3 ms·
s/Statements/laws/; s/Genentech/every company and moneyed interest group ever/; The health care bill was so long that none of the lawmakers who voted on it ha
by InclinedPlane 17y ago
s/Statements/laws/;
s/Genentech/every company and moneyed interest group ever/;
The health care bill was so long that none of the lawmakers who voted on it had time to read it all. Do the math. This congress is one of the most corrupt in quite some time.
- jaiwithani 17y agoCorrelating long bill length with corruption is a fallacy. None of the lawmakers read the whole bill in its technical legal form because it would be an exercise in futility - for virtually any bill, good or bad. It's the nature of our legal system (or any modern, complex legal system) that amending the law (especially in large cases like health care where there is a great deal of law already on the books and about few dozen loosely-related issues are being addressed in one go) that the resulting legal language is going to be confusing except to lawyers reading it very closely. For example, a great deal of the legislation refers to minor changes to existing laws, and hence would require reading those laws as well to read the bill comprehensively. It's sort of like complaining that a program can't be good because the developers never bothered to fully read the binary produced by the compiler. Which is not to say that all legislators don't understand the bill. This is what staffers are for - carefully drafting and reviewing legislation and imparting the meaning of it to their bosses. Incidentally, there is at least one draft of the bill in plain-English form, the Senate Finance Committee bill. The Finance Committee, by tradition, drafts all legislation in legible English, with all members presumably reading the full draft, before handing it off to staffers to translate into legalese. You could argue that all Congressional committees should follow a similar practice, although it's worth noting that in this case the process didn't do much to improve the bill - the Finance Committee version is generally regarded as the least-effective and industry-friendly version of the bill Congress has considered. You can, in fact, "do the math" on this by looking at the projected coverage rates under each plan. The claim that this is the most corrupt congress in some time, while subjective, seems counterintuitive. This Congress is likely to pass finance reform within the next few months, despite that sector making massive contributions to both parties. Additionally, while insurance and pharma have had undue influence over the health care debate, their power is significantly less so than it was during the Medicare Part D legislation passed only a few years ago, in which they successfully got Congress to restrict the government from negotiating on drug prices. While I have many complaints about the honesty, integrity, and effectiveness of the current Congress, I would rank them as significantly better (less bad) than every Bush Congress.