subject.
- derefr 12y ago> When people are talking about "safe areas" to protect students from words spoken by a speaker, then criticism is dead. I understand what you're getting at, but some people really do have PTSD, and some speeches really do contain things like graphic recountings of abuse. Should those people just not attend university? (I'm actually undecided.)
- click170 12y agoWhen specifically did you gain the right to not be offended? As far as I'm aware, nobody has any such right. If you don't like what someone is saying, walk away.
- kaonashi 12y ago> When specifically did you gain the right to not be offended That's an unbelievably dismissive view. What makes you think these areas are merely about exclusion from offense?
- alextgordon 12y agoUniversities exist for the benefit of society at large, not for the benefit of individuals. If people are afraid or forbidden to speak their minds, then the university won't be able to function as a place to advance our understanding of the world.
- kaonashi 12y agoThat would make sense to say if we were talking about the entire university; but we're not.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- derefr 12y agoNot being offended, and not entering a dissociative fugue state and shaking and screaming and muttering for 30 minutes and quite disrupting the speech in the process, are very different things. PTSD is not Tumblr-fairy disease; it's the thing you get from being interned in a POW camp or locked in someone's sex dungeon for months/years. People do have a right to avoid reliving that sort of experience. Which, like I said, might mean that they'd have to avoid going to university altogether. It's probably nearly impossible to have an environment that both allows for a free-flowing exchange of ideas, and yet protects people with this sort of permanent mental disability. But making an allowance for rape survivors to leave the room when there's going to be a live screening of Salò isn't all that hard, is it?
- xmjee 12y agoUniversity should be the one place where Crocker's rules apply to all participants BY VIRTUE OF THEIR SIGNING UP FOR UNIVERSITY. http://sl4.org/crocker.html http://sl4.org/crocker.html If scientific facts (so-called "HateFacts", think Evolutionary Psychology) offend you, it's your problem really.
- pfortuny 12y agoAt the same time, if factual acts (like the teachings of a religion concerning human acts) offend you, it's your problem really. The thing goes in all directions.
- pjc50 12y agoEvolutionary psychology should be careful about what it elevates to scientific "fact", because quite a lot of it as quoted by people seems to be just-so stories with no hard evidence. The "interpretation of archeological artefacts" kind of science is a lot less durable than the "reproducible double-blind experiment" kind.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]