5 ms·
I've noticed a shift to where people downvote if they don't agree with a comment instead of using at it was intended to downvote bad comments. I wonder if comm
by DiabloD3 12y ago
I've noticed a shift to where people downvote if they don't agree with a comment instead of using at it was intended to downvote bad comments.
I wonder if comment downvoting needs further restrictions; I'm tired of having to make "I don't know why parent is getting downvoted" type comments to get people to reconsider downvoting.
- BorisMelnik 12y agoFully agree with this. I've responded and disagreed with a number of active discussions, all backed up with data or sound reasoning & eloquently written only to find that my responses were downvoted. I was always of the understanding that down voting was to discourage things that were against HN policy, comments that lacked content, etc.
- zxcvcxz 12y agoMaybe if people were given a set amount of downvotes they could use per day it might make them think more before using them? And maybe they could "earn" more downvote power by receiving upvotes, this could create incentive for downvoters to reply to the people they're downvoting in an attempt to get upvotes to use for further downvoting.
- krapp 12y agoUnfortunately, pg said downvoting for disagreement is perfectly acceptable, so it's probably not going away. However, complaining about being downvoted is against the rules, so you're just expected to swallow it. If you're using Firefox and are a bit tired of unpopular comments being blotted out to spare you the indigity of reading them, here is a small userscript that fixes this "feature." https://gist.github.com/kennethrapp/5b5e413220afb93c9c93 https://gist.github.com/kennethrapp/5b5e413220afb93c9c93
- tzs 12y ago> Unfortunately, pg said downvoting for disagreement is perfectly acceptable, so it's probably not going away Even Homer nods. Pg blew that one. He said: I think it's ok to use the up and down arrows to express agreement. Obviously the uparrows aren't only for applauding politeness, so it seems reasonable that the downarrows aren't only for booing rudeness. If the down arrows merely did the opposite of the up arrows on comments, and so moved the comment farther down the page, then he'd have a good point. However, as soon as a comment goes non-positive (which will happen if the very first person to vote on it votes down), the color is changed to make it harder to read, and the more it goes down, the harder it gets to read. If down votes are used for mere expression of disagreement, this means that if a topic is at all controversial it only takes a bit of bad luck to have your comment seen first by a few people who disagree, and then it is so sunk that people can't read it, and the people who would have up voted and brought it back to visibility never see it. When I read HN on mobile, sometimes I cannot follow the conversation on controversial but interesting topics because so many of the comments are greyed out. When I get back to my desktop (where I override the HN stylesheet to mark those comments in a different way that doesn't make them hard to read), I invariably find that a large fraction of the greyed out comments were well written and valuable contributions to the discussion. Because of that, several times I've refrained from participating in threads that I thought were going to be controversial.
- krapp 12y ago>Several times I've refrained from participating in threads that I thought were going to be controversial. I kind of suspect that's the intended effect.
- brudgers 12y agoDownvotes are overloaded. Disagreement is just one of their modes. The overall purpose is to keep HN from being worse. It's an editorial tool for strategic protection of the commons not absolute valuation of each comment.
- DanBC 12y ago> I've noticed a shift to where people downvote if they don't agree with a comment instead of using at it was intended to downvote bad comments. It's not a shift. It was accepted practice for a thousand days before you had this account. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=117171 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=117171
- krapp 12y agoTo be fair, that's an opinion stated by pg, not necessarily a statement of site policy. The opinion of the site's administrator and creator matters, but it isn't incontrovertible.
- yellowapple 12y agoAnd it's still a practice with rather disturbing implications, seeing as how downvoting causes a comment to fade further and further; it implies that dissenting comments (regardless of their validity) are worthy of being silenced.
- DanBC 12y agoLimited numbers of people have the ability to downvote. Everyone with an account has the ability to upvote. When you see a comment that has a single downvote for disagreement you're also seeing a comment that has several thousand logged-in views that didn't want to supply a corrective upvote.
- fsk 12y agoDownvote = "I disagree" is harmful. Over time, it leads to a circlejerk. Downvote should only be for spam or offtopic. Alternatively, have 2 types of downvotes.