3 ms·
Nope. Note that I didn't say "makes money." Economics isn't about money; it's about utility. Facebook didn't make anyone any money for a very long time—but it s
by derefr 12y ago
Nope. Note that I didn't say "makes money." Economics isn't about money; it's about utility. Facebook didn't make anyone any money for a very long time—but it served a social need for people that they were willing to invest their time and mindshare into.
A stupid idea is one that serves nobody's needs; it has no monetary value, no social value, no value of any kind. Again, Pets.com: it sounds like something that could work on paper, but there's nobody (in 1999) that would be better-served by doing business with it than by ignoring it and doing what they were already doing.
To make this clearer, some "social good" examples might help:
- Food stamps are a smart idea. People in the targeted group are willing to go through the trouble of getting them, for what they get from them; people who can afford food aren't, so they don't. Since they can't be used to buy much other than food, they also aren't a common target for exploiters trying to make a public-handout money pump. The incentives work out.
- Ambulances (under their current model) are a horrendously stupid idea—they bill people extreme amounts for taking them to a hospital, such that the people most in need (the poorest people usually wait the longest before going to a hospital, and are therefore in the worst/most critical condition) are the ones most strongly disincentivized from taking them. The incentives don't work out at all.