2 ms·
Right - but you aren't allowed to do that under any theory of Law that I've ever heard. Copyright law explicitly prohibits you from duplicating and reselling.
by ghshephard 17y ago
Right - but you aren't allowed to do that under any theory of Law that I've ever heard. Copyright law explicitly prohibits you from duplicating and reselling. If Pystar had wanted to do this legally, they could have sold X86 Computer and a retail package of OS X that they purchased from Apple bundled together. First Sale Doctrine would have allowed them to resell the retail copy of the software.
Let's not argue the hypothetical what Pystar was "willing" do do - they were actually making duplicates of OS X, modding it, and then reselling the results.
It was actually a pretty good checklist of what copyright law prohibits you from doing.
[edit - Ah. I reread your statement - I see that you are saying that Psystar wanted _limited_ rights to duplicate, modify, and resell - with the understanding that they would pay Apple the retail price for each copy they made. ]