3 ms·
>might sound great in some abstract/idealistic sense, but is very obviously not aligned with anyone's incentives You're confusing economic viability - which re
by TheOtherHobbes 12y ago
>might sound great in some abstract/idealistic sense, but is very obviously not aligned with anyone's incentives
You're confusing economic viability - which relies on lowest-common-denominator customer pandering - with broader social value.
The idea that price = social value is a very cynical one, and marginalises and discounts minority interests.
One big problem with the argument is that real innovation often comes from people who live in those fringes, and not from those who live in the middle of the bell curve.
So eliminating that "stupidity" will kill off a lot of sources of future investment and innovation.
E.g. what keeps the music or fashion or web technology markets running: those people who recycle the same ideas over and over, or the "stupid" people who invent new ideas that have no obvious economic value - until they do.
- derefr 12y agoNope. Note that I didn't say "makes money." Economics isn't about money; it's about utility. Facebook didn't make anyone any money for a very long time—but it served a social need for people that they were willing to invest their time and mindshare into. A stupid idea is one that serves nobody's needs; it has no monetary value, no social value, no value of any kind. Again, Pets.com: it sounds like something that could work on paper, but there's nobody (in 1999) that would be better-served by doing business with it than by ignoring it and doing what they were already doing. To make this clearer, some "social good" examples might help: - Food stamps are a smart idea. People in the targeted group are willing to go through the trouble of getting them, for what they get from them; people who can afford food aren't, so they don't. Since they can't be used to buy much other than food, they also aren't a common target for exploiters trying to make a public-handout money pump. The incentives work out. - Ambulances (under their current model) are a horrendously stupid idea—they bill people extreme amounts for taking them to a hospital, such that the people most in need (the poorest people usually wait the longest before going to a hospital, and are therefore in the worst/most critical condition) are the ones most strongly disincentivized from taking them. The incentives don't work out at all.