3 ms·
Two potential effects, one is that as more people reach the cutoff level to down vote they do, and two as people grow the community, opinions about what should
by ChuckMcM 12y ago
Two potential effects, one is that as more people reach the cutoff level to down vote they do, and two as people grow the community, opinions about what should merit a down vote evolves.
Some services use up/down votes strictly for 'like it'/'didn't like it' others are more nuanced. Might be nice to add an interstitial for 'new' downvoters to check their understanding of the intent but I don't imagine it will change.
- AceJohnny2 12y ago> Some services use up/down votes strictly for 'like it'/'didn't like it' Yeah, this is what I really hope HN can avoid, which is why I brought the topic up. Such a trend can only lead to an echo chamber effect and a community that refuses to be challenged.
- brudgers 12y agoThere are healthy ways the HN community can be challenged. Given that it is a community rather than an individual the domain of challenges are those appropriate for communities in general and the unique aspects of HN in particular. What is and isn't appropriate is a variation of HN's community sentiment toward political topics. Some opinions are meant to foster discussion. Others are meant to invite disagreement or structured with a disregard for that potential. Cargo culting is less if an issue than trolling behavior, in my opinion, and the diversity of ideas I see on HN has increased from the days when mentioning Microsoft in a positive light or Apple in a negative one invited downvotes to grey.