3 ms·
The publishing business and IP laws were alway backward. It doesn't make sense today, it doesn't make sense in the past. There's alway people who scream about
by kiba 17y ago
The publishing business and IP laws were alway backward. It doesn't make sense today, it doesn't make sense in the past.
There's alway people who scream about piracy and censorship and there are alway people who will supply it.
Cheap sheet musics. Banned books. Video tapes. Widespread British literature in America. Pirated poetry in Britain. The movie industry's move to California. The radio. Napster. Bittorrent.
Copyright law has alway been a privelleges of the monopolists. The pirates are simply people who produces and distribute despite the law.
All copyright and patent do is criminalizes the free production, distribution, and entrepeneurship in arts and the science for the alleged benefit of the public, authors, and inventors.
If ye try to criminalize a perfectly good pink act, it shall be a black act, and continues underground.
Also, please don't try to convince me about the morality of giving anyone a living. If an artist starve on the street and he refuse to find another, more fruitful occupation, than it shall be so. If customers do not wishes to buy arts, it shall be so that arts decases altogether.
The customers are kings. All the rages about "right to make a living" is moot when laid at the soverigns. All of prosperity depends on satisifying the customers' subjective preferences and all survival in a free market economy depends on satisfications of customers.
If no one is willing to pay for arts and games, why create it?
- lucumo 17y ago> The pirates are simply people who produces and distribute despite the law. I'll give you "distribute", but "produces" is plain nonsense. If I copy a book to give it to a friend, I'm not "producing" it, I'm "distributing" it. The act of producing was the effort that went into writing it, editing it, typesetting it, etc.
- kiba 17y agoPirates that prints books must "produces" it via their printing press. It depends on the context.